Appointments of match officials at 2025 FIFA Club World Cup, Group Stage, MD3.
 |
| The list of all selected officials |
Group Stage, MD3
Group B
Monday 23 June 2025, 21:00 CET
Rose Bowl, Los Angeles
Monday 23 June 2025, 21:00 CET
Rose Bowl, Los Angeles
Atlético Madrid (ESP) - Botafogo (BRA)
Referee: César Ramos MEX
Assistant Referee 1: Alberto Morin MEX
Assistant Referee 2: Marco Bisguerra MEX
Fourth Official: Gustavo Tejera URU
Assistant Referee 2: Marco Bisguerra MEX
Fourth Official: Gustavo Tejera URU
Video Assistant Referee:
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:
Support Video Assistant Referee:
Group B
Monday 23 June 2025, 21:00 CET
Lumen Field, Seattle
Monday 23 June 2025, 21:00 CET
Lumen Field, Seattle
Seattle Sounders (USA) - Paris Saint Germain (FRA)
Referee: Cristian Garay CHI
Assistant Referee 1: Miguel Rocha CHI
Assistant Referee 2: Jose Retamal CHI
Fourth Official: Campbell-Kirk Kawana-Waugh NZL
Assistant Referee 2: Jose Retamal CHI
Fourth Official: Campbell-Kirk Kawana-Waugh NZL
Video Assistant Referee:
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:
Support Video Assistant Referee:
Group A
Tuesday 24 June 2025, 03:00 CET
MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford
Tuesday 24 June 2025, 03:00 CET
MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford
FC Porto (POR) - Al Ahly (EGY)
Referee: Jesus Valenzuela VEN
Assistant Referee 1: Jorge Urrego VEN
Assistant Referee 2: Tulio Moreno VEN
Fourth Official: Omar Al Ali UAE
Video Assistant Referee:
Assistant Referee 2: Tulio Moreno VEN
Fourth Official: Omar Al Ali UAE
Video Assistant Referee:
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:
Support Video Assistant Referee:
Group A
Tuesday 24 June 2025, 03:00 CET
Hard Rock Stadium, Miami
Tuesday 24 June 2025, 03:00 CET
Hard Rock Stadium, Miami
Inter Miami (USA) - Palmeiras (BRA)
Referee: Szymon Marciniak POL
Assistant Referee 1: Tomasz Listkiewicz POL
Assistant Referee 2: Adam Kupsik POL
Fourth Official: Michael Oliver ENG
Assistant Referee 2: Adam Kupsik POL
Fourth Official: Michael Oliver ENG
Video Assistant Referee:
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:
Support Video Assistant Referee:
After Ramos appointment, one should stop to follow the tournament...
ReplyDeleteHe makes the games entertaining. For football fans it creates great matches. As a referee he isn't helping us. But since he has no management at all it means any game can get completely out of hand.
DeleteIt's either a total sacrifice on an impossible match OR, as I said in the other thread, you might as well pencil Ramos in for the WC Final next year.
DeleteI don’t really understand option 2. How would this appointment relate to next year’s WC final? If so, which I don’t believe, wouldn’t it be far more sensible to keep him out of the spotlights in this tournament?
DeleteI'm assuming it's impossible for a performance to be rejected in this competition... Garay wasn't great, but Ramos... Surely it's better to break the confederation neutrality earlier, then it becomes less of a story when it inevitably happens later on
DeleteIt's a bit of hyperbole @Unknown.
DeleteBut the point would be that Ramos can do no wrong in FIFA's eyes. He's already had a semifinal. And, politically, after the 2006-2022 UEFA/CONMEBOL domination, it could be time to see a referee from a third confederation. Plus it's a home WC for Mexico.
I think we'd all be foolish to believe he isn't in consideration for that match next year, despite our near collective analysis on his abilities. Obviously, I hope I'm wrong.
Wow,speechless.
DeleteYou can have performance as he had in BOC-BEN,you wont be punished.
Bravo Fifa,excellent.
Teachincg refs that being lenient,forgiving everything and letting everything go is the way to go.
Mobbing and aggressive attitude towards the ref is acceptable and that's the way Fifa views his style.
I was excepting he would get another match,but match of this magnitude???
Decider and almost similar in terms of passion?????
Jezz.
Then we can also not exclude Kovacs for some important matches,but he is different, he punishes dissent and that's not how Fifa wants it.
To see Ramos again in this match is as disgusting as absurd.
DeleteAssuming how Atlético always behaves, plus what Botafogo showed yesterday, and Ramos' style... this has only one word: COMPLETE DISASTER. (I hope not but it's going to be a very difficult/impossible game from minute 1)
ReplyDelete37' Salman Falahi - Di Maria.
ReplyDeleteYet another chapter of allowing everything to players...
Good to see the Qatari ref standing up to the dissent by Di Maria in Orlando
ReplyDeleteCorrect foul given on the gk to disallow a benfica goal. May have been offside too
ReplyDeleteYes, correct foul, also offside. And good job by Falahi to delay his whistle until the ball was in the goal, just in case.
Delete43', I have a feeling the Qatari referee whistled exactly when ball was entering the net, maybe for a foul? But I think he was lucky because there was also offside before (quick VAR check, but no signals by referee to understand what he had punished...).
ReplyDeleteI watched it again; at least on my broadcast, the whistle was well after the ball was in.
DeleteYes, he whistled with ball in the net and punished the foul on keeper, but there was offside before. VAR simply confirmed the decision.
DeleteVery forceful message from the medic to the referee as they are going through the head injury protocol. And now what is following from the player, wow...
ReplyDeleteRemarkable from that player. I actually think that reaction is reason enough to not let him back on
DeleteBased on his reaction there was no way he did not have a concussion. It was not a regular reaction in any way.
DeleteGood yc for dissent by action for the kicking of the ball in frustration. Now a correct penalty
ReplyDeletehttps://streamin.me/v/667e40f9
ReplyDeleteCorrect decision. Missing YC for reckless?
Apparently what it takes to get a yellow card for dissent at this tournament is kicking the ball at the referee from 30 yards away. At least we know there IS a line!
ReplyDeleteManagement in first half:
ReplyDelete37' Reaction to Di Maria dissent. At UEFA level, this is a clear YC and player is at the border of RC. Aggressive approach against referee, unacceptable. You can positively observe the body language of the Qatari, but on a scale of tolerating dissent, this is still a medium reaction. It's a YC missing. But I think we can't ask for more at this tournament.
https://streambug.org/cv/ae38b1
45'+4 YC for kicking ball (against referee? unsure) from a certain distance, but surely frustration
https://streambug.org/cv/f42a30
Am I the only one getting totally annoyed by all the adverse weather suspensions? I cannot remember we experienced this so often in past bigger tournaments.
ReplyDeleteMaybe FIFA should choose a host for next year's WC, where it is possible to play a game of football in June. ;)
DeleteIf this is the standard of suspension in MLS, well, US fans can't definitely complain about VAR breaking up the flow of the game. They have definitely something "bigger" doing it very often...
DeleteFrom an American fan: this is definitely a lot more weather delays than normal. Usually in the summer we have delays for some games in Florida every now and then, but not every matchday like we are seeing. That region is very prone to thunderstorms on summer evenings. Delays in Cincinnati and New York would be pretty rare, though.
DeleteI can't understand how Carreras intentionally kicking the ball to the referee isn't a straight RC instead of just a YC. At least here in ESP everyone would expect a RC.
ReplyDeleteFrom that distance, there can be an element of doubt about whether the ball was meant to be kicked directly at the referee, or just in the general direction of the penalty area in frustration.
DeleteIvan Barton has definitely good skills.
ReplyDeleteI’m not sure that foul was reckless, but absolutely correct in his management of the situation
DeleteThe Salvadoran referee has a certain demeanor when calling a foul and he makes some gestures that reminds me of Byron Moreno, but of course only in that regard.
ReplyDeleteI thought about that, too. But he really impressed and convinced me, not the first time, btw.
DeleteI don't dislike Barton, but there is certainly an element of theatre. Not sure it really helps to calm things with an English team. He does seem more in control than many Americas officials have been
ReplyDeleteWhat you're seeing are the left-over remnants of CONCACAF under Brian Hall's control. Where referees were encouraged (expected) to be "actors" on the pitch. It meant, an excessive amount of gesturing and posturing with no actual refereeing qualities.
DeleteI think you are completely missing the mark if you believe Barton is a product of Hall. Like, not even close.
DeleteEscobar, yes. Escobar is the model that Hall wanted to create and push.
But Escobar and Barton are like night and day for refereeing. They could not be more different.
Clement Turpin is fourth official between Mamelodi Sundowns - Borussia Dortmund
ReplyDeleteRamos + Botafogo aggressiveness/dissent + Atletico attitude/gamesmanship + possible must win for both teams = complete and utter DISASTER!!!
ReplyDeleteIt saddens me to see that CONCACAF has fallen this low in terms of referees. With all due respect to these other confederations. CONCACAF is at or below to AFC/CAF levels. Only above OFC!
But it comes as no surprise with Mexican referees. As I've witnessed the steady deterioration/decline under the disastrous/draconian mandate of Benito Armando Archundia.
Wow,speechless.
DeleteYou can have performance as he had in BOC-BEN,you wont be punished.
Bravo Fifa,excellent.
Teachincg refs that being lenient,forgiving everything and letting everything go is the way to go.
Mobbing and aggressive attitude towards the ref is acceptable and that's the way Fifa views his style.
I was excepting he would get another match,but match of this magnitude???
Decider and almost similar in terms of passion?????
Jezz.
Then we can also not exclude Kovacs for some important matches,but he is different, he punishes dissent and that's not how Fifa wants it.
Maybe he will change his approach for this game,but I dont think so.
DeleteHe's unable to. He can only be worse.
DeleteGreat two onside decisions by Pupiro on the 1-1 goal in Flamengo vs Chelsea
ReplyDeleteAnd another for the 2nd goal though it was a bit easier
DeleteWOW what a quick red card...
ReplyDeleteAnd top decision by Barton
DeleteGreat red card decision and very well managed in front of the technical areas
ReplyDeleteIt is true that the referee from El Salvador has a rather "chaotic" style, but definitely skills of a big talent.
ReplyDeleteExactly. I think in the first half his demeanor was very risky, potentially even inflammatory at times (see: the first yellow card of the match, 11'). But in other moments that needed a big personality (YC in first half added time, red card to Jackson), he really shines.
DeleteFor Barton I think the one improvement I was would is for him to develop more nuance: instead of being at 100% energy, super high intensity all the time, being able to slow himself down when his default energy is counterproductive.
Still, this has been a very good performance by Barton so far.
Maybe he was reading my mind... his lower-key reaction to the foul at 90'+4' was exactly what I was looking for (although in theory a yellow card could be justified too).
DeleteSo, you want him to change the style that suits him best and that we've seen him succeed with?
DeleteI can guarantee you that it would be detrimental to him and to his career.
Referees come in all colors, shapes, and sizes. And unsurprisingly, not all of them referee in the same manner. Nor should they be forced to.
Take the "cookie cutter" referee mindset and toss it in the trash bin.
Brilliant spot by Barton. I thought at first that the contact was only on the foot, but very well seen that it started on the shin and raked down, and his immediate presence on the situation diffuses any further tension.
ReplyDeleteI also thought the same until I rewound and watched again. Worth noting that El Salvador has no VAR in their domestic league. Perhaps VAR has caused the skill of recognizing SFP live to atrophy.
Delete@thegreatwar, I've been saying this--your last sentence--for a long time. Maybe not the skill, per se. But the confidence in acting on what you see. I think the fear of being wrong with an affirmative decision weighs on referees; they'd rather be told they missed something via VAR than told they called something wrong.
DeleteAntony Taylor acted otherwise in this tournament. Nut interesting discussion, numbers of on field given SFP red cards before and after VAR should and could be evaluated...
DeleteAnd Taylor might truly be the exception to the rule. I believe we've seen him overturn himself a few times at the monitor on big decisions.
DeleteReferees give SFP red cards before and after VAR was introduced but players are more careful now with VAR.
DeleteExcellent red card decision!
ReplyDeleteAn argument for SFP with that challenge? It trapped the attackers leg
ReplyDeleteBack to Penso, Infantino visited the female trio after Al Ain - Juventus game to congratulate. It seems like a very strong endorsement by FIFA president for the American woman, we will almost certainly see her at the World Cup. Ramos, from her same confederation, is terrible, while Barton from El Salvador is excellent. I haven’t fully assessed the US referee so far, also considering the relatively limited assignments she has been given, but she might be better than Frappart, if we want to make a European comparison. Time will tell. But it's not hard to be the best in CONCACAF in recent times (said with all respect for both her and the others).
ReplyDeleteFrom what I've seen, she's better than Frappart. By a fair bit. I think her inclusion is completely justified
DeleteThere are of course other concacaf referees than the ones mentioned.
DeleteWill be interesting, whether she gets a challenging appointment in this tournament like INT-RIV on MD3 or even a KO match.
DeleteThere are several referees in CONCACAF who do not have the same "support" as those mentioned and, therefore, 0 opportunities... TBH Ramos only for "reputation and name" is present in this tournament, Ortiz is much better (although many do not like his "protagonist" style on the field).
DeleteAnd yes, Penso is much better than Frappart... I have seen an immense number of her games (live/TV) and I don't remember a "disaster"... The charisma she has and the feeling of always having the game under control that she transmits are keys to her success, added to the good decisions she makes in the field… Even Esther Staubli (who for me deserved the opportunities of Frappart and much more in the “male world”), Edina and even Katia Garcia with her level right now, are much better than Frappart.
I'll wait to see Penso and Co in an actual challenging "men's" match, to pass judgement. Let's not kids ourselves. Juventus v Al Ain wasn't exactly Boca v Benfica or PSG v Botafogo.
DeletePenso is better than all the other female international referees insofar as how she performs in men's matches. By far. It's really not close. She's comfortable managing men and overseeing VAR in a way that other female referees just are not.
DeleteThat said, she's considered middle tier in MLS. She's good and I think she deserves more opportunity domestically. But it's not like she's USA's #1 or close. She benefits some from having men's international matches where either the teams want to play or, well, she's superior to the talent on the field (e.g., CONCACAF WCQ before the final round).
So it is worth asking how she'd be tested in a top tier, heated men's match. It's a very open question.
Of course, the fact that you can contemplate giving her such a match at a FIFA event proves she's light-years ahead of Frappart or anyone else. I cannot imagine Frappart, Staubli or Alves with an actual tough men's match in a senior tournament setting.
So the question for me becomes whether or not FIFA just uses Penso twice next year on two lesser-to-mid matches OR if they really start to push her. Her next assignment at CWC should tell us a lot.
I watched some parts of tze 2nd half.
DeleteShe had very bad moment where instead of letting advantage,she whistled and booked Gatti from Juve.
Then,not punishing blatant agressive running and potests towards her form Al Ain.
But looking right now at that,trend is not punishing dissents and mobbing,players can do and say what they want.
When someone like Kovacs does something about that,he is public enemy number 1.
Kovacs had much bigger problems than dealing with dissent. And, yes, when a referee gives out a card for dissent and clearly has no idea the player was already on a yellow, that is a problem--particularly when he could have picked the goalkeeper for the caution, as that dissent was much clearer. Oh, and also the fact that Kovacs mistake let to the whole scene.
DeleteBut we digress. Penso is not perfect. I would also say she possibly missed a DOGSO at 16', which no one seemed to notice or talk about here. That said, no one is putting in perfect performances. I would argue she deserves a difficult match, but given just how challenging some of these MD3 games could be, such an assignment could be more curse than blessing.
+1
DeleteBarton with the best display of the tournament, and in doing so it also became the best football match. Well done!
ReplyDeleteOu est Mr LETEXIER ???
DeleteReserved for Benfica-Bayern, I guess
DeleteFalahi had an OFR for a penalty in extra time. He should have spotted that live as he was in a good position (if anything, maybe too close).
ReplyDeleteSome doubts about Di Maria attitude, from some angles, it can look even a dive or at least he used the contact to fall. But basically, one can understand why VAR called.
DeleteSo, you're telling me that timely, necessary, and well given Yellow and Red cards, actually DON'T "KILL" a match. What an out of this world theory and approach.
ReplyDeleteYet Barton is from CONCACAF. How curious.
DeleteHowever, Barton has shown that unlike other CONCACAF referees. He's adaptable, flexible, and has the ability to adjust his style.
DeleteHe seamlessly goes from domestic Barton to CONCACAF Barton to international Barton. Of course, his worst version being CONCACAF Barton.
I shudder to think how messy and chaotic Barton's Red Card incident would have been. If it had been handled by one of those referees who have to wait and think about Yellow vs Red. The ones who are overly passive and are slow to get to the location of the incident.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure all would have been fine... Waiting and thinking, replaying in the mind, having input from your team, can be a skill too!
DeleteAnd in that time the confrontations, pushing, and shoving amongst players starts. Followed by the inevitable intervention by the coaches and players in the technical area.
DeleteWrong penalty by Eskas, overturned on review and YC given for simulation
ReplyDeleteNow Eskas overturned his penalty decision with VAR.
ReplyDeleteVery eloquently and right to the point said that player fell too easily and also got YC for that.
But then again,mobbing from LA players being not punished is obviously trend at this CWC.
What mobbing, Didn't you hear, there's the Only The Captain rule now, so mobbing doesn't exist anymore :D
DeleteYep,Captain with ref and around ref and captain 50 players 😀😀😀
DeleteJoke of a rule.
The captain rule got forgotten within a month. And already within the first week there have been several per match where the 8-second rule is ignored too.
DeleteCaptain rule,if more than 2 players surround ref automatic YC for someone,time added is not correct every time..
DeleteI could go on and on,but today ever, game had their mobbing the ref moments.
And I think Barton was the only one who delivered great today.
But whole CWC there is trouble with constant pressure and mobbing on ref(Ramos obviously,Penso ,Falahi,Fisher and now Eskas).
I say it,only english refs and english league are dealing with properly,booking every time there is mobbing and booking every time there is game delay.
Marciniak would have been ideal for Atletico-Botafogo.
ReplyDeleteBut given the last couple of months and his decisions where Barca and Spain are blaming him for Barca's loss,that was for sure factor.
Also,maybe they were looking athe confederations neutrality.
But then again,anyone but Ramos.
Botafogo is already used to leniency and forgiving dissents,so nothing new for them.
Atletico will now see how one ref can be different from other(Ramos-Kovacs).
I'm sure they will like it Ramos way more than Kovacs.
Teams like refs who punishes nothing and allows everything.
Ndala appears as A1
ReplyDeleteHmm,should this be YC for going into the crowd?
ReplyDeleteI thought that. But I don’t think Collina would be happy with a second yellow there. Goal was pretty controversial aswell
DeleteI also thought about the 2CT but he didn't actually climb a fence--those stands are quite low. I don't think anyone actually wants a card there and it's not technically required anyway.
DeleteThus, the reason a YC for removing your shirt to celebrate is ridiculous. It's no worse than an entire bench and coaching staff crossing the length of the field to celebrate a goal.
Delete+1
DeleteAnyone else have a foul by the attacker just prior to the Esperance 1-0 goal? The LAFC defender wins the ball and the Esperance attacker trips him. Pretty surprised this goal stands.
ReplyDeleteI'm with you on that one. The LAFC player wins/clears the ball and is then plain and simply taken out by the Esperance player.
DeleteMinute 71 goal for Espérance. There is no way that that's a goal. It's a clear foul. Defender clears the ball and gets completely tackled. Very easy and clear foul but it was allowed.
ReplyDeleteI still couldn't understand how could be this is biggest FIFA tournament if when the referee injured, there's no replacement and force FO (even if he should) to running in the lines that surely he's not running in that line for years.
ReplyDeleteI don't think it was clear and obvious error. I think it was supportable decision by Faghani to allowed the goal, but then he go to the monitor, surely the original decision difficult to stand.
ReplyDeleteIt's not a clear and obvious error, and I'm not entirely convinced its a foul anyway. Goalkeeper has to be stronger. Referee's call should have stood, and I think he should have been stronger and rejected it at the monitor
DeleteThis isn't just not a clear and obvious error, it's not even a foul for me. They're both holding eachother. Completely wrong intervention by Guzmán, and once again it's Faghani who isn't strong enough to reject at the monitor
DeleteCome again? An attacker is deliberately backing into a goalkeeper and pushes him into his own net, thereby preventing him from attempting to play the ball at all.
DeleteThis has been a foul since the dawn of time. I am quite literally shocked that the first three comments on this play here assert it's not a foul. Making this not a foul would change the sport.
Vicario at Tottenham was having this done to him on a weekly basis a year or two ago, and the goal was given everytime. It's not like this always gets given, and certainly not with a VAR getting involved
Delete43'very reckles foul on Kane,Costa shoud have seen yc
ReplyDeleteThere are some positives and negatives in 1st half;
ReplyDeleteSo far Faghani has control,he has that experience and also players that they are dealing with one of the best refs.
This last sequence I dont get it.
Boca player pushes Bayern player,Goretzka,off the ball incident.
Then Goretzka says something and then he's booked.
So in the end of that mini battle,Boca player eon,I dont know if that was Costa
1 clear YC,1 totally missed in 43',rest is ok.
1 minutes of added tim in 1st H after VAR review and moments before that,this whole procedure after 1st canceled goal took some time,atleast 3 minutes..
Then there were some protests throughout 1st half goal scored and you add 1 minute?!No words
https://streamin.me/v/7f2fb07a
ReplyDeleteHere the disallowed goal for foul on keeper. I don't think that Faghani had a good view of the situation, maybe he didn't do any assessment at all. Always difficult situations when keepers are involved, for most of VAR it's impossible to play on. I think that no foul could have been accepted, but how things turned out, made the call mandatory for VAR...
59' Possible second yellow to Advincula
ReplyDeleteLooks like a poor performance by Eskas.
ReplyDeleteFor me, a clear foul before Espérance goal, can't understand why VAR didn't call it. Late and reckless challenge.
About the penalty he whistled and then revoked by VAR, you could be deceived live, but rewatching it's indeed a simulation. Player uses an extremely soft touch to make a big fall. Very evident.
Then in the final minutes, OFR for assigning a penalty: correct again by VAR. Absolutely no discussion.
Really sorry for the Norwegian, very sub standard and maybe he will not get a second game.
For me, foul before Esperance goal is not VAR-stuff. Classic confrontation for the ball between attacker and defender, no particular danger for defender physical integrity ,no influence on goal whatsoever. Would have stood if whistled but not clear and obvious to me.
DeleteProbably the LAFC team needed to massively confront the referee there to get an OFR...
DeleteYep,as we saw with some Europeans and mostly South American teams.
DeleteDisciplinary control somewhat lacking towards the end here. 90'+6' foul against Kane (for the umpteenth time this match) was purely frustration and cynical, should have definitely been a yellow.
ReplyDeleteNevertheless, very good performance by Faghani in a fairly challenging game.
Yep,also moments before reckless foul on Stanisic,also yc material.
DeletePredictions for the last games:
ReplyDeleteAuckland - Boca: Tantashev UZB (maybe Kovacs)
Benfica - Bayern: Turpin FRA
LAFC - Flamengo: Zwayer GER
Espérance - Chelsea: Tello ARG
Inter Milan - River Plate: Barton SLV
Urawa Reds - Monterrey: Taylor ENG
Dortmund - Ulsan HD: Sy SEN
Mamelodi - Fluminense: Letexier FRA
Juventus - City: Makkelie NED
Wydad - Al Ain: Fischer CAN
Al Hilal - Pachuca: Oliver ENG
Salzburg - Real Madrid: Nyberg SWE
Barton in Inter-River Plate is indeed the most predictable appointment.
DeleteI wonder whether Benfica–Bayern might come too early for Turpin. His fourth official assignment in Cincinnati suggests to me that he’s scheduled for a later match in the program. Maybe Juventus–City after his low-key first game.
As for Oliver, he’s the fourth official on Tuesday. I think the plan is for him to move straight to the Round of 16 or quarter-finals after just one group stage match. And I would assign Makkelie to an intercontinental fixture; it suits his style.
I agree on Barton, but it's also possible that he gets a direct R16 game.
DeleteThen maybe Tantashev for INT-RIV - I think, he deserves more than AKL-BOC. So either a good game on MD3 or a direct R16.
If no UEFA referee in AKL-BOC, Penso might also be an option.
WAC-AIN might very well turn out meaningless, so this could be another option for Kovacs (or for Benitez or Beida, if they don't recommend themselves for a R16 today).
If Oliver gets a direct R16 (as his 4th official appointment indeed indicates), Vincic could slot in for one of the games on the last day.
Not sure it was mentioned here, but the Qatari referee awarded a penalty at the end of the first half yesterday. And there was an on-field review for a penalty at the end of the second half. The announcement was, let’s say… “interesting.” :)
ReplyDeleteDiscussed above, here the video of the OFR:
Deletehttps://streambug.org/cv/a1a4f7
I don't understand what referee said.
"Tripped" the opponent?
One can have doubts about the attitude by Di Maria, surely used the contact to fall, but you have the action by defender so call can't be questioned. From some angles, it looks even almost no contact for me.
Yes he said tripped but pronounced it as ”ettrippad”.
DeleteWell, Vincic’s got himself a heavyweight VAR crew. Compare that to some of the other crews we’ve seen in the booth…
ReplyDeleteWell, I must say you are not wrong. The best UEFA crew for the Slovenian, I think in almost all the other games we saw different choices.
DeleteFurther clips from Faghani game (disallowed goal is above in the discussion):
ReplyDelete45'+3 YC for dissent
https://streambug.org/cv/a0eb05
But surely referee missed what had happened before. Clear foul there.
41' Possible YC for reckless
https://streambug.org/cv/36b2ff
I think that the player should have been booked as he was aware to go against opponent in a very late and for me reckless manner, but surely one of these situations where in today refereeing we are used to see differently judged.
59' Possible second YC for reckless arm
https://streambug.org/cv/e52327
And when you see the classic simulation by a player in this situation, aware that opponent is already booked and YC is enough to be sent off, you are happy that referee didn't give it. Under the pure technically point of view at border, one can maybe say that it was still OK to assess careless, but very risy action (in case of face hit with that arm, for me YC).
90'+6 Missed YC for (at least reckless)
https://streambug.org/cv/3a723b
For me, this is the very objective mistake, very cynical given with frustration, the aim must be to protect players.
Once again, if you go to scrutinize everything, you don't find a perfect Faghani but in this case better than previous game for me. It is a pity that some very easy decisions are not taken... but if the previous performance was liked, well, good for him.
Taking advantage of the possible presence of some americans in the forum, do you know if Ismail Elfath is still injured?
ReplyDeleteAm I wrong or did he not ref in 2025 ?
Injured at Copa America 2024. Hasn't worked since. That's why Dickerson is at Gold Cup; he's the backup plan on the male side (presuming Penso is a lock).
DeleteNot to be harsh so early on, but I've found the first 10 minutes from Benitez to be really jarring. Multiple instances (a throw-in, and a handball) where he just didn't signal anything despite players confused with the call, and then in the 9th or 10th minute he made a big deal about the position of the ball on the corner arc, when it was very clear to everyone else that the ball was already on the arc.
ReplyDeleteVincic refereeing a game between an Argentine team and a Mexican team... I'm not confident that the match will be safe, given the Slovenian's inconsistent and insecure way of refereeing. Not to mention that some Latin American teams tend to use catimba as well.
ReplyDeleteBlowing for half time at a corner is just terrible game management
ReplyDeleteBenitez blowing for half time after just allowing a set piece to be set up. Really??
ReplyDeleteNobody does that in modern refereeing anymore...
DeleteVideo:
Deletehttps://streambug.org/cv/118aef
Ball out at 2:40 of added time, 20 seconds before the end (3 minutes).
I think the South American referee didn't like the lazy handling by Borussia Dortmund players. This can be only reason.
They didn’t seem to take excessive time over the corner. He should’ve allowed it to be taken anyway considering the first minute wasn’t played due to a goal
DeleteOh that is terrible management. If it was as soon as the ball went out, understandable, but seeing everything set up like that. Not great
DeleteA decision like that is just asking for negative attention. Shows lack of understanding for refereeing.
Delete35’ missed YC, some may even argue red, for Urawa. Very difficult to see the contact with the Achilles, but still.
ReplyDeleteOther than that, not much to say about Beida so far. Pretty football-focused game that does not ask for too much from a referee. His physical aptitude is, as usual, very impressive, though in some moments, his positioning seems awkward (eg ~38th minute he almost finds himself in a shooting lane, and ~3rd minute perhaps too close to assess a potentially reckless foul).
35' Missed YC, possible RC for SFP.
Deletehttps://streambug.org/cv/0f7878
67' Pretty harsh first caution of the match
DeleteIMO, VAR should've intervened, full studs contact clearly endangering the opponent's safety...
DeleteNormal difficulty game, referee not really challenged, all is about the possible red card in 35'.
Delete