Wednesday, 23 September 2026

FIFA U-20 Women's World Cup Poland 2026 - Referee Appointments

Referee assignments at 2026 FIFA Women's Under-20 World Cup in Poland.  Tournament will be played with VAR, being a crucial event for 2027 FIFA Women's WC preselection. 




GROUP STAGE

MATCHDAY 1

5 September 2026

Group A
POLAND - ARGENTINA
Referee: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Assistant Referee 1: Gabrielle Lemieux CAN
Assistant Referee 2: Mijensa Rensch SUR
Fourth Official: Marianela Araya CRC
Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ
  
Group A
MEXICO - BENIN 
Referee: Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Daniela Costantinescu ROU 
Assistant Referee 2: Irina Pozdejeva LTU
Fourth Official: Silvia Gasperotti ITA 
Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR 

Group B
BRAZIL - TANZANIA
Referee:  Marta Huerta De Aza ESP
Assistant Referee 1: Iragartze Fernández Esesumaga ESP
Assistant Referee 2: Andreia Sousa POR 
Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peşu ROU
Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX

Group B
CANADA - ENGLAND
Referee: Anahí Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 1: Daiana Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 2: Belén Clavijo URU
Fourth Official: Milagros Arruela PER
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE

6 September 2026

Group C
FRANCE - SOUTH KOREA 
Referee: Charly Deretti Straub BRA
Assistant Referee 1: Fernanda Antunes BRA 
Assistant Referee 2: Anne Sá BRA 
Fourth Official: Lizzet Garcia MEX
Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar VEN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX
  
Group C
ECUADOR - GHANA 
Referee: Silvia Gasperotti ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Giulia Tempestilli ITA 
Assistant Referee 2: Svitlana Grushko UKR
Fourth Official: Alyssa Pennington USA
Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA

Group D
JAPAN - NEW ZEALAND
Referee: Twannyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Assistant Referee 1: Diana Chikotesha ZAM
Assistant Referee 2: Carine Atezambong Fomo CMR
Fourth Official: Shamirah Nabadda UGA
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU

Group D
USA - ITALY 
Referee: Casey Reibelt AUS
Assistant Referee 1: Emma Kocbek AUS
Assistant Referee 2: Madelaine Allum AUS
Fourth Official: Dione Rissios CHI
Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV

7 September 2026

Group E
NORTH KOREA - PORTUGAL 
Referee: Milagros Arruela PER 
Assistant Referee 1: Mariana Aquino PER
Assistant Referee 2: Aranza Quero Aguilar MEX
Fourth Official: Anahí Fernández URU
Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:  Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
  
Group E
COSTA RICA - COLOMBIA 
Referee: Kim Yu-jeong KOR
Assistant Referee 1: Heba Saadia PLE 
Assistant Referee 2: Allys Clipsham NZL
Fourth Official: Asaka Koizumi JPN
Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI 

Group F
NEW CALEDONIA - CHINA
Referee: Shamirah Nabadda UGA 
Assistant Referee 1: Fanta Kone MLI 
Assistant Referee 2: Fides Bangourabona BDI
Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peşu ROU
Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga RWA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE 

Group F
SPAIN - NIGERIA
Referee: Marianela Araya CRC 
Assistant Referee 1: Shirley Perelló HON
Assistant Referee 2: Lourdes Noriega HON
Fourth Official:  Lizzet García MEX  
Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL

MATCHDAY 2

8 September 2026

Group A
BENIN - ARGENTINA
Referee: Alyssa Pennington USA 
Assistant Referee 1: Meghan Mullen USA 
Assistant Referee 2: Jassett Kerr-Wilson JAM
Fourth Official: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN
  
Group A
POLAND - MEXICO 
Referee: Anahí Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 1: Daiana Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 2: Belén Clavijo URU
Fourth Official: Charly Deretti Straub BRA 
Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:  Stefani Escobar VEN

Group B
BRAZIL - CANADA
Referee: Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi ITA 
Assistant Referee 1: Paulina Baranowska POL
Assistant Referee 2: Irina Pozdejeva LTU
Fourth Official: Silvia Gasperotti ITA
Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE 

Group B
ENGLAND - TANZANIA 
Referee: Dione Rissios CHI 
Assistant Referee 1: Leslie Vásquez CHI
Assistant Referee 2: Yomara Salazar CHI
Fourth Official: Casey Reibelt AUS 
Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-udom THA

9 September 2026

Group C
GHANA - SOUTH KOREA 
Referee: Ionela Alina Peșu ROU
Assistant Referee 1: Emily Carney ENG
Assistant Referee 2: Heini Hyvönen FIN
Fourth Official: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Video Assistant Referee:  Eszter Urbán HUN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR 
  
Group C
FRANCE - ECUADOR 
Referee: Asaka Koizumi JPN
Assistant Referee 1: Ha Thi Phuong VIE
Assistant Referee 2: Amal Badhafari UAE 
Fourth Official: Twannyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga RWA

Group D
ITALY - NEW ZEALAND
Referee: Lizzet Garcia MEX 
Assistant Referee 1: Aranza Quero MEX
Assistant Referee 2: Fernanda Juarez MEX 
Fourth Official: Marianela Araya CRC 
Video Assistant Referee:  Diana Pérez MEX
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV

Group D
JAPAN - USA
Referee: Marta Huerta De Aza ESP 
Assistant Referee 1: Iragartze Fernández Esesumaga ESP
Assistant Referee 2: Andreia Sousa POR
Fourth Official: Milagros Arruela PER 
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ

10 September 2026

Group E
NORTH KOREA - COSTA RICA
Referee: Silvia Gasperotti ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Giulia Tempestilli ITA 
Assistant Referee 2: Svitlana Grushko UKR
Fourth Official: Dione Rissios CHI
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar VEN
  
Group E
COLOMBIA - PORTUGAL 
Referee: Casey Reibelt AUS
Assistant Referee 1: Emma Kocbek AUS
Assistant Referee 2: Madelaine Allum AUS
Fourth Official: Kim Yu-jeong KOR
Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 

Group F
SPAIN - NEW CALEDONIA
Referee: Twannyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Assistant Referee 1: Diana Chikotesha ZAM
Assistant Referee 2: Carine Atezambong Fomo CMR
Fourth Official: Shamirah Nabadda UGA 
Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga RWA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI 

Group F
CHINA - NIGERIA 
Referee: Charly Deretti Straub BRA
Assistant Referee 1: Fernanda Antunes BRA 
Assistant Referee 2: Anne Sá BRA 
Fourth Official: Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi ITA
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU

MATCHDAY 3

11 September 2026

Group A
BENIN - POLAND
Referee: Milagros Arruela PER 
Assistant Referee 1: Irina Pozdejeva LTU 
Assistant Referee 2: Mariana Aquino PER
Fourth Official: Asaka Koizumi JPN
Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar VEN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
  
Group A
ARGENTINA - MEXICO 
Referee: Shamirah Nabadda UGA
Assistant Referee 1: Fanta Kone MLI 
Assistant Referee 2: Fides Bangurambona BDI
Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peşu ROU
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI

Group B
ENGLAND - BRAZIL
Referee: Alyssa Pennington USA 
Assistant Referee 1: Meghan Mullen USA 
Assistant Referee 2: Jassett Kerr-Wilson JAM
Fourth Official: Lizzet Garcia MEX 
Video Assistant Referee:  Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 

Group B
TANZANIA - CANADA 
Referee: Kim Yu-jeong KOR
Assistant Referee 1: Heba Saadia PLE 
Assistant Referee 2: Allys Clipsham NZL
Fourth Official: Marta Huerta de Aza ESP
Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN

12 September 2026

Group C
GHANA - FRANCE
Referee: Dione Rissios CHI
Assistant Referee 1: Leslie Vásquez CHI
Assistant Referee 2: Yomara Salazar CHI
Fourth Official: Casey Reibelt  AUS
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE

Group C
SOUTH KOREA - ECUADOR 
Referee: Marianela Araya CRC
Assistant Referee 1: Shirley Perelló HON
Assistant Referee 2: Lourdes Noriega HON
Fourth Official: Twannyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ

Group D
ITALY - JAPAN
Referee: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Assistant Referee 1: Gabrielle Lemieux CAN
Assistant Referee 2: Mijensa Rensch  SUR
Fourth Official: Charly Deretti Straub  BRA
Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo  SLV
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU

Group D
NEW ZEALAND - USA 
Referee: Anahí Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 1: Daiana Fernández URU
Assistant Referee 2: Belén Clavijo URU
Fourth Official: Marta Huerta De Aza ESP
Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga RWA

13 September 2026

Group E
COLOMBIA - NORTH KOREA
Referee: Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi ITA 
Assistant Referee 1: Paulina Baranowska POL
Assistant Referee 2: Emily Carney ENG 
Fourth Official: Alyssa Pennington USA
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI  
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN

Group E
PORTUGAL - COSTA RICA 
Referee: Asaka Koizumi JPN
Assistant Referee 1: Ha Thi Phuong VIE
Assistant Referee 2: Amal Badhafari UAE 
Fourth Official:  Kim Yu-jeong KOR
Video Assistant Referee:  Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga RWA 

Group F
CHINA - SPAIN
Referee: Lizzet Garcia MEX 
Assistant Referee 1: Aranza Quero MEX
Assistant Referee 2: Fernanda Juarez MEX 
Fourth Official: Milagros Arruela PER
Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar VEN 

Group F
NIGERIA - NEW CALEDONIA 
Referee: Ionela Alina Peşu ROU
Assistant Referee 1: Daniela Costantinescu ROU 
Assistant Referee 2: Heini Hyvönen FIN
Fourth Official: Charly Deretti Straub BRA 
Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 

ROUND OF 16

16 September 2026

ARGENTINA - SOUTH KOREA 
Referee: Marta Huerta De Aza ESP
Assistant Referee 1: Iragartze Fernández Esesumaga ESP
Assistant Referee 2: Andreia Sousa POR
Fourth Official: Lizzet Garcia MEX
Reserve AR : Fernanda Juarez MEX
Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR

BRAZIL - USA 
Referee: Silvia Gasperotti ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Giulia Tempestilli ITA
Assistant Referee 2: Svitlana Grushko UKR
Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peșu ROU
Reserve AR : Paulina Baranowska POL
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga  RWA

ITALY - CHINA
Referee: Alyssa Pennington USA
Assistant Referee 1: Meghan Mullen USA
Assistant Referee 2: Jassett Kerr-Wilson JAM
Fourth Official: Anahí Fernández URU
Reserve AR : Yomara Salazar CHI
Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella ECU

SPAIN - PORTUGAL 
Referee: Asaka Koizumi JPN
Assistant Referee 1: Ha Thi Phuong VIE
Assistant Referee 2: Allys Clipsham NZL
Fourth Official: Milagros Arruela PER
Reserve AR : Amal Badhafari  UAE
Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-udom THA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB

17 September 2026

FRANCE - CANADA 
Referee: Twannyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Assistant Referee 1: Carine Atezambong Fomo CMR
Assistant Referee 2: Fides Bangourabona BDI
Fourth Official: Shamirah Nabadda  UGA
Reserve AR : Fanta Kone  MLI
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet  MRI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI

ENGLAND - NIGERIA 
Referee: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Assistant Referee 1: Gabrielle Lemieux CAN
Assistant Referee 2: Mijensa Rensch SUR
Fourth Official: Marianela Araya CRC
Reserve AR : Lourdes Noriega HON
Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar  VEN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos  POR

NORTH KOREA - JAPAN 
Referee: Charly Deretti Straub BRA
Assistant Referee 1: Fernanda Antunes BRA
Assistant Referee 2: Anne Sá BRA
Fourth Official: Dione Rissios CHI
Reserve AR : Leslie Vásquez  CHI
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV

POLAND - COLOMBIA 
Referee: Casey Reibelt AUS
Assistant Referee 1: Emma Kocbek AUS
Assistant Referee 2: Madelaine Allum AUS
Fourth Official: Kim Yu-jeong  KOR
Reserve AR : Heba Saadia  PLE
Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić  SRB

QUARTERFINALS

19 September 2026

SOUTH KOREA - ITALY 
Referee: Milagros Arruela PER
Assistant Referee 1: Leslie Vásquez CHI
Assistant Referee 2: Mariana Aquino PER
Fourth Official: Dione Rissios CHI
Reserve AR : Yomara Salazar CHI
Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza COL
Support Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ 

BRAZIL - SPAIN 
Referee: Lizzet Garcia MEX
Assistant Referee 1: Aranza Quero MEX
Assistant Referee 2: Fernanda Juarez MEX
Fourth Official: Myriam Marcotte CAN
Reserve AR : Gabrielle Lemieux CAN
Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI 
Support Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE

20 September 2026

NORTH KOREA - CANADA
Referee: Marianela Araya CRC 
Assistant Referee 1: Shirley Perelló HON
Assistant Referee 2: Lourdes Noriega HON
Fourth Official: Marta Huerta De Aza ESP 
Reserve AR : Iragartze Fernández Esesumaga ESP
Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:  Stefani Escobar VEN
Support Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA

NIGERIA - COLOMBIA 
Referee: Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi ITA 
Assistant Referee 1: Emily Carney ENG 
Assistant Referee 2: Paulina Baranowska POL
Fourth Official: Casey Reibelt AUS 
Reserve AR : Madelaine Allum AUS 
Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR 
Assistant Video Assistant Referee:  Eszter Urbán HUN
Support Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić SRB 

SEMIFINALS

23 September 2026

ITALY - SPAIN 
Referee: Ionela Alina Peșu ROU
Assistant Referee 1: Daniela Costantinescu ROU 
Assistant Referee 2: Heini Hyvönen FIN
Fourth Official: Marianela Araya CRC 
Reserve AR : Lourdes Noriega HON
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán HUN 
Support Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana SWZ

NORTH KOREA - COLOMBIA 
Referee: Casey Reibelt AUS
Assistant Referee 1: Emma Kocbek AUS
Assistant Referee 2: Madelaine Allum AUS
Fourth Official: Twanyanyukwa Antsino NAM
Reserve AR : Diana Chikotesha ZAM
Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
Support Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA

THIRD PLACE GAME

26 September 2026

ITALY - COLOMBIA
Referee: Lizzet Garcia MEX
Assistant Referee 1: Aranza Quero MEX
Assistant Referee 2: Fernanda Juarez MEX
Fourth Official: Alyssa Pennington USA
Reserve AR : Meghan Mullen USA
Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos POR
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal CHI
Support Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet MRI

FINAL

27 September 2026

SPAIN - NORTH KOREA 
Referee: Charly Deretti Straub BRA
Assistant Referee 1: Fernanda Antunes BRA
Assistant Referee 2: Anne Sá BRA
Fourth Official: Anahí Fernández URU
Reserve AR : Daiana Fernández URU
Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez MEX
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo SLV
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom THA

58 comments:

  1. I consider the appointment of Silvia Gasperotti as a referee on the day immediately following an assignment as Fourth Official to be less than optimal. Should such scheduling constraints prove unavoidable, the reverse arrangement would, in my view, be the more appropriate solution. However, particularly when making the initial appointments, at a stage when maximum flexibility still exists, I would refrain from assigning any official to a different venue as Fourth Official on the day preceding a match for which they are appointed as referee.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, with 18 referees in the tournament squad, this really seems avoidable. The three referees without appointment so far are Koizumi (JPN), Kim (KOR) and Demetrescu (ROU), so one of them could have been 4th official in MEX-BEN (unless they are unavailable).

      Delete
    2. And the underlying strange thing is, that no support officials have been nominated. In the last edition, there were 4 support referees (and also 18 main referees).

      Delete
  2. A late call for Allys Clipsham NZL, assistant referee not included in the original selection. Let's see whether she is a replacement. She has been appointed in AFC team, the expected official was Supawan Hinthong THA. However, we can't say, as it seems there are many changes so far.

    ReplyDelete
  3. BRATAN 37' (Huerta de Aza / Fernández Esesúmaga)
    Penalty awarded upon advice by AR1
    https://streama.in/Tr2q37GVXe0Bcp7/watch

    MEXBEN 55' (Ferrieri Caputi)
    Penalty awarded for kicking
    https://streama.in/hg6LlwXemwYgM5z/watch

    CANENG 85' (Fernández Hernández / Daza Ortiz)
    Penalty awarded for tackle after OFR
    https://streama.in/tujBZrBQWfbbZYW/watch

    Huerta de Aza's performance was not the best. Penalty awarded only because AR1 noticed the offence (37'), missed blatant encroachment at kick-off (0'), missed blatant SPA holding by BRA16 due to bad positioning (13'), missed stealing metres at throw-ins (16', 90'), possible YC for reckless kick by TAN3 (29'), possible YC for SPA to BRA8 (90')

    Marcotte with the easiest game of day1, she didn't face any challenge in POLARG. Potential YC for delaying the restart in 90+4' but she forgave the Argentine player.

    Ferrieri Caputi with a game involving many challenges. Potential YC for SPA not given in 2', missed mandatory YC for reckless step on foot in 26' (totally missed by her and AR1), not stopping play for head injuries in 8' and 81' that could've led to big troubles.

    Anahí Fernández with not a clear performance in CANENG. Penalty should've been spotted live (85'), possible YC to ENG7 for simulation (6'), missed YC for SPA to ENG18 (9'), being hit with the ball twice in a short period of time (13', 14'), possible YC ENG5 for SPA and/or ENG2 for delaying the restart (57'), funny incident when everyone thought the ball was out and English player caught the ball (78').

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Honestly, sometimes it's impossible to understand how referes can miss so evident incidents like the penalty in Canada - England, with a free view. And then making an OFR without being reactive at monitor.
      Mexico - Benin is a clear penalty, no doubts.
      Brazil - Tanzania is the classic situation in which attacker makes everything to win the call, but always assessed as penalty.

      Delete
  4. Day 2

    JPNNZL 57' (Twanyanyukwa / Rivet)
    PAI handball
    https://streama.in/F09c4Sgdn8BvPWc/watch

    JPNNZL 84' (Twanyanyukwa / Rivet)
    [OFR] Penalty awarded after GK's intervention
    https://streama.in/QZJSaLUbMm9QNji/watch

    ECUGHA 45+2' (Gasperotti / Campos)
    PAI tripping
    https://streama.in/oe1xD7cW02PSVmx/watch

    ECUGHA 90+2' (Gasperotti / Tempestilli)
    Quickly switching from wrong penalty for handball to IDFK for offside
    https://streama.in/yK0G8x9xHabnQCR/watch

    USAITA 40' (Reibelt / Carvajal Molina)
    Potential impeding in APP at Italy's goal
    https://streama.in/OYchODNUXPCZI8O/watch

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Expected level performance by Charly Deretti in an easy-going FRAKOR. Quite lenient disciplinary but no mandatory YC missed. Perhaps she should’ve clocked that French players’ tactics was to quickly stop potential counter-attacks by deliberate offences but as the different players committed the fouls, there is not much to blame the ref (64’, 69’, 76’, 83’). In 71’, the play was stopped for suspected injury of players of both teams after head collision but they were allowed to stay on the field of play.

      Mrs. Twanyanyukwa faced two key match incidents in JPNNZL:
      - no penalty for handball (57’; good call according to current interpretation - the ball hit the New Zealand’s player in a thigh, changed moving direction and the contact with an unnaturally positioned arm followed);
      - penalty awarded for goalkeeper’s intervention after an on-field review (84’; very long check and given the images shown to the referee perhaps something was wrong with the software, otherwise very amateur procedure by Maria Rivet; I agree with the intervention although using the FIFA philosophy one can say the contact was initiated by the attacking player, but to me she was trying to get over the goalkeeper and was simply tripped)
      Disciplinary was okay-ish: opening YC to NZL11 for LoR/SPA shirt pulling (16’), missed YC to NZL17 for SPA holding (20’, if whistled it has to be a YC), YC to NZL8 for reckless tackle after some delay (76’) and a balancing (de facto wrong) YC to JPN4 for SPA (77’).
      The most shocking was the lost time compensation. The VAR check started at 84:00. At that point already third minutes should’ve been added. So, easy maths, it should’ve been “9” on the electronic board. Instead, the “5” was shown. After the penalty goal, the play was restarted at 92:00, yet the final whistle came at exactly 95:00… So, even though the overall performance was not bad, the OFR (procedure) and the extremely subpar dealing with added time left us with a bitter taste.

      Silvia Gasperotti is surely ahead of most of their female colleagues regarding soft skills. It was very nice to watch how well she connected with players by staying serious, professional and at the same time her talks not being theatrical and not taking too much time (quick stern warning after UB against GK in 12’, quick talk to a player after an attempted delaying the restart by not retreating in 14’ and 41’ or perfect positioning and clear gesture after tackles on the ball in 25’ and 33’ gave her a very high level of credibility). Two possible YCs not given: to ECU3 for SPA holding (37’) and GHA3 for deliberate SPA-ish handball (51’, would be good also for balancing purposes after a YC to ECU player four minutes earlier).
      Everything would’ve summed up for a good performance but the Italian spoiled it by awarding a totally wrong penalty for handball to Ghana only to instantly switch for offside (really blatant one, should’ve been given earlier with the SAOT-Live system in use).

      No problems for Casey Reibelt who applied a high threshold for fouls and nicely contributed to a football-focused fast-paced USAITA. Good play-on call in APP at USA's goal (17’ - clear tackle) and tricky incident with potential impeding at Italy's equalizer (40’, for me it's a foul but I guess FIFA will accept). The opening YC to ITA11 for cynical tripping/kicking from behind gave the clear signal that unsporting behaviours won’t be tolerated (22’). In 90+3’, USA’s goal correctly disallowed for offside.

      Delete
  5. Il SAOT non c'è. Perché prima di commentare non vi informate?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry, the commentator said it's in use in the Polish game. Also, some offside calls are very late what would suggest it's in use but surely you're better informed ;)

      Delete
    2. Secondo le indicazioni degli organi preposti, l' AR comunica all'arbitro il fuorigioco attravetso l'aurucolare, l'arbitro fischia e immediatamente dopo l'AR alza la bandiera

      Delete
    3. È questa la tempistica; può sembrare una segnalazione in ritardo, ma non è così, sono queste le indicazioni

      Delete
  6. Tanzania - Canada

    Referee: Kim Yu-jeong (KOR)
    Assistant Referee 1: Heba Saadia (PLE)
    Assistant Referee 2: Allys Clipsham (NZL)
    Fourth Official: Marta Huerta De Aza (ESP)
    Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos (POR)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán (HUN)

    ReplyDelete
  7. England - Brazil

    Referee: Alyssa Pennington (USA)
    Assistant Referee 1: Meghan Mullen (USA)
    Assistant Referee 2: Jassett Kerr-Wilson (JAM)
    Fourth Official: Lizzet Garcia (MEX)
    Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom (THA)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić (SRB)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Argentina - Mexico

    Referee: Shamirah Nabadda (UGA)
    Assistant Referee 1: Fanta Kone (MLI)
    Assistant Referee 2: Fides Bangourabona (BDI)
    Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peşu (ROU)
    Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou (GRE)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet (MRI)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Benin - Poland

    Referee: Milagros Arruela (PER)
    Assistant Referee 1: Irina Pozdejeva (LTU)
    Assistant Referee 2: Mariana Aquino (PER)
    Fourth Official: Asaka Koizumi (JPN)
    Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar (VEN)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza (COL)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Shamirah Nabadda with very big assignment for a CAF official.
    Given that their standard seems to officiate mostly games with OFC national teams, that's a more than outstanding appointment.
    Argentina - Mexico, crucial for qualification, with Mexico having the chance to overtake Argentina.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting given she had two OFRs in her game!

      Delete
  11. Day 3

    PRKPOR (Milagros Arruela)
    03' https://streama.in/UlgqQDbfnWNrpvG/watch
    24' https://streama.in/Rt4EE0Mt8itrY22/watch
    42' https://streama.in/OOQavYALwPEAJMR/watch
    56' https://streama.in/CZpkilF3yOyYf94/watch
    61' https://streama.in/Qi3k3Z9GSlSnYWs/watch

    Bad mistake with an onside call by AR1 Mariana Aquino in 3', goal allowed after VAR intervention. Good assessment of penalty area incidents: penalty for handball in 24', no penalty after mutual offence in 42' and no penalty after attacker creating/using contact in 56'. Possible RC for SFP to POR16 (kick in the face) in 61' but IDFK was awarded.
    Otherwise an okay performance with a rather non-obtrusive approach. Good reaction/alertness to unsporting behaviours in 9' and 71' (here fourth official did her job properly!), missed stealing metres at throw-in in 80', possible YCs to POR6 for SPA holding in 10' and POR5 for SPA holding in 83'.


    NCLCHN (Shamirah Nabadda)
    51' https://streama.in/P4UFI6Pl22PFOMm/watch
    76' https://streama.in/sSJVmUgHjhd1Wu4/watch

    A game that didn't offer many challenges for the Ugandan official but the overall picture was not good after two overturned penalty decisions (51' no handball, 76' fair tackle) and three VAR corrections re. corner kicks (4', 41', 64'). Also, not addressing the very blatant late tripping by NCL9 in 2' was suboptimal.


    CRCCOL (Kim Yu-jeong)
    21' https://streama.in/HYC7XyAIZainlYx/watch
    33' https://streama.in/XGp86psyvdnIxkk/watch
    86' https://streama.in/WBO2CzhzkWgp8QT/watch
    90' https://streama.in/55XrRa5LHZqeKDv/watch

    Very elegant way of refereeing and being a very fluent English speaker makes the Korean looking very professional, even comparable to best UEFA Elite referees. The game was a typical Latin game with some trash-talking (GK to a penalty taker in 25' and verbal conflict in 43') and many challenges.
    Unfortunately, two OFRs were needed: missed illegal use of arm - penalty awarded after OFR (21') and missed kicking offence - penalty awarded after OFR (86'). The no-penalty decision after clumsy tackle in 33' was correct. I was surprised to not see an OFR for potential violent conduct after COL18 kicked her opponent in the face (90').
    Possible YCs to COL14 for tactical impeding (33', very stern warning issued), CRC10 for strongly kicking the ball away after a FK awarded against her (45+4') and COL8 for reckless late challenge (53').


    ESPNGA (Marianela Araya)
    Differently to previous three games on Day 3, this one didn't offer any key match incidents. The overall impression: a typical FIFA refereeing in a bad meaning. Nigerians decided to play roughly against Spaniards and the referee should've act stronger against some of the challenges. For example, a strong warning should be given in 24' after cynical challenge by NGA11 but it was delivered one minute later after a 'nothing foul' by NGA12. Nothing followed after late challenge by NGA10 (29'), tactical offence by NGA12 (32'), tactical offence by NGA10 (40') and only a very blatant reckless kick by NGA15 caught attention and the player was cautioned (58'). The Spanish player deserved a YC in 90+1' for quite blatant SPA tackle. In 49', the referee - due to bad positioning - missed a FK execution and not keeping 9.15m by Nigerian player, play was allowed to continue...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Some very positive notes in the officiating by Peruvian referee. Excellent call for the handball. I agree with no penalty in 56', rather surprising (in positive sense) that VAR understood the point of view by referee. Then OK to play on in 42' as well, but I think here she rather mised the couple of players, not looking at them. Indirect free kick close to end should be because she thought no contact. Correct by VAR to stay silent as this one could have been just YC for reckless.
      Extremely strange that Nabadda got ARG - MEX after two OFRs for wrong penalties, in the first case it's always hard with handballs, but I fully dislike these very easy whistles by many referees, they don't see the handball,they just think that it has happened.
      About the Korean referee, she should have spotted the penalty in 86'. The illegal use of arm was maybe a bit harder to spot but still...
      Very good no penalty decision in 33', while I understand why no VAR intervention for the possible violent conduct as the end of the game, VAR thought about an unintentional action, so rather reckless, but to me it was on purpose.

      Delete
  12. Italy - Japan

    Referee: Myriam Marcotte (CAN)
    Assistant Referee 1: Gabrielle Lemieux (CAN)
    Assistant Referee 2: Mijensa Rensch (SUR)
    Fourth Official: Charly Deretti Straub (BRA)
    Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo (SLV)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella (ECU)

    ReplyDelete
  13. New Zealand - USA

    Referee: Anahí Fernández (URU)
    Assistant Referee 1: Daiana Fernández (URU)
    Assistant Referee 2: Belén Clavijo (URU)
    Fourth Official: Marta Huerta De Aza (ESP)
    Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal (CHI)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga (RWA)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Korea Republic - Ecuador

    Referee: Marianela Araya (CRC)
    Assistant Referee 1: Shirley Perelló (HON)
    Assistant Referee 2: Lourdes Noriega (HON)
    Fourth Official: Twannyanyukwa Antsino (NAM)
    Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez (MEX)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana (SWZ)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Ghana - France

    Referee: Dione Rissios (CHI)
    Assistant Referee 1: Leslie Vásquez (CHI)
    Assistant Referee 2: Yomara Salazar (CHI)
    Fourth Official: Casey Reibelt (AUS)
    Video Assistant Referee: Maria Victoria Daza (COL)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou (GRE)

    ReplyDelete
  16. Day 4

    BENARG (Alyssa Pennington)
    25' https://streama.in/ygFWB2qJioZLwIZ/watch
    57' https://streama.in/02jvNchJPQiK2yc/watch
    66' https://streama.in/ogfaB4hPfUmqm16/watch
    89' https://streama.in/IM3B85dFdf7lgct/watch

    Tricky penalty incident in 25' and the Serbian VAR was most likely in trouble to decide - I would say the Argentine was rather hit by the ball and not played it and then she tripped the opponent, so the optimal decision should be a penalty here.
    Otherwise, a very lenient performance by the American referee who handled the game in a typical FIFA manner. Forgiven YC to ARG8 for SPA in 2', correctly issued YC to BEN2 for SPA in 6' and then BEN players were entitled to do anything: hard challenges (36' - warning, 40' - warning, 54', 90+1') and tactical offences (29', 37', 90+3'). Good alertness re. throw-in position in 34' but in 37' and 89' she was too meticulous in this regard.
    Good performance by AR1 Meghan Mullen: great onside before penalty (57'), very good onside prior to Argentina's seventh goal (66') and correctly disallowed Argentina's goal (89').


    BRACAN (Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi)
    06' https://streama.in/E00cqXaYmIbHraG/watch
    25' https://streama.in/bF94w1UUX1DyDtq/watch
    36' https://streama.in/jCnxipAYGCJvIq0/watch
    52' https://streama.in/LZOaHPRRyXtfddP/watch

    Very good performance by the Italian. All key match incidents correctly assessed live - penalty to Brazil for kicking (6'), RC CAN5 for DOGSO (25'), no penalty for holding as the potential offence occured before the corner kick execution (36'). AR1 Baranowska with a good onside prior to Brazil's third goal (52'). Disciplinary was not challenging in this game: okay warning to CAN10 for illegal use of arm (11') and possible YC to BRA2 for SPA holding (24').


    POLMEX (Anahí Fernández)
    35' https://streama.in/Oyy0bFRuRVKQEXb/watch
    69' https://streama.in/E1C0bO9rwnaFbti/watch
    71' https://streama.in/xv82tYVYYVzpXyg/watch
    85' https://streama.in/DTtL5FLBKtDmFhX/watch

    Quite challenging game for the Uruguayan official. Okay no penalty in 35' (holding but the Polish player fell on her own accord), play-on after potential SPA/DOGSO pushing (69'), on-field review was needed to determine the foul on Polish player and award a penalty (71' - however, the ball was not reachable for the attacker and the offence was not clearly reckless, so FIFA maybe would accept/like a play-on?) and a tricky penalty incident - knee against back/ribs but, again, the ball not reachable for the fouled player and the offence not being clearly reckless, so VAR didn't intervene (85').
    Apart from above, good alertness and overall game management, able to connect with players and control their behaviours.


    ENGTAN (Diona Rissios)
    03' https://streama.in/YAChLT53EwTfRjQ/watch
    06' https://streama.in/9jxfrO2cNv78K3r/watch
    08' https://streama.in/EXu7zzv6x5K2NhB/watch
    11' https://streama.in/3qmHZ3fiXRt7LP3/watch
    36' https://streama.in/CatOAf9fNsbVyre/watch
    42' https://streama.in/LPas7gRXXu5r04U/watch
    83' https://streama.in/03SF62hDNOOfIK8/watch

    Bad performance from the Chilean. The first penalty to England should've been spotted live (11'), controversial no penalty after dynamic tackle after the pass had been made - no replay, unfortunately (36'), correct penalty to England for tripping (42') and epic goal -> penalty -> offside (without VAR gesture) decision (83').
    In addition, poor handling of a Tanzania player going off for 1' after medical treatment - re-entering the field of play without permission managed in-play (3') and bizarre offside call by AR1 Leslie Vásquez (8') who correctly flagged offside at Tanzania's goal (90+3'). Not an evening to remember for the officials...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for these reports.
      Regarding Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi, coming to this point after she has participated in so many FIFA competitions, it can be said that this is her world and that she feels more at ease here compared to Serie A and Serie B where, unfortunately, partly due to these continuous absences due to international duties, but unfortunately also (and more) technically, she struggles to stand out.
      The two major decisions of her match are very clear, the penalty kick first and the red card after, but that doesn't change the fact that it was a very strong performance.
      I would say that, since it all started from Collina idea to call her one of the first times for the FIFA tournaments, and her career was heavily accelerated at the UEFA level, she could referee the final of this U20 WC if Italy allows it, but we have to wait and see.

      Delete
    2. Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi was in charge of the final of Women’s U20 World Cup last edition, back in 2024 in Bogotà

      Delete
    3. I forgot that, crucial mistake for me.
      Indeed, she attended many FIFA youth tournaments, that's very particular, surely more than many other referees.

      Delete
  17. Union Berlin Schalke: injury of Gerach and very young Jarno Wienefeld(28yo) makes his debut
    https://x.com/mrasubio/status/2098535195427184855?s=46

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Another debut (regular this time) is coming up in the afternoon when Freiburg faces Mönchengladbach. Richard Hempel, 28 years of age too, will be in charge of his first Bundesliga game. He doesn't look like 28 either...

      Delete
  18. First VAR review show of the season from Scotland. Always interesting to listen to the processes and reasoning behind decisions.

    https://youtu.be/HNQaFXr3GgQ?is=r2UwJR8Z73K_g2N7

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For once I actually thought Collum came across rather well certainly better than other editions of this show I've seen. More pushback and debate from the host than previously had or a more insightful discussion.

      Delete
    2. Yes it was good to see some decent debate

      Delete
  19. Sanchez martinez wronly pulling the red card instead of the yellow one
    https://x.com/alnassrtribune/status/2098469751982809317?s=46

    ReplyDelete
  20. Any opinion on disasi’s RC in crystal palace ipswich?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Appointments of match officials - Round of 16

    Argentina - Korea Republic

    Referee: Marta Huerta De Aza (ESP)
    Assistant Referee 1: Iragartze Fernández Esesumaga (ESP)
    Assistant Referee 2: Andreia Sousa (POR)
    Fourth Official: Lizzet Garcia (MEX)
    Reserve AR : Fernanda Juarez (MEX)
    Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán (HUN)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos (POR)


    Brazil - USA

    Referee: Silvia Gasperotti (ITA)
    Assistant Referee 1: Giulia Tempestilli (ITA)
    Assistant Referee 2: Svitlana Grushko (UKR)
    Fourth Official: Ionela Alina Peșu (ROU)
    Reserve AR : Paulina Baranowska (POL)
    Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou (GRE)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Salima Mukansanga (RWA)

    ReplyDelete
  22. Italy - China PR

    Referee: Alyssa Pennington (USA)
    Assistant Referee 1: Meghan Mullen (USA)
    Assistant Referee 2: Jassett Kerr-Wilson (JAM)
    Fourth Official: Anahí Fernández (URU)
    Reserve AR : Yomara Salazar (CHI)
    Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez (MEX)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Susana Corella (ECU)


    Spain - Portugal

    Referee: Asaka Koizumi (JPN)
    Assistant Referee 1: Ha Thi Phuong (VIE)
    Assistant Referee 2: Allys Clipsham (NZL)
    Fourth Official: Milagros Arruela (PER)
    Reserve AR : Amal Badhafari (UAE)
    Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-udom (THA)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jelena Jovanović Džajić (SRB)

    ReplyDelete
  23. France - Canada

    Referee: Twannyanyukwa Antsino (NAM)
    Assistant Referee 1: Carine Atezambong Fomo (CMR)
    Assistant Referee 2: Fides Bangourabona (BDI)
    Fourth Official: Shamirah Nabadda (UGA)
    Reserve AR : Fanta Kone (MLI)
    Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet (MRI)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal (CHI)


    England - Nigeria

    Referee: Myriam Marcotte (CAN)
    Assistant Referee 1: Gabrielle Lemieux (CAN)
    Assistant Referee 2: Mijensa Rensch (SUR)
    Fourth Official: Marianela Araya (CRC)
    Reserve AR : Lourdes Noriega (HON)
    Video Assistant Referee: Stefani Escobar (VEN)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos (POR)

    ReplyDelete
  24. NL predictions
    ITABEL: Obrenovic (SVN) TURFRA: Schärer (SUI)
    BELFRA: Rumsas (LTU) TURITA: Oliver (ENG)
    FRAITA: Eskas (NOR) BELTUR: Gil Manzano (ESP)
    FRABEL: Stieler (GER) ITATUR: Zwayer (GER)
    NEDGER: Letexier (FRA) SRBGRE: Grinfeeld (ISR)
    SRBNED: Hernandez (ESP) GERGRE: Walsh (SCO)
    GRENED: Kruzliak (SVK) GERSRB: Lambrechts (BEL)
    NEDSRB: Sozza (ITA) GREGER: Nyberg (SWE)
    ENGESP: Kovacs (ROU) CZECRO: Gözübüyük (NED)
    ESPCRO: Siebert (GER) CZEENG: Peljto (BIH)
    CROENG: Delajod (FRA) ESPCZE: Meler (TÜR)
    CROESP: Mariani (ITA) ENGCZE: Massa (ITA)
    PORWAL: Jablonski (GER) NORDEN: Kavanagh (ENG)
    DENWAL: Guida (ITA) NORPOR: Marciniak (POL)
    WALNOR: Sanchez (ESP) DENPOR: Jovanovic (SRB)
    PORNOR: Turpin (FRA) WALDEN: Kabakov (BUL)

    SVNSCO: Stegemann (GER) MKDSUI: Brisard (FRA)
    SVNMKD: Krogh (DEN) SCOSUI: Ocenas (SVK)
    SUISVN: Godinho (POR) MKDSCO: Berka (CZE)
    SUIMKD: Malcevs (LVA) SCOSVN: Gidzhenov (BUL)
    GEONIR: Barbara (MLT) HUNUKR: Hennessy (IRL)
    GEOUKR: Aghayev (AZE) NIRHUN: Weinberger (AUT)
    UKRNIR: de Burgos (ESP) HUNGEO: Schnyder (SUI)
    UKRHUN: Minakovic (SRB) NIRGEO: Kolaric (CRO)
    AUTISR: Pignard (FRA) KOSIRL: Balakin (UKR)
    AUTKOS: Nobre (POR) ISRIRL: Alberola (ESP)
    ISRKOS: Raczkowski (POL) IRLAUT: Sylwestrzak (POL)
    KOSAUT: Saggi (NOR) IRLISR: Vergoote (BEL)
    POLBIH: Fotias (GRE) SWEROU: Colombo (ITA)
    ROUBIH: Tohver (EST) SWEPOL: Berke (HUN)
    POLROU: Treimanis (LVA) BIHSWE: Xhaja (ALB)
    ROUSWE: Brooks (ENG) BIHPOL: Masiyev (AZE)

    SMRFIN: Sheehan (GIB) ALBBLR: Dickinson (SCO)
    FINBLR: Aslam (NOR) SMRALB: Higraff (NOR)
    FINALB: d'Hondt (BEL) BLRSMR: Bognar (HUN)
    ALBSMR: S. Kovacs (ROU) BLRFIN: Petrescu (ROU)
    ARMLVA: Fesnic (ROU) MNECYP: Kos (POL)
    ARMMNE: Al-Hakim (SWE) LVACYP: Milanovic (SRB)
    LVAMNE: van der Eijk (NED) CYPARM: Roucek (CZE)
    CYPLVA: Matosa (SVN) MNEARM: Hamiti (ALB)
    FROKAZ: Kastrati (KOS) SVKMDA: Pajac (CRO)
    MDAFRO: Osmers (GER) SVKKAZ: Ginchev (BUL)
    KAZMDA: Bandic (BIH) FROSVK: KruashvilI (GEO)
    KAZFRO: Gishamer (AUT) MDASVK: Nalbandyan (ARM)
    ISLEST: Robinson (NIR) BULLUX: Visser (BEL)
    BULEST: Barbu (ROU) LUXISL: Fuxman (ISR)
    ISLBUL: Muntean (MDA) ESTLUX: Bertolo (POR)
    LUXBUL: Kikacheishvili (GEO) ESTISL: Cerny (CZE)

    ANDMLT: Robertson (SCO) GIBAND: Kopiievsky (UKR)
    MLTGIB: Bogar (HUN) MLTAND: Badstübner (GER)
    LIELTU: Ladebäck (SWE) LTUAZE: Jones (ENG)
    AZELIE: McNabb (NIR) AZELTU: Sundberg (DEN)

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nigeria - Colombia
    Referee Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi
    VAR Catarina Campos
    Original decision RC for SFP, confirmed after OFR.
    https://files.fm/u/ebntyyhsj9qnvahc
    In my opinion wrong intervention, but the argument by Portuguese VAR is clear, almost no contact with opponent.
    However, given that the arm is clearly hit by the raised leg, no chance to consider it a clear and obvious mistake because the player entered in a very dangerous way the challenge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad you think it's a wrong intervention, but for me the "logic" from Campos is absurd. The challenge could have broken the other player's wrist. And if it was a little to the right, it would have speared her in the abdomen. The myopic focus on the point of contact these days is maddening. The tackle itself endangered the safety of the opponent. Whether the limb is the leg or the arm (or a limb at all) should be irrelevant with this bad of a tackle.

      I cannot believe a VAR sent this down as a clear and obvious error. The disconnect between theoretical officiating from the VOR and good on-field practical refereeing seems to be getting wider and wider.

      Delete
    2. This time we agree about everything.
      I will repeat it again and again: focusing on a detail (in this case the point of contact) is the biggest argument from which many crucial mistakes are made by VARs in modern refereeing.
      Very often, they don't analyze the full picture for unknown reasons, but they look in particular what they can find for their personal interpretation, and that's a big issue.
      In the case of Catarina Campos one can say she was in doubt that, given the point of impact, the challenge could have been assessed as not enough for SFP, so she decided to shift responsibility to Ferrieri Caputi. It's easy to understand this reasoning, but let me add, in modern refereeing in both FIFA an UEFA, they do many seminars, lessons and so on. but I fear they never introduce such a topic.
      It's easy to say, before looking at a detail, try to get always the full picture: how the challenge starts, how much dangerous it can be, and so on.

      Delete
    3. Portuguese VAR to decrete an OFR id completely madness here. Very good decision by Caputi to mantain the original call. What a pity by Campos !

      Delete
  26. Completely agree, usaref. Clear RC

    ReplyDelete
  27. Appointments of match officials - Semi-final

    Italy - Spain

    Referee: Ionela Alina Peșu (ROU)
    Assistant Referee 1: Daniela Costantinescu (ROU)
    Assistant Referee 2: Heini Hyvönen (FIN)
    Fourth Official: Marianela Araya (CRC)
    Reserve AR : Lourdes Noriega (HON)
    Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou (GRE)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Eszter Urbán (HUN)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Letticia Viana (SWZ)

    DPR Korea - Colombia

    Referee: Casey Reibelt (AUS)
    Assistant Referee 1: Emma Kocbek (AUS)
    Assistant Referee 2: Madelaine Allum (AUS)
    Fourth Official: Twannyanyukwa Antsino (NAM)
    Reserve AR : Diana Chikotesha (ZAM)
    Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet (MRI)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal (CHI)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom (THA)

    ReplyDelete
  28. DPR Korea vs Colombia

    90 +1
    What are the arguments for a no VAR intervention?
    What are the arguments for no PK call?

    I believe the referee team (especially AR1) erred in not spotting the deliberate yet completely unnecessary act by the Colombian player.
    The fact that it happened during open play and off the ball. I can kind of understand the referee team missing it live. Even though I have a hard time believing that AR1 didn’t see it.
    The non VAR intervention, I am personally unable to find any reasons or justifications.
    Thank you. : )

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't find the incident you are reporting, moreover in the 90'+1 minute AR1 was on the side of Colombia attack. So in case should be AR2, I think?

      Delete
    2. Ah OK I found it, it was in first half, 45'+1.
      https://streamin.link/v/8c790f00
      Not enough for a violent conduct, according to VAR...
      Add this to the VAR intervention in Ferrieri Caputi game and you know how lenient today referees are about red cards!

      Delete
    3. Yes correct, 45 +1. I apologize for the confusion.

      My dear Chefren. I’m not advocating for VAR to have intervened for a VC Red Card and as result a PK.

      My question is, why is this not a VAR review for a just a PK? What are the arguments?

      Letting that blatant and unnecessary act by the Colombian player go unpunished looks terrible.

      It’s just as bad as Frida Klarlunds missed hair pulling in last seasons Women’s Champions League match between Arsenal and Chelsea.

      And in my humble opinion, it’s these type of specific actions in which VAR can truly show it’s worth and help out the on field referee team.

      Thank you.

      Delete
  29. Appointments of match officials - Third place

    Italy - Colombia

    Referee: Lizzet Garcia (MEX)
    Assistant Referee 1: Aranza Quero (MEX)
    Assistant Referee 2: Fernanda Juarez (MEX)
    Fourth Official: Alyssa Pennington (USA)
    Reserve AR : Meghan Mullen (USA)
    Video Assistant Referee: Catarina Campos (POR)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Rodrigo Carvajal (CHI)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maria Rivet (MRI)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The fact that Campos and Rivet are assigned yet again is mind boggling.

      Campos had ZERO reason to send Caputti for an OFR on a CLEAR as day SFP that Caputti spotted perfectly.

      And Rivet, IMHO, should have called Riebeldt for an OFR at 45 +1 for a possible PK in DPR Korea vs Colombia.

      Delete
    2. The fact that Campos and Rivet are assigned yet again is mind boggling.

      Campos had ZERO reason to send Caputti for an OFR on a CLEAR as day SFP that Caputti spotted perfectly.

      And Rivet, IMHO, should have called Riebeldt for an OFR at 45 +1 for a possible PK in DPR Korea vs Colombia.

      Delete
    3. Sorry for the double post.

      Delete
  30. Appointments of match officials - Final

    Spain - DPR Korea

    Referee: Charly Deretti Straub (BRA)
    Assistant Referee 1: Fernanda Antunes (BRA)
    Assistant Referee 2: Anne Sá (BRA)
    Fourth Official: Anahí Fernández (URU)
    Reserve AR : Daiana Fernández (URU)
    Video Assistant Referee: Diana Pérez (MEX)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ismael Cornejo (SLV)
    Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom (THA)

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for writing a comment on our blog!