tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post3586923862165972938..comments2024-03-29T12:32:42.861+01:00Comments on Law 5 - The Referee: 2019-20 UEFA Champions League - Third qualifying round (Second Legs)Law5TheRefhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/12274952933938429751noreply@blogger.comBlogger92125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-89588664270101113312019-08-17T17:33:40.245+02:002019-08-17T17:33:40.245+02:00RF, after having covered all games (if I'm not...RF, after having covered all games (if I'm not wrong) let me thank you again. Your work is excellent. Please find below the two potential penalty incidents in Porto - Krasnodar (thank to your notes):<br /><br />4'<br />I think assessed by AR2, quite difficult if not impossible for referee, teamwork.<br />https://streamable.com/mhaz5<br /><br /><br />75'<br />Ok PLAY ON, but maybe even simulation? Possible YC?<br />https://streamable.com/qtn14Chefrenhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09540069165794069444noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-82555158844463995122019-08-17T13:48:00.779+02:002019-08-17T13:48:00.779+02:00CELTIC vs CFR 1907 CLUJ
Andris Treimanis (Latvia)...CELTIC vs CFR 1907 CLUJ <br />Andris Treimanis (Latvia) 7.9<br /><br />(-) 07.40 Missed penalty for CFR. Careless tackle.<br /><br />26.23 (0-1 CFR)<br /><br />34.34 CFR 99 should receive yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />35.00 CEL possible penalty situation for handball. Correct play on.Natural position.<br /><br />39.03 CFR 99 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />40.31 CEL 33 yellow card for SPA.<br /><br />41.40 Player has already yellow card.But Only DFK correct decision.Careless foul.<br /><br />50.02 (1-1 CEL)<br /><br />60.26 (2-1 CEL)<br /><br />62.10 CFR 10 yellow card for dissent.<br /><br />(+) 71.40 Correct penalty decision for (CFR) handball.(2-2 CFR).<br /><br />75.05 (3-2 CEL)<br /><br />79.55 (3-3 CFR)<br /><br />87.05 CFR GK yellow card for time wasting.<br /><br />87.55 Quick free-kick should be retaken instead of throw-in decision.<br /><br />96.06 (3-4 CFR) Correct goal decision no offside.RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-56826922352768137402019-08-17T13:12:20.243+02:002019-08-17T13:12:20.243+02:00PORTO vs KRASNODAR
Marco Guida (Italy) 8.4
02.00 ...PORTO vs KRASNODAR<br />Marco Guida (Italy) 8.4<br /><br />02.00 (0-1 KRA)<br /><br />03.32 FCP possible penalty situation for handball. Play on correct decision. Arm stick to body. Ball comes to chest.<br /><br />11.45 (0-2 KRA)<br /><br />33.20 (0-3 KRA)<br /><br />38.00 KRA 77 yellow card for tactical foul.<br /><br />44.41 KRA 52 yellow card for SPA.<br /><br />51.52 FCP 11 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />56.20 (1-3 FCP)<br /><br />60.16 FCP 16 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />74.45 KRA possible penalty situation.Correct play on.No contact.<br /><br />75.50 (2-3 FCP)<br /><br />80.59 KRA 89 yellow card for tactical foul.<br /><br />94.00 FCP 20 and KRA 5 yellow card after mass-confrontation.<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-33784649597849762302019-08-17T07:46:11.574+02:002019-08-17T07:46:11.574+02:00AJAX vs PAOK
Craig Pawson (England) 8.6
22.40 (1...AJAX vs PAOK <br />Craig Pawson (England) 8.6<br /><br />22.40 (1-0 PAOK)<br /><br />25.00 AJAX 21 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />(+) 29.40 Correct penalty decision for AJAX.Penalty missed.<br /><br />(+) 40.50 Correct penalty decision for (AJAX) handball. (1-1 AJAX).<br /><br />49.40 PAOK 7 yellow card for reckless.<br /><br />53.40 PAOK GK yellow card for dissent.<br /><br />59.40 AJAX 28 yellow card for tactical foul.<br /><br />64.03 PAOK 23 yellow card for reckless tackle (The card shown after the advantage).<br /><br />77.20 AJAX possible penalty situation. Both players hold each other.<br /><br />78.10 (2-1 AJAX )<br /><br />(-) 80.40 Missed yellow card for AJAX 9 illegal use of arm.<br /><br />(+) 83.00 Correct penalty decision in favour of AJAX. PAOK 3 yellow card (3-1 AJAX).<br /><br />93.00 (3-2 PAOK) AJAX GK yellow card for unsporting behaviour.<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-62459707558476775982019-08-16T15:21:22.515+02:002019-08-16T15:21:22.515+02:00OLYMPIAKOS vs MEDIPOL BASAKSEHIR
Robert Madden (S...OLYMPIAKOS vs MEDIPOL BASAKSEHIR <br />Robert Madden (Scotland) 8.5<br /><br />34.52 Incorrect play on decision.Offside decision should be given(AR1)...OGSO situation.<br /><br />35.24 BAS 44 yellow card for tactical foul.<br /><br />54.18 (1-0 OLY)<br /><br />57.55 OLY 3 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />61.05 BAS 3 yellow card for holding-SPA.<br /><br />69.30 OLY goal correctly disallowed for offside (AR1).<br /><br />69.50 OLY 14 yellow card for SPA.<br /><br />74.30 Possible penalty situation for handball(BAS).Unexpected ball,natural arm.Correct play on.<br /><br />(+) 76.15 Correct penalty decision for OLY. (2-0 OLY)<br /><br />81.40 BAS 80 should receive yellow card for reckless - Step on foot.<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-60495398517299867442019-08-16T15:07:36.985+02:002019-08-16T15:07:36.985+02:00LINZER ASK vs BASEL 1893
Əliyar Ağayev (Azerbaijan...LINZER ASK vs BASEL 1893<br />Əliyar Ağayev (Azerbaijan) 7.8<br /><br />03.40 LASK 7 should receive yellow card.<br /><br />(-) 36.58 Missed penalty for BAS.Goalkeeper should receive yellow card for reckless tackle.Referee decision was play on.<br />Referee should’ve been <br />thought GK touched the ball but he wasn’t.<br /><br />50.30 LASK 26 yellow card for holding.<br /><br />58.50 (1-0 LASK)<br /><br />62.40 BASEL 14 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />(-) 77.30 Missed yellow card LASK 26 for off the ball offence/holding.<br /><br />79.20 (1-1 BASEL)<br /><br />88.20 (2-1 LASK)<br /><br />93.00 (3-1 LASK)RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-14875266500831364452019-08-14T20:28:22.742+02:002019-08-14T20:28:22.742+02:00Thanks to our user RF, below I can present some cl...Thanks to our user RF, below I can present some clips from selected games:<br /><br />=> Ferencvárosi TC - GNK Dinamo, Ruddy Buquet<br /><br />Full Refereeing Highlights can be found in the link below.<br /><br />https://streamable.com/f5odv<br /><br /><br />=> Qarabağ FK - APOEL FC, Daniel Siebert<br /><br />30.30 APO 10 yellow card for reckless challenge.<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=49m42s<br /><br />(+) 32.40 Correct penalty for APO (tripping) (0-1 APO).<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=51m58s<br /><br />36.50 QAR 5 should receive yellow card for reckless tackle.<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=56m8s<br /><br />63.00 QAR 4 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=1h39m10s<br /><br />67.20 (0-2 APO)<br /><br />90.20 QAR 20 yellow card for holding. APO 11 yellow card for dissent?<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=2h6m21s<br /><br />92.55 QAR 20 received (second) yellow card for SPA.<br />https://vk.com/video-175468074_456239224?t=2h8m54sMikael Whttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05362465559010649548noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-89992488314799401102019-08-14T18:41:25.922+02:002019-08-14T18:41:25.922+02:00ROSENBORG vs MARIBOR
Serdar Gözübüyük (Netherlands...ROSENBORG vs MARIBOR<br />Serdar Gözübüyük (Netherlands) 8.3<br /><br />02.00 RBK 8 should receive yellow card for illegal use of arm.Referee didn’t whistle for a foul<br /><br />16.00 RBK 25 yellow card for holding<br /><br />38.50 RBK 8 yellow card for reckless tackle<br /><br />45+1 (0-1 MAR)<br /><br />53.00 (1-1 RBK)<br /><br />60.10 (2-1 RBK)<br /><br />(-) 71.55 Missed yellow card MAR 10 holding.<br /><br />80.20 (3-1 RBK) <br /><br />90.55 MAR goal disallowed.The ball comes outside after the corner kick was taken.(No clear replay) (AR2).<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-58103592420144329732019-08-14T18:38:48.924+02:002019-08-14T18:38:48.924+02:00KOBENHAVN vs CRVENA ZVEZDA
Gediminas Mažeika (Lit...KOBENHAVN vs CRVENA ZVEZDA <br />Gediminas Mažeika (Lithuania)<br />7.4<br /><br />(-) 00.35 Missed penalty for CZV and missed yellow card for FCK 10.<br /><br />05.25 CZV 19 yellow card for illegal use of arm.<br /><br />16.50 (0-1 CZV)<br /><br />26.40 FCK 14 yellow card for illegal use of arm.CZV goalkeeper yellow card for dissent?<br /><br />36.55 CZV 26 yellow card for step on foot.<br /><br />44.00 (1-1 FCK)<br /><br />52.45 Correctly disallowed CZV goal for offside (AR1).<br /><br />53.20 CZV 19 received correct (second) yellow card for illegal use of arm.<br /><br />57.25 CZV 14 should receive yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />79.50 FCK 2 yellow card for delay the restart of the game.<br /><br />87.50 FCK 16 yellow card tactical foul.<br /><br />106.50 FCK yellow card for dissent.<br /><br />109.40 CZV 10 yellow card for not respecting 9.15 meters before the corner kick is taken.<br /><br />(-) 109.55 Missed penalty for FCK (handball).<br /><br />111.30 Missed clear foul just outside of penalty area.<br /><br />111.50 FCK 16 received (second) yellow card and sent off for holding offence.<br /><br />Penalties CZV.RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-63353940251944190722019-08-14T17:59:55.843+02:002019-08-14T17:59:55.843+02:002 RC's from Bbek's match are around 2:06.
...2 RC's from Bbek's match are around 2:06.<br /><br />https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsGjfItyubkMhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12602730142951547472noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-21781669156388308822019-08-14T14:25:28.803+02:002019-08-14T14:25:28.803+02:0094' Great no offside call by AR during last Br...94' Great no offside call by AR during last Brugge's goal.Mhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00432451363345051380noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-84564886122255786612019-08-14T12:00:11.295+02:002019-08-14T12:00:11.295+02:00QARABAG vs APOEL
Daniel Siebert (Germany)
8.5
30....QARABAG vs APOEL<br />Daniel Siebert (Germany)<br />8.5<br /><br />30.30 APO 10 yellow card for reckless challenge.<br /><br />(+) 32.40 Correct penalty for APO (tripping) (0-1 APO).<br /><br />36.50 QAR 5 should receive yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />63.00 QAR 4 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />67.20 (0-2 APO)<br /><br />90.20 QAR 20 yellow card for holding. APO 11 yellow card for dissent?<br /><br />92.55 QAR 20 received (second) yellow card for SPA.<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-38139286506523787982019-08-14T07:43:22.517+02:002019-08-14T07:43:22.517+02:00DYNAMO KYIV vs CLUB BRUGGE
Ivan Bebek (Croatia) 7....DYNAMO KYIV vs CLUB BRUGGE<br />Ivan Bebek (Croatia) 7.9<br /><br />05.00 (1-0 DYN)<br /><br />08.45 BRU 35 yellow card for dissent.Referee could avoid this yellow card by giving strong verbal warning.<br /><br />21.40 BRU 77 yellow card for reckless tackle.Referee could manage the situation without showing yellow card .<br /><br />37.25 (1-1 BRU)<br /><br />49.20 (2-1 DYN)<br /><br />54.15 DYN 16 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />56.10 DYN 44 yellow card for holding.<br /><br />59.40 DYN 26 yellow card for handball/SPA.<br /><br />77.55 BRU 14 yellow card for step on leg.No red card for me because no brutality.<br /><br />(+) 81.15 Correct (second) yellow card and sent off for SPA (DYN 26)<br /><br />(-) 83.00 BRU 35 received (second) yellow card and sent off for foul on GK. IMO yellow card was not needed. It had to be only DFK.<br /><br />85.00 BRU 20 yellow card for dissent.<br /><br />87.40 (2-2 BRU)<br /><br />92.15 (3-2 DYN)<br /><br />94.55 (3-3 BRU) BRU 80 yellow card for taking shirt off/goal celebration.<br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-75108364738135488022019-08-14T07:40:48.749+02:002019-08-14T07:40:48.749+02:00FERENCVAROSI vs GNK DINAMO
Ruddy Buquet (France) 8...FERENCVAROSI vs GNK DINAMO<br />Ruddy Buquet (France) 8.4<br /><br />15.30 (0-1 DZG)<br /><br />23.15 FTC 17 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />25.00 DZG 5 yellow card for reckless foul.<br /><br />27.05 DZG 8 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />(-) 36.30 Missed yellow card (FTC 33) for reckless tackle.<br /><br />46.20 (0-2 DZG)<br /><br />54.20 (0-3 DZG)<br /><br />57.40 FTC 17 should receive (second) yellow card for reckless foul.(Not a black and white mistake).<br /><br />67.50 FTC 17 received (second) yellow card and sent off for illegal use of arm.Even I don’t agree with this one but supportable call IMO.<br /><br />78.15 (0-4 DZG)<br /><br />(+) 87.30 Correct penalty was given for (DZG) tripping.Penalty missed.<br /><br />90.10 DZG 10 yellow card for reckless tackle.<br /><br />RFhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13051777305664066882noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-87579250897815849982019-08-14T01:33:26.090+02:002019-08-14T01:33:26.090+02:00Highlights of Craig Pawson's performance in Aj...Highlights of Craig Pawson's performance in Ajax - PAOK<br /><br />https://vk.com/video424113568_456239050Euro Soccer Refhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15901062602280003219noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-48259658068744333582019-08-14T00:16:51.752+02:002019-08-14T00:16:51.752+02:00I would like to see Skomina in Young Boys-Crvena z...I would like to see Skomina in Young Boys-Crvena zvezda! Kuipers, Turpin, Oliver, Rocchi, Hategan also, but not Kassai please.Nolehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02146505705074134668noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-88173568564240237102019-08-14T00:12:02.340+02:002019-08-14T00:12:02.340+02:00Play-Off predictions (VAR in brackets):
APOEL-Ajax...Play-Off predictions (VAR in brackets):<br />APOEL-Ajax: Orsato (Irrati) / del Cerro Grande (Hernandez)<br />Linz-Brugge: Hategan (Gil Manzano) / Skomina (Zwayer)<br />Cluj-Slavia: Turpin (Letexier) / Taylor (Attwell)<br />Olympiacos-Krasnodar: Zwayer (Dankert) / Kuipers (Makkelie)<br />Zagreb-Rosenborg: Cakir (Marciniak) / Brych (Dingert)<br />Bern-Crvena Zvedza: Kassai (van Boekel) / Rocchi (Guida)Philipp Shttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17241731897712166394noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-32703290345989745212019-08-14T00:10:53.457+02:002019-08-14T00:10:53.457+02:00well..his performance in the last 20 minutes was t...well..his performance in the last 20 minutes was too passive. He lacked personality on the pitch. One or two RC missing for bad tackles and bad behaviour. He lacked authority..The third penalty was indeed soft. A mark higher than 8 but definitely less than 8.3john stavhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08403729406390586953noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-43892229886166835302019-08-13T23:56:56.750+02:002019-08-13T23:56:56.750+02:00I forgot: one possible penalty missed for Kobenhav...I forgot: one possible penalty missed for Kobenhavn in the second half for handball (Zvezda player was slightly pushed and the ball hit his stretched arm or shoulder). In second overtime the ball touched Zvezda player's arm (just a small touch), but it was close distance, unexpected ball which went out and referee didn't even give a corner kick (it should be only corner kick - wasn't enough for PK).Nolehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02146505705074134668noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-15515111876083980722019-08-13T23:51:24.377+02:002019-08-13T23:51:24.377+02:00https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=5&...https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=5&v=vV0TZHaKvSk<br />Missed penalty in 1st minute.Nolehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02146505705074134668noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-48835358959428632019-08-13T23:47:39.069+02:002019-08-13T23:47:39.069+02:00Mazeika - what to say?! Very challenging match for...Mazeika - what to say?! Very challenging match for him. Several good and several bad decisions. First of all, missed clear penalty in 1st minute. Both RC were correct (two 2nd YCs, all YCs were correct). But, he gave cautions for Zvezda players for small protests. One, maybe two can be called dissent - the rest were small protests, talking to him (I believe that Cakir would give maybe 1 YC in total for "dissent"). All of them occured because he didn't whistle fouls or out for Zvezda. Mazeika refused to talk with players - he decided everything to solve with the cards. I dislike that approach. Mostly after his small mistakes he gave yellow cards for small protests. Furthermore, he missed foul in very dangerous situation for Zvezda close to PK area in 1st overtime, and in 2nd overtime missed also clear foul for Kobenhavn at 17 meters from the goal (and he was very close, strange that he didn't see it). At the penalty shoutout, after first Zvezda penalty, Kobenhavn goalkeeper was jumping, strongly shaked the bar and player hit the bar from the penalty. I don't know whether this is by the rules (before 3rd penalty, he warn goalkeeper not to do the same, but to stay on the line!!! All in all, one important mistake, at least 6-7 smaller mistakes (two of them important), correct RCs - for me not more than 7,8.Nolehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02146505705074134668noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-52032279991526972022019-08-13T23:44:54.723+02:002019-08-13T23:44:54.723+02:003 penaltys cant be 8.0, more like 8.6 if everythin...3 penaltys cant be 8.0, more like 8.6 if everything is correct.Mlackohttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11863238477859134319noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-88933454492993252892019-08-13T23:22:44.998+02:002019-08-13T23:22:44.998+02:00I would say that the third penalty was a bit soft....I would say that the third penalty was a bit soft. Not wrong though. Generally good performance with points to improve in how to handle the last 20 min of a tense game. I wpuld give him 8.0-8-2 considering how challenging the match was.john stavhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08403729406390586953noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-71373630882187722482019-08-13T23:18:51.680+02:002019-08-13T23:18:51.680+02:00Please can anyone give me the link to watch the aj...Please can anyone give me the link to watch the ajax vs paok referee clips.....<br /><br /><br />And how will you rate pawson on a scale of 10-100...Jafhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14271170544299431373noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3596681196436096141.post-59218199171789443172019-08-13T22:59:44.171+02:002019-08-13T22:59:44.171+02:00Missed penalty for Crvena Zvezda in 1st minute. Missed penalty for Crvena Zvezda in 1st minute. Mlackohttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11863238477859134319noreply@blogger.com