Friday, 1 February 2019

Referees primed for spring duty

UEFA’s top European male and female referees have been in training in Lisbon – preparing for the second half of the campaign, as well as for the introduction of video assistant referees (VAR) in the UEFA Champions League.

A challenging second half of the season awaits Europe’s top referees – with UEFA confident that the match officials will take an important period for refereeing in their stride.

The 122 male and female referees – 46 of them newcomers to the international list - have spent the week in Lisbon at UEFA’s latest annual winter gathering, in preparation for assignments in UEFA’s club and national team competitions over the coming months.

For top European male match officials on the advanced course, the four days in Portugal saw training and fine-tuning work for the imminent introduction of video assistant referees (VAR) in the UEFA Champions League, starting in the Round of 16, which kicks off on 12 February.

Italian referees in Lisbon
Last year, VAR was incorporated into the Laws of the Game by football’s lawmakers, the International Football Association Board (IFAB), following trials in major competitions. The video assistant referee reviews decisions made by the referee in certain key match situations with the use of video footage and a headset for communication.

UEFA’s Executive Committee decided to introduce VAR in UEFA competitions last September, and the committee took a subsequent decision in December for VAR to be deployed from the start of this season’s UEFA Champions League knockout phase. In addition, VAR is to be used at this season's UEFA Europa League final in Baku, the UEFA Nations League Finals in Portugal in June and the UEFA European Under-21 Championship final tournament in Italy in the same month.

Roberto Rosetti's lesson
The referees took part in specific practical training sessions and simulation sessions involving recorded footage of actual matches, practising reviews in particular. Study sessions on recent incidents in UEFA matches, using video clips, also included discussions on potential VAR situations. “VAR will provide an important help to match officials,” said UEFA’s chief refereeing officer Roberto Rosetti. “It’s a big step forward for Europe’s referees, and we are ready for the challenge.”

Group-work session
In addition to VAR preparation, the referees were encouraged to be decisive and firm in fulfilling their crucial role on the field. Instructions given to them included the need to protect players from serious injury caused by reckless challenges, as well as to safeguard the image of the game by, for example, acting firmly against cases of dissent or mobbing.

“We don’t need nice or popular referees,” Rosetti said. “We need strong personalities with a professional attitude, who show courage in taking decisions and act as role models for other referees around Europe”.

The international newcomers received a full briefing into what UEFA expects from them as they start out on their journey. “You should be proud, because this is a very important time for you,” Rosetti told them. “Be yourselves – look for improvement every day, don’t try to copy others, and enjoy this moment.”

The new referees were also given wise words of motivation by two officials who have reached the European summit – Germany’s Felix Brych and Switzerland’s Esther Staubli – who advised them in particular about their important role as ambassadors for UEFA and European football.

Fitness training was a key item on the agenda in Lisbon, with the newcomers in particular tested in sprint exercises and undertaking the yo-yo intermittent endurance test – the aim being to check their physical condition. “Challenge yourself to make progress – we are there to help you,” UEFA referee fitness expert Werner Helsen told them.

During the course, referees were reminded of the need for consistency and uniformity in decision-making. The new officials in particular were informed of the standards that UEFA expects of them as they set on what they hope will be long and successful careers.

The week ended with an inspirational moment – courtesy of special guest Beatrice Vio, the Italian wheelchair fencer who has won the world, European and Paralympic titles in recent years.

Beatrice "Bebe" Vio, special guest
The 21-year-old, who at the age of 11 had both legs amputated from the knee, and both arms from the forearms owing to meningitis, was given a standing ovation by the referees for her stirring story of courage and determination to overcome adversity and achieve sporting success. “If you referee, you are doing it because you love it,” she told the officials. “Believe in yourselves, and believe that what you are doing is right.”

Source:
uefa.com

80 comments:

  1. Milvil - Everton
    Referee : Michael Oliver
    Goal scored after Milvil player played the ball with his hand
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqFd_ETl3Qc

    ReplyDelete
  2. Looks like they used a 2019-1 RAP in the group-work sessions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Using some inferencing skills, we can make a shortlist of the referees who will officiate Under21 EURO in Italy / San Marino in the summer.
    They have to fill these prerequisites: Attended the UEFA Advanced Course (VAR training), Belong to UEFA First Category, Never attended U21 EURO before.

    This leaves us with:
    Əliyar Ağayev (AZE), Aliaksiej Kuĺbakoŭ (BLR), Georgi Kabakov (BUL), Craig Pawson (ENG), Mattias Gestranius (FIN), Ruddy Buquet (FRA), Daniel Siebert (GER), Orel Grinfeld (ISR), Davide Massa (ITA), Andris Treimanis (LVA), Paweł Raczkowski (POL), István Kovács (ROU), Srđan Jovanović (SRB), Andreas Ekberg (SWE).

    If UEFA appoint nine referees like 2017 edition, my prediction is:
    Ağayev, Kabakov, Pawson, Siebert, Massa, Treimanis, Kovács, Jovanović, Ekberg.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with your shortlist.
      My prediction is: Ekberg, Grinfeld, Kabakov, Kovacs, Kulbakov, Massa, Raczkowski, Siebert, Treimanis

      Will also be interesting, who will be chosen as VAR. The top ones from the CL season or some new candidates to increase the VAR squad for the following season.

      Delete
    2. I just realized, there is also the U20 WC directly before. So referees, who go there, probably won't attend the U21 EURO as well.
      My early prediction for UEFA referees for the U20 WC would be:
      Bastien, Gil Manzano, Kulbakov, Massa, Oliver, Vincic

      Delete
  4. Anyone information (pictures etc.) about the referee kits from the new supplier Macron for the FIFA referees?
    Macron will be supplier from summer on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Source of that info? Seems strange to me...

      Delete
    2. My referee colleague from my hometown became FIFA Assistent referee this year and she had to give FIFA her sizes. And they were informed that ist will be Macron Jerseys, track suits etc.

      Delete
    3. It is true, my FIFA referee friend told me same information.

      Delete
    4. Law5-TheRef, the blog where almost every reader is a friend of a FIFA referee.

      Seems very strange as Adidas remains official technical partner of both FIFA and UEFA.

      Delete
    5. And why not to have a friend who is in FIFA? Is that a bad thing? This is not 2010 anymore my friend.

      Delete
    6. Well, it is still strange, as Adidas has been the supplier for many years. Another question is… does that affect UEFA as well or is only for FIFA competitions?

      Delete
    7. just check https://m.facebook.com/SchiedsrichterMS/
      and you will see my referee colleague ;-)

      Delete
  5. How is possible not to whistle penalty for Bayer Leverkusen in 2nd minut (blatant handball of Hummels) ?
    It was a silent-check (no OFR) but no penalty. Outrageous for me ... I'm waiting for your opinions !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For me a cleary deliberate handball. Even DOGSO was possible there... I’m sorry, but German VAR is a simple joke.

      Delete
    2. Waiting for Vlad's outburst about German VAR. :D

      Delete
    3. Not the best quality of the clip for now, but here:

      2’ - Deliberate handball? SPA vs DOGSO?
      => https://streamable.com/ajtk4

      Delete
    4. According to UEFA, I think that this is for sure a punishable handball. Only reason to play on is short distance. I think referee made this assessment, but very likely he was wrong.

      Delete
    5. The situation kind of reminds me of the one in CL quarterfinal 2016, Atlético-Barcelona: Iniesta handles the ball, Rizzoli awards a YC. I remember that this situation was analyzed by Roberto Rosetti during a conference with Turkey federation, concluding that this should have been DOGSO and RC.

      What would you say here? YC (SPA) or RC (DOGSO). Personally, I think that's DOGSO...

      Delete
    6. For me it's a penalty, but as there are arguments against it (no movement towards ball, natural arm position, short distance) I don't see it as a case for the VAR (as long as Stieler has seen the handball).

      Delete
    7. What ???

      - Natural arm position ? The hand is almost perpendicular on the body in the moment of handball.

      - Short distance ? I wouldn't say that. More than that, it was preety obvious for everyone (including Hummels) that a shot on goal will follow. Hummels tried to block that shot, it wasn't something unexpected.

      Delete
    8. With "natural arm position", I mean that it is part of his movement and not neccesarily targeted on blocking the ball.
      But I basically agree with you, because I also think, that it should be a penalty. I am only arguing, that it is not that clear and obvious, because one could support those arguments. For VAR, we have to distinguish between our own opinion on a situation and whether we think, (nearly) everyone has this opinion.
      Furthermore, Stieler had a good view on the situation, which made it unlikely, that he would change his opinion in an OFR - and in that case, one can avoid this delay.
      At least, it is not among the ca. 20 situations in this Bundesliga season, where I think, that a crucial mistake should have been avoided with the help of VAR.

      Delete
    9. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    10. Do you have a video this situation?

      Delete
  6. Great penalty by Michael Oliver in Crystal palace vs Fulham what makes it even very hard to give is that both players arm of both teams were up and both players were wearing black gloves and he was very confident about his decision
    Video:https://streamable.com/tawn5

    ReplyDelete
  7. And in Anthony Taylor's game a crucial moment where he booked a player for simulation (quite controversial) and number 10 of Burnley should be given a second yellow card and sent off because of his reaction first to the asst referee and to Taylor.. quite bad to see such dissent go unpunished anyone with video of the incident please share

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dzeko is banned for only 2 matchs after his terrible act on referee. Terrible and scandalous decision by FIGC. Unbelievable...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. According to referee's report, it wasn't a spit.

      Delete
  9. Strange situation for Undiano in FCB-VAL. He just blew the whistle to concede a (correct) PK just 0.1 seconds before Messi's shot entered on goal. Not a mistake at all, but...

    He also conceded a PK before, supported by VAR.

    ReplyDelete
  10. In the Man. City v Arsenal game the 3-1 goal scored by undeliberate handball. It won't be possible in UEFA Champions League's knock-out stage as UEFA don't want goals scored by hand. Clear violation of the LotG until they are changed though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There was an example for that in Bundesliga as well yesterday:
      https://www2.pic-upload.de/img/36343588/ezgif.com-video-to-gif397.gif
      Goal was allowed and the decision was widely accepted.

      Delete
  11. Maresca in Roma- Milan:

    - no penalty for Milan after a foul of Kolarov against Suso (no OFR)
    - missed 2nd yellow for Pellegrini 82' (foul from behind)

    ReplyDelete
  12. PK whistled by Turpin in OL-PSG : what do you think ?

    https://streamable.com/jtafw

    ReplyDelete
  13. https://mobile.twitter.com/PSG_inside/status/1092201449226948609

    Another controversial decision during this match : only a YC after this foul...

    ReplyDelete
  14. What do you think about that ?
    Goal or offside
    No reaction AR & no reaction VAR

    https://youtu.be/QwV_jbJhSIY

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is a clear offside, very worrying if VAR missed it...

      Delete
    2. At least 3 meter offside, what is VAR doing? and also the assistant should easily see that.

      Delete
    3. What is VAR doing? VAR is doing what too many VAR's are doing and more worryingly, willing to do. And what exactly is that? It's VAR's who are unwilling to "expose" their fellow referee's and put the obvious mistakes "on blast". Benefit of the doubt will forever impede VAR from truly being effective.

      Delete
    4. I think, that the VAR just not realized the potential offsiof. Which shows that nowadays, players need to protest to make sure, VAR checks a situation...

      Delete
  15. Wrong decision by AR2 because onside. For me is offside and no goal for Liverpool

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He was out of position. I have to say that both assistant referees in this game were pretty awful. Many mistakes leading to goal scoring opportunities.

      Delete
  16. Women's WC referees are undergoing VAR training in preparation for this summer's championship in France.

    https://www.apnews.com/c385be9640054f1c8873cce45ae5efad

    Thanks to refereeingworld blog!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Would be interesting, who the male VARs are there (considering that most of the UEFA experts are in Malaga this week).

      Delete
  17. In addition to VAR gathering in Malaga, yesterday there was also a meeting betweeen Rosetti and all the 16 coaches of CL teams. He explained the VAR system. English teams for sure were the most interested in that, they had only some experiments in FA Cup while all the other ones have regularly VAR in their leagues.

    ReplyDelete
  18. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZ48sKKx8ZQ
    Another VAR example from the Netherlands.
    Not clear and obvious IMO, therefore the VAR asks the referee, whether he has seen the holding. He denies that, so the OFR makes a lot of sense.
    There I would accept both decisions by the referee, because there is a lot of holding, but the player seems to fall down anyway.
    Also, the goal of the offending team could not really be avoided in this case, there was no good opportunity to stop the game and it's understandable that the check took quite long.
    (Referee: van den Kerkhof, VAR: Makkelie)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correct PK. I liked what you pointed out, Makkelie suggesting a review for something van den Kerkhof completely missed not because of a misjudgement but because he hasn't seen it.

      Delete
  19. OT: Situation in Spanish 3rd division match.

    Reckless challenge or SFP? (referee decided to issue a straight red, maybe because of the speed of play and the danger the challenge has in those kind of situatuons?)

    https://streamable.com/r3469

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Supportable decision IMO, I would have been ok with just a yellow tough.

      Delete
  20. I'm always complaining that the overly lenient line of referees nowadays is dangerous for players. In the Bundesliga, two shocking RC challenges weren't punished at all (YC in the first scene, no pk or foul call in the second) in the last two weeks. Both players are injured severely and won't be able to play again this season.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I will repeat myself once again: Fröhlich and Drees should be sacked.

      Delete
  21. https://imgur.com/a/KuXteZ3

    Not a RC in Germany.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OK, I was not aware of Stindl's injury.
      IMO it is not a clear RC, because the player pulls back and therefore the intensity (and the danger for the opponent) is not high.
      http://i.imgur.com/OJxQn1M.gif
      http://i.imgur.com/QzzjmoZ.gif

      Delete
    2. Stindl wasn't. I was referring to this one with regard to the second injury: http://images.sportbuzzer.de/v1/photos/raw/fussball-1-bundesliga-saison-2018-2019-19-spieltag-borussia-dortmund-hanno-x5995/regular-16-9

      Delete
    3. Nitpicking about the "intensity" of these type of unesacary and dangerous tackles is one of the reason why we continue to see them. Add to this a bunch of limp wristed, no backbone having, afraid to show the Red Card "modern" referee's. And the brutality will continue. But hey, as long as there are 22 players on the pitch when you blow your final whistle. You've complied with your orders and you're a success, right?

      Delete
  22. Interview with Rosetti in a German magazine
    kicker: With the start of the knockout phase of the current Champions League, the video assistant referee (VAR) will make its debut in this competition next week. UEFA President Ceferin hesitated for a long time with the introduction because he did not find the technology ripe yet. Is it now, Mr. Rosetti?

    Rosetti: "I would not call that a hesitation, Aleksander Ceferin is very serious and professional, he just wanted to be quite sure, he wanted to get the necessary feedback from everyone: what's important for TV stations, is there a technical problem, what says the provider, and he wanted me to guarantee that the referees were ready for it. "

    kicker: What motivated him to give the green light?

    Rosetti: "We did a lot of good testing, and our provider gave the warrants to carry it out, and so did I." Then the UEFA Executive Committee decided to introduce it. It's not just a referee project, it's a football project, we're doing it to reduce the referees' wrong decisions and for the benefit of football, we know that this project is not perfect, but if you ask the referees if they want VAR or not, everyone will say he wants it. "

    kicker: You looked at the VAR in different leagues and countries. What differences have you identified and what conclusions have been drawn?

    Rosetti: "In my opinion we had to clarify the idea of ​​the VAR and come back a little bit on the principle of the VAR. We only want to use this tool in case of obvious mistakes. The VAR should only intervene with a clear proof. The referee should not be sent to an OFR for every doubt. No, that's not the point, we need to protect the football, we love this game, we only need the VAR if we make clear mistakes. "

    kicker: You say "clear mistakes". That's exactly what the responsible people in Germany say. But we have a lot of discussion here about what a clear mistake is.

    Rosetti: "Not only in Germany ..."

    kicker: So what does the term "clearly wrong decision" mean?

    Rosetti: "Again: The VAR may only intervene if a referee's mistake is provable, only with evidence from the camera images, if he is sure that it is a mistake immediately after looking at the scene, he must intervene. In addition, we are working very hard on standardization, because we have to have a consistent line in these interventions, and for some decisions, the limit on interventions is very low because we have clear facts, for example about the place where something happened. This applies to offside situations where we use the 3-D technology with lines, the best that is currently on the market, here the VAR must intervene - without any doubt - or in deciding whether a foul happened within or outside the penalty area or if the ball was already out of play during the attacking move before a goal. "

    kicker: But this uniqueness is not always given.

    Rosetti: "Many situations in football leave scope for interpretation, but there are also differences here, for example: someone in the penalty area is clearly getting stepped on his foot - of course there is room for interpretation, but this is limited by the fact that somebody stepped on the foot. That's where the VAR can intervene. Or a clear kick. If we clearly have that in the picture, we can intervene because it's the interpretation of a fact. But then there are 50-50 situations, too. For example, a collision between two players is a subjective assessment by the referee, and in such situations the level for interventions is very, very high, because that is a decision of the referee, who must feel the power and intensity of the scene. It's not a matter of pictures, it has to be decided on the pitch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. kicker: What happens when players claim the VAR?

      We have instructed the referees to show yellow cards for clear gestures, i.e. forming a screen with their hands. It's the same as when a player demands a YC for an opponent. "

      kicker: It's still all about the four complexes: confusion of players, penalties, red cards and goals?

      Rosetti: "Yes, we have to make it clear that there is only one protocol written by IFAB and that we have to follow 100%. It's not yellow cards, not 2nd yellow cards, not normal fouls - just four cases, we work a lot on these individual topics, like penalties, red cards, etc. And all the topics have sub-points, because there are a lot of different penalties and for all of them we define the limit to the intervention of the VAR. "

      kicker: There are also the 30/70 decisions, for example in a duel. The referee assesses it on the field, but notes after the game that the decision was rather wrong, but there were also arguments for his decision. He is therefore at 30 percent. Should the VAR intervene in these cases as well, or do yousay, with such small mistakes we have to live?

      Rosetti: "I only want the intervention if the VAR has proof, if he's sure it's a penalty, it's a red card, but not if it's a 'maybe' or an 'in my opinion'. Because we have to protect football, we can not interrupt four or five times, we do not want to re-referee the game. "

      kicker: The majority of German fans are still critical of the VAR because of the mistakes that have happened. Is the VAR's use in the Bundesliga a role model for UEFA? Some things worked well too.

      Rosetti: "The VAR will not lead to no discussions going on. Not just in the Bundesliga, but everywhere we are talking: in Italy, in Spain, in France, it is the same - we just have to work on unification, but absolute unity is utopian, impossible, we still have a great deal to do to reduce the differences in interpretation. "

      kicker: Lutz Michael Fröhlich, referee boss of the Bundesliga, said in an interview that the way the VAR is used in the Bundesliga is rated better internationally than in Germany. Do you agree?

      Rosetti: "I can say that the German referees are doing a very good job in the UEFA competitions, and I am really pleased with the performances of Felix Brych, Felix Zwayer and Daniel Siebert. Daniel has refereed his first match in the Champions League, he is very young and I've known him for many years, he does that really well and the German referees are very important to this project. "

      kicker: And how do you assess the way, how the VAR is used in the Bundesliga?

      Rosetti: "I generally do not talk about the leagues, but as I said, we have German referees in our competitions who do a very good job and who already have a lot of good experience with VAR from the Bundesliga."

      kicker: Is the image internationally more positive than nationally?

      Rosetti: "Well, there's a lot of discussion going on, the championship is very long with a lot of games, so of course it's easy to see some inconsistency in the decisions, and I do not want to be too specific about that."

      Delete
    2. kicker: Were too high expectations attached to the introduction of the VAR - keywords: infallibility of technology, no more wrong decisions?

      Rosetti: "You're right, the expectations are high, but we've made some progress, and a few years ago we discussed goals in which the scorer was one meter offside, which is not possible anymore. Or, many years ago, we talked about a goal scored with the hand, and that's no longer possible, now we're talking about a possible handball, about a possible unnatural hand position. This project is still young, we have only started two years ago. Of course, we can not turn back the clock, so now we have to work on improving this project. "

      kicker: Are you afraid that despite the introduction of the VAR there will continue to be great discussions about handball situations?

      Rosetti: "Handball is probably the most complicated topic, there is a lot of discussion going on all over football, and the IFAB is working on the subject to help the referees and make the complex clearer to everyone. If the VAR has a proof for a deliberate handball, he should intervene. Or, if the arm protrudes unnaturally from the body at shoulder height or beyond, the VAR must intervene in the same way. But of course the grey area continues to exist and the referee must decide on the court and consider auxiliary parameters such as distance, speed, arm and ball movement in his decision, which is then not a case for the VAR. "

      kicker: Often discussed are, for example, scenes in which a player who makes a sliding tackele gets the ball on his hand. Punishable or not?

      Rosetti: "We just had a meeting of the UEFA elite referees in Lisbon and of course we talked about handball. There are two situations: Either the player tries to play the ball or he tries to block it. There's a big difference. When you hit the ball, you need your arms for balance, which is natural. But when the arm on the floor is splayed and stretched, it's not natural. Of course, if a player uses his arms to increase his body area to block it, it's just as unnatural and punishable. "

      kicker: There are voices that have identified new emotions, new moments of tension through VAR decisions. Like last year's DFB Cup Final, when all the spectators and players were looking forward to the decision of Felix Zwayer in the Review Area shortly before the end, whether there is a penalty for Bayern or not. Is it just a matter of getting used to the VAR?

      Rosetti: "Yeah, that kind of creates a lot of emotions. Three years ago we discussed that the VAR will destroy the emotions, but the opposite is the case, we have twice as many emotions. In the beginning we were very worried about the time. But nobody talks about the time anymore. "

      kicker: What do you mean?

      Rosetti: "For the crucial scene of a match, one minute and 30 seconds is nothing, we lose eight minutes per game for free kicks, seven minutes for throw-ins, four minutes for corner kicks. The most important thing is to work for a reliable and correct tool for the referees."

      kicker: It seems like the problems and issues shift from the lawn to the monitors. Is this the future of football?

      Rosetti: "We are aware of that, but what is very important is that we still want the referee to be in the center of the decision-making process and that he makes the final decision. VAR can make factual decisions - offside yes or no, foul inside or outside the penalty area - and the referee makes the final decision without having to go to the monitor. But for all subjective cases where the VAR has clear evidence, the referee must judge himself on the monitor because he will continue the game and explain to the players, what happened. Otherwise the players say, who is the VAR? Where is he? We do not see him. Who is with him? "

      Delete
    3. kicker: Where will the VAR be in the Champions League? Will there be video centers like Cologne in the Bundesliga or Moscow at the World Cup?

      Rosetti: "No, they will be in the stadium."

      kicker: Will the fans in the stadium also be able to see the relevant VAR scenes on the screens or are there only text graphics like in the Bundesliga?

      Rosetti: "As in the Bundesliga, there will only be text graphics."

      kicker: Is it planned to show scenes to the fans in the stadium?

      Rosetti: "It's a young project and we're working to increase transparency and objectivity, and that could be part of it in the future."

      kicker: How many people does a video team have?

      Rosetti: "A VAR, an assistant to the VAR, an operator and an assistant to the operator plus a background UEFA official who simply communicates the reason for a review and then the final decision via tablet to the respective stadium director and TV channels and is not involved in the decision-making process. "

      Delete
    4. Thanks, Philipp, for translation!!!

      Delete
    5. Thank you so much Philipp! :)

      Delete
  23. An article about the Women seminar in Doha:
    https://www.fifa.com/womensworldcup/news/womens-referee-course-under-way-in-doha

    ReplyDelete
  24. OT

    Spanish Jesus Gil Manzano will be in charge of the derby PAOK - Olympiakos on Sunday night. His assistants will be Raul Cabanero Martinez and Diego Barbero Sevilla. Fourth official will be Tasos Sidiropoulos and observer Juan Antonio Fernandex Marin.

    ReplyDelete
  25. OT:

    Facebook video abut how referees worked during AFC Asian Cup.

    https://www.facebook.com/hakan.anaz.1/videos/10155967838307724/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hello Philipp. Sorry but these images are terrible. How it’s Possible on earth to tolerate YC here ? I’m speechless...

    ReplyDelete
  27. OT:
    Lahoz with a good performance in El Clasico.
    He handled "hot" situations really well, calmed ppayers down and in my opinion proved that he is Spain's numero uno.All his bookings were justified but I dont know why Alba got one right after Barca goal.
    Maybe Alba was complaining about no penalty call ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't seen much, but I have read Alba got it for dissent - apparently, he had been fouled by gk Navas right before the goal was scored and demanded some punishment for that.

      Also, he missed a rather blatant foul on Alba shortly after the break. But good to hear he was good apart from that!

      Delete
    2. One wonders how can somebody be as stupid as Jordi Alba was on that situation. You say you've been fouled (which, live, I think he had not), but in the end you have scored a goal, so you have got the greatest advantage you could get. Why do you go to the referee instead of celebrate the goal? And so it is stated by Mateu in the match report: "On the 58th minute, player (18) Alba Ramos, Jorge was cautioned for the following reason: show dissent to one of my decisions when his team had just scored a goal.". For those who speak spanish and are interested: http://actas.rfef.es/actas/RFEF_CmpActa2?cod_primaria=1000144&CodActa=54613

      Delete
    3. So for Spanish cup and league, the referee reports are published online? I wasn't aware of that, thank you very much for the link!

      And yes, rather senseless.

      Delete
    4. Spanish 1st, 2nd, 3rd Division and Copa del Rey matches' reports are published online, yes. :)

      And you have free access since 2003/2004 season. Very useful and entertaining if you can read Spanish or translate it.

      Main page link:

      http://actas.rfef.es/actas/RFEF_CmpJornada?cod_primaria=1000144&CodCategoria=100

      Delete
    5. Thank you, yes it is indeed a very useful database - and entertaining as well! :)

      Delete
  28. OT
    Serbian referee update.
    Not sure if this is true but i heard that AAR2 from Mazics team Nenad Djokic has retired.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe this was the reason for which there were two different versions of Serbian list for 2019 and some confusion, UEFA had still Nenad Đokić in its categories, while FIFA removed him. One can guess he was in doubt whether to retire or not until the last days...

      Delete
    2. Rumors says that he retired because he lost FIFA badge..

      Delete

Thank you for writing a comment on our blog!