Friday, 21 April 2023

2022-23 UEFA Youth League - Semifinals and Final Appointments - Willy Delajod (FRA) in charge of the final

The following officials have been appointed by UEFA to referee the last three games of 2022-23 UEFA Youth League. The final will be officiated by Willy Delajod (FRA)




Semi-Finals

Friday 21 April 2023

13:00 CET - Geneva (Stade de Genève)
Sporting CP (POR) - AZ Alkmaar (NED)
Referee: Manfredas Lukjančukas LTU
Assistant Referee 1: Mangirdas Mirauskas LTU
Assistant Referee 2: Vytenis Kazlauskas LTU
Fourth Official: Luca Cibelli SUI
UEFA Referee Observer: Roberto Rosetti ITA
UEFA Delegate: Kurt Zuppinger SUI

18:00 CET - Geneva (Stade de Genève)
HNK Hajduk Split (CRO) - AC Milan (ITA)
Referee: Rohit Saggi NOR
Assistant Referee 1: Morten Jensen NOR
Assistant Referee 2: Anders Olav Dale NOR
Fourth Official: Alessandro Dudic SUI
UEFA Referee Observer: Björn Kuipers NED
UEFA Delegate: Kurt Zuppinger SUI

Final

Monday 24 April 2023

18:00 CET - Geneva (Stade de Genève)
AZ Alkmaar (NED) - HNK Hajduk Split (CRO)
Referee: Willy Delajod FRA
Assistant Referee 1: Erwan Finjean FRA
Assistant Referee 2: Cyril Mugnier FRA
Fourth Official: Thomas Léonard FRA
UEFA Referee Observer: Carlos Velasco Carballo ESP
UEFA Delegate: Kurt Zuppinger SUI

98 comments:

  1. Good choice to me; I was expecting a step ahead for Saggi and Delajod. I supposed they were assigned to Euro U21. When will officially publish the list of the referee for Euro U21 ?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Any news about Uefa payment system?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Since 2018 (Ekberg), only referees from the Big 5 countries have refereed the Youth League final. That's really disappointing: this tournament isn't just a development tournament for youth players, the same applies to referees - the final should be given to someone who could really use this for their development (since their national competition offers them too little opportunities), not someone who officiates teams like Bayern, Liverpool and PSG every other week

    ReplyDelete
  4. ISIDRO DÍAZ DE MERA is one of few refs that impresses me more and more in La Liga.

    With only 33 yrs old,he can be next future of Spain but I doubt that will happen,cause his matches tend zo end with plenty bookings and right,why have ref that makes every decision and punishes evry foul like it should be...

    His matches are quite like younger Maresca,plenty bookings and hot teams,but almost every his decision is by the book .

    I say ,his style reminds me of younger Maresca or in Portugal we have 2 refs that are similar to him,Oliveira and Godinho.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. RC for DOGSO in 70':

      https://streamin.me/v/5f0a4c82

      Delete
  5. Tonight's Bundesliga top game and potential title decider between Bayern München and Borussia Dortmund (18:30 CET):
    Marco Fritz, Dominik Schaal, Marcel Pelgrim, Frank Willenborg - Benjamin Brand, Thorsten Schiffner

    ReplyDelete
  6. An interesting documentary on the career of Maria Sole Ferrieri Caputi, the first woman to officiate in serie A. It's called "Un giorno di Sole" = "A day of Sun" (in Italian: Sole = Sun).
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QBw9BnXSB1o
    You can activate the subtitles on youtube in your language.

    ReplyDelete
  7. OT:

    71st min.Chelsea-Villa

    How is that not booking for Havertz?

    GK infrigment...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Clearly there was no SPA, so no need for a yellow.

      Delete
  8. Did mohd salleh subkhiddin malaysia ex- international referee deserved to referee at least one match in world cup both 2006 and 2010 ? I think he deserved it in 2006 he was better than kamikawa japan and khalil alghamdi saudi arabia ( reserve in Germany )

    ReplyDelete
  9. https://twitter.com/i/status/1642571636246298624

    penalty or not
    Referee: Jasper Vergoote
    VAR: Nicolas Laforge

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. At least acceptable penalty as the hand is 'extended laterally away from the body'.

      Delete
    2. https://scontent-bru2-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/339573034_751996963206441_2502010443265988150_n.jpg?stp=cp6_dst-jpg&_nc_cat=110&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=dbeb18&_nc_ohc=a2fqjFCw0pIAX8KwLpg&_nc_ht=scontent-bru2-1.xx&oh=00_AfAkpc6yOOhEDa9PFI5PbthiNRk7XWEUnb3nFVfK_gMCrQ&oe=642E6572

      Photo of the contact

      Delete
    3. I think the expected decision here is a penalty kick. Also, VAR cannot intervene for me.

      Delete
  10. https://streamable.com/sokxce

    Unthinkable decision at yesterday Alexey Kulbakov's performace at PAOK-AEK ATHENS for the Greece play-offs. In 5th minute of the match the player of the PAOK makes a mistake and gives the ball back to his GK without seeing that the striker of AEK haw followed the phase. But the Belarusian referee whistled something which not the same has understood. Even now whole Greece is wondering what has given in that phase. In addition, that whistle appears intention because he whistled before AEK's player score, with purpose neither VAR (Krogh from Denmark) can interfere to correct that monstrous decision.
    However, to be fair he managed very well the whole match, but his decision in the beginning of the match marked his appearance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It would be interesting to know the exact moment of the whistle, not clear in this video. If he whistled moments before and players continued the action it can be more understandable for some aspects, but still a mistake because phantom foul whistled. If the whistle occurred after the goal, then VAR could have intervened.

      Delete
    2. It is assumed that he whistled before AEK's player score. But nobody (not the same) knows what has whistled. The video includes all the available replays and we don't have other replays from other aspects. But if you notice carefully until the camera lose the referee from the plan he haven't whistled something yet (a foul maybe) and he is running to catch up the phase. Therefore given that we don't have any offside, because the ball returns from PAOK's playerthe only epxlanation is that he had given defensive foul at Gacinovic (AEK's player) in the middle and he didn't olay well the advantage. But the match restarts with the possession at PAOK with a free kick!!!!

      Delete
    3. Anyway, the media in Greece today have publicized that after the end of the match AEK's player asked from the referee the cause of the cancellation and he characteristically moved his shoulders not knowing what to reply, staying silence!

      Delete
    4. Very weird situation, and if indeed the whistle was for offside, the offence happened far away from where the eventual free kick was taken

      Delete
  11. Greece

    Wed 5 April 2023

    18:30 Áris - Panathinaïkós AO
    Tamás Bognár - Balázs Buzás, Péter Kóbor (all HUN)
    [Balázs Berke HUN]

    20:00 Olymbiakós SFP - PAOK
    François Letexier - Cyril Mugnier, Mehdi Rahmouni (all FRA)
    [Pierre Gaillouste FRA]

    ReplyDelete
  12. Barça vs R Madrid
    Referee:Juan Martinez Munuera
    Var: González González

    ReplyDelete
  13. after u20 wc was taken from peru, now the u17 wc was taken from peru...a bit early, as it would still be half a year to go. peru could not provide sufficient infrastructure and supply financial guarantees. in my eyes a bit odd, to to this half a year before, when you already chose the country some years ago?

    ReplyDelete
  14. My UCL predictions:
    RMA-CHE: Vincic
    CHE-RMA: Orsato

    BEN-INT: Taylor
    INT-BEN: Turpin

    MCI-BAY: Del Cerro Grande
    BAY-MCI: Marciniak

    AC-NAP: Makkelie
    NAP-AC: Oliver

    My UEL predictions:
    MNU-SEV: Days
    SEV-MNU: Umut Meler

    JUV-SPO: Nyberg
    SPO-JUV: Jovanovic

    LEV-USG: Gozubuyuk
    USG-LEV: Kruzliak

    FEY-ROM: Zwayer
    ROM-FEY: Letexier

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Without Kovacs in all competitions? i think Kovacs will get a QF games, but I don't know what games. And maybe the final of the Nations League. Now I get why are so many important observer in this round. I think they will choose the refs for the finals.

      Delete
    2. I put Kovacs for an SF, knowing that there can be a CHE-MCI SF, I prefer to use Taylor and Oliver in QF

      Delete
    3. Yes, i agree with you, to have Kovacs in semifinal.

      Delete
  15. appointments The Netherlands Semi-final Dutch Cup

    4-4-23 20:00

    Spakenburg - PSV
    Ref: Manschout
    AR1: Goossens
    AR2: Vandeursen
    FO: Nagtegaal
    VAR: Kamphuis
    AVAR: Inia

    5-4-23 20:00
    Feyenoord - AJAX
    Ref: Lindhout
    AR1: Honig
    AR2: Bluemink
    FO: Kooij
    VAR: van Boekel
    AVAR: Diks

    Debut for Lindhout in the Dutch classic match between Feyenoord and AJAX. Very hot match since Feyenoord is a few points ahead and probable take over the title from rivals AJAX. The Cup is for AJAX the only option to win a title this season.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Any predictions for the U17 and U19 finals? Damian Sylwestrzak from Poland has a chance in your opinion? He refereed 4 matches of the youth league at a high level, he was a great referee at the U19 qualifying tournament in Spain...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Early prediction:

      U17 (8): Theoulí (CYP), Berka (CZE), Levy (ISR), Sylwestrzak (POL), Milanović (SRB), Smajc (SVN), Masiyev (AZE) & Ladebäck (SWE)

      U19 (6): Bogár (HUN), Schlager (GER), Xhaja (ALB), Jenkins (WAL), Gishamer (AUT) & Kooij (NED)

      Delete
    2. My prediction
      U19: Delajod (FRA), Fesnic (ROU), Obrenovic (SVN), Saggi (NOR), Walsh (SCO), Xhaja (ALB)
      U17: Bilbija (BIH), Jaanovits (EST), Jenkins (WAL), Kooij (NED), Manouhos (GRE), Milanovic (SRB), Kurgheli (BLR), Sylwestrzak (POL),

      Delete
  17. I note Frappart will lead the team in the Finalissima on Thursday. Interesting to see a very different approach to in the men's competition were a much less experienced name was appointed. I'm concerned about the lack of development in women's officials in a way, where it seems only one name is trusted for everything. After Steinhaus-Webb's retirement it is clear that Frappart is the no.1, but it would be nice to have a more trusted pool to choose from, it's not like there aren't options! Another deserved accolade for Frappart, however

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, I would give Monzul and Staubli more chances.
      Monzul has had many opportunities (Euro Final/UEL/UECL) but it seems that she has disappeared.
      And I have always considered Staubli, after Frappart, the second best referee in Europe.
      Only there are no opportunities for her.

      Delete
    2. Less so Monzul, but I also have rated Staubli highly every time I've seen her, and think she has been unlucky to get so few top top appointments

      Delete
  18. Aleksandar Mitrović has been given an 8 match ban for shoving Chris Kavanagh and showing aggressive language and behaviour afterwards.

    On the other hand, Mexican FIFA referee Fernando Hernández has been suspended for 12 matches for his VC against a player (said player has been suspended for 2 matches)

    ReplyDelete
  19. According the Guardian, The FA intends to appeal against the eight-game ban. In addition, there was a fine of +/- 86,000 euro.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Finalissima Brazil vs England:

    Referee: Stéphanie Frappart (France)
    ARs: Elodie Coppola, Manuela Nicolosi (France)
    FO: Esther Staubli (Switzerland)
    VARs: Jérôme Brisard, Maika Vanderstichel (France)

    ReplyDelete
  21. What a mess after final whistle Juve-Inter...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://youtu.be/34-jE64EdPQ

      Delete
    2. https://youtu.be/g-8No0Tr8Xo

      Delete
    3. Disgracefull cards by Massa for Lukaku after his reaction to the racist chants. Then you dont understand it as a referee imo

      Delete
    4. As a non-avid Italian football viewer, maybe someone more familiar could explain if harsh yellows for any gesture to the crowd are the norm in Serie A, as to me I'm struggling to understand how you get anywhere near a caution for what Lukaku did assuming it was for something in the celebration. Now I am aware there are some things that seem difficult to understand for folks from other countries when it comes to Italian sanctions for words/gestures (such as the anti-blasphemy suspensions), so maybe there's something odd here? But I really don't understand it and feel greatly for Lukaku

      Delete
    5. The situation should be the following: according to last rumors, it seems as Rocchi has appreciated the officiating by Massa and I must agree, a very good performance at least until last minutes of second half, including the penalty call (possible that this was suggested by either AR1 or FO, you can see the delay in whistling by Massa). Then, coming into your question, we must start from the fact that Massa didn't hear about any racist chant, so for this reason he thought that the celebration of Lukaku was against the home-fans. Indeed the Inter player made the gesture and said "shut up". This, according to book, is identified as provoking celebration, so correct yellow card. There isn't a strict application of this rule in serie A and I must say that if we start from assumption that the racist chants were not heard by referee, the technical decision is just a correct one...
      Now Lukaku and Internazionale are complaining about that and we must wait the decisions that will be taken by disciplinary board (very likely tomorrow). In case, it is possible that they will take time to make a deep analysis of what happened on the stands during the game.

      Delete
  22. Bayern Freiburg,late penalty,thoughts?


    https://youtu.be/CdyNC8b4b2s

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correct penalty IMO. A deflection from his body doesn't change the fact he jumped with his arms above his head.

      Delete
  23. Saudi Arabia

    Sat 1 April 2023

    21:00 Al-Hilal Riyadh - Al-Khaleej Saihat
    João Pinheiro - Bruno Jesus, Luciano Maia (all POR)
    [Hélder Malheiro POR]

    Tue 4 April 2023

    21:00 Al-Ittihad Jiddah - Damak
    Istvan Kovacs - Vasile Florin Marinescu, Mihai Ovidiu Artene (all ROU)
    [Ovidiu Alin Hațegan ROU]


    Kuwait

    Sat 1 April 2023

    20:30 Al-Kuwait - As-Salmiyah
    Kristo Tohver EST
    [Juri Frischer EST]

    20:30 Kazma - Al-Fahaiheel
    Vítor Ferreira POR
    [Fábio Melo POR]


    Cypriot Cup Semi-Finals

    Wed 5 April 2023

    18:00 Olymbiakós Lefkosías - AEL Lemesoú
    Livio Marinelli ITA
    [Marco Serra ITA]

    Thu 6 April 2023

    18:00 Páfos - Omónia Lefkosías
    Rosario Abisso ITA
    [Daniele Paterna ITA]

    ReplyDelete
  24. IMO very good performance by Martínez Munuera in the Copa del Rey semifinal 2nd leg Clásico today, including a correct PK for Real Madrid. Not faultless, maybe a couple of missed de iure bookings, but probably one of the best performances in recent Clásicos, considering the huge tension.

    My general perception of Martínez Munuera is that there's no refereeing 'attribute' (disciplinary, fitness, personality, presence...) in which he's a 10/10, but instead he's a 7/10 or 8/10 in everything

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In General I agree with your opinion. But there is one thing totally annoing me about him. He needs so much time for couple of Things (don't know whether that was the case yesterday because i could not see the game). For example he sometimes blows the whistle and then about ten seconds later realizes that he needs to Take his Spray or has to communicate with some Players which then also Takes a relatively Long Time itself. Don't know whether you also recognized that but this is often my Feeling when i am watching His games

      Delete
  25. Hi. Do you know which referee will be in charge of Panathinaikos and Olimpiacos on sunday?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Del Cerro Grande - Guadalupe Porras - Garcia Gonzalez (Ever ESP)

      [Hernández Hernández] (ESP)

      Delete
  26. Right now another very poor performance by Mariani in an important serie A game. At first they changed a wrong penalty in free kick, but in my opinion this was just a strategy to avoid a mandatory OFR, and then a few minutes ago missed penalty for reckless challenge by keeper and OFR.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Rojas again with his usual leniency...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On the occasion of today usual Rojas's performance in the Osasuna - Real Betis, who do you think are the most lenient referees in the 5 major leagues (England, France, Germany, Italy and Spain). For example, in France I can easily understand that it is Turpin.

      Delete
    2. From Germany, I would say, some of the young ones are most lenient: Reichel, Badstübner, Jöllenbeck, Jablonski
      Among the senior ones: Stieler and Hartmann

      Delete
    3. Spain:Rojas

      France:Wattellier imo,Turpin's close,but not like Wattellier...

      England:Hooper,Oliver...

      Italy:Doveri and that's not even close,what he allows is sometimes funny to me.

      Orsato is also lately very lenient and Sacchi.

      Portugal:Goncalves

      Germany:I dont follow that much,but then I have to agree with Philipp S.

      Brazil:Goncalves Lima,he is different level,maybe the most lenient ref in the whole world.

      Also from same country,Daronco,very lenient ref.

      Delete
    4. I had a look at the card statistics and based on them one could say.
      Spain:
      Least cards: Alberola Rojas (clearly as indicated by M), de Burgos, Pizarro Gomez
      Most cards: Muniz Ruiz, Diaz de Mera, Hernandez

      France:
      Least cards: Bollengier, Wattelier, Batta (and then Turpin)
      Most cards: Vernice, Pignard, Bastien

      England:
      Least cards: Hooper, Gillett, A.Madley (Oliver is on place 6)
      Most cards: Salisbury, Brooks, Bankes

      Italy:
      Least cards: Marinelli, Sacchi, Marchetti (among the more prominent ones: Chiffi and Doveri)
      Most cards: Marcenaro, Maresca, Valeri

      Germany:
      Least cards: Reichel, Badstübner, Jöllenbeck
      Most cards: Ittrich, Schröder, Schlager

      All five leagues together:
      Least cards: Hooper, Reichel, Gillett
      Least cards among CL referees: Oliver, Stieler, Taylor
      Most cards: Marcenaro, Muniz Ruiz, Diaz de Mera
      Most cards among CL referees: Hernandez, Gil Manzano, Sanchez
      Order among the leagues: England, Germany, France, Italy, Spain

      Method: 1 point for YC, 3 points for 2nd YC, 5 points for RC
      Average per game for all games in the domestic highest league
      Minimum 10 games done in that league

      Delete
    5. Class Philipp on the research.

      Delete
    6. As those were also mentioned
      Portugal
      Least cards: Pinheiro, Almeida, Mota
      Most cards: J. Ferreira, Correia, Martins

      Brazil
      Least cards: Goncalves Lima, Alves Batista, Schleich
      Most cards: Pombo, Zanovelli, Machado

      Ferreira and Correia actually take place 2 and 3 for most cards in all those leagues and Portugal overall has even more cards than Spain, while Brazil ranks between France and Italy.

      Delete
    7. @philipp s, great work, thanks a lot. question: is this cards per game? interesting would be to see this in relation to fouls?

      Delete
  28. OT: Strukan gave correct YC for simulation in the last seconds of the game, and player's, lets just say very unusual reaction :))

    https://streamable.com/ezemiu

    ReplyDelete
  29. What a poor performance by Sanchez Martinez in Barca-Atletico. I had some expectations given his European appointments, including a recent UEL QF. Did Mourinho have nothing to complain about against Feyenoord? I am very dissapointed after this game today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The PK he whistled in FEYROM was in favor of Roma, so no complaints by JM ofc. Penalty was wrong in my book. Other than that, his management was decent, and like most 1st legs it was less challenging than the return

      Delete
    2. Mixed feelings....

      We see the difference in 1st half and 2nd half.

      1st was lenient style,card must be shown when it is a foul that requires card,like Alonso one.

      2nd one was different.

      He was like you get a card,you get card,that reminded me of his earlier days in Primera when he had plenty matches with 10plus cards.

      And about non penalty in dying minutes.

      I will say this;I agree with no penalty.
      However,we saw this year penalties being given for far less.

      Delete
  30. Is there a list for officials for UEFA U17 and U19 finals?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, I'm sorry, in past UEFA cared about the official publication of the names, recently the focus on refereeing in these tournaments has been almost abolished... that's not good if you ask me. As long as there aren't official confirmations, we can't publish any name...

      Delete
  31. Makkelie is in Saudi Super Cup Semifinal between Al Ittihad vs Al Hilal tonight. He's not injured as many people predicted days ago.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Clips of late penalties awarded by Daniel Siebert in PAOK vs. Panathinaikos today:

    https://streamable.com/l2r7hn
    https://streamable.com/ozo7f7

    (involvement in both scenes for VAR Sascha Stegemann)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All correct after VAR interventions, first incident clear penalty but Siebert couldn't see the foul properly (best replay 00:40), maybe he could have struggled, trying to detect more. Rather passive appearance, but a miss that can happen.
      Second case, correct penalty call live and then offside, a mistake from AR2 that you can understand.

      Delete
    2. Var changed this morning…manouchos from Greece

      Delete
  33. The Juventus-Napoli game was going so good for Fabbri. A pity that now both teams are angry with him. I really liked his performance so far.

    ReplyDelete
  34. For me scandalous decision in Juve-Napoli to annul Juve's goal. Is this a VAR stuff??? What is VAR stuff??? Referee was 3 meters away from that "foul", het let the play, and was called for an OFR for alleged foul. There was some contact, but was that enough to annul a goal. For me very wrong decision from VAR ref.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. No VAR stuff, not clear and obvious wrong.

      Delete
    2. So what about the possible violent conduct by Gatti before? To me, another shocking performance by Fabbri overall and this must be his lasta appearance in a big match.

      Delete
    3. I am shocked that he gets big games after big games.

      He is not that kind of ref.

      These matches should be given given top Italian refs,like Massa,Mariani,Orsato and Maresca(imo not Doveri).

      We all remember couple of years ago his performance when Lazio were playing Juve.

      He is somehow center of attention whenever ge has these big games.

      And to add,tonight's perfromance had so much inconsistencies,no clear line on what is booking and what is not,letting conflicts and not being authoritative enough.

      Delete
    4. I agree that his appointment was unexpected given the teams implied, but, meh... from 20' when I started watching the game to ~70' was at least ok performance. After that, he completely lost it, the final quarter of the match was a disaster.

      Delete
  35. Scandalous decisions in Bosnia, especially the first one.

    https://streamable.com/zypgmb

    ReplyDelete
  36. Greece
    Play offs appointments 26l04

    Aris Thessalonikis - Olympiacos Piraeus Danny Makkelie, H.Steegstra, J. De-Vries, VAR: R.Dieperinik

    AEK Athens - PAOK Thessaloniki
    Tobias Stieler, C.Gittelmann, R. Kempter, VAR: P.Mueller

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Will be interesting, who gets the big Panathinaikos-AEK on Sunday. Marciniak or Orsato maybe?

      Delete
    2. Judging from the very good relations that Mr. Bennett has had lately with the German and Italian federations, I would say that it is more likely that an elite referee from Italy will come. And possibly orsato. Also, unless I'm making a horrible mistake Marciniak has never come to Greece to officiate a game between Greek teams!

      Delete
    3. Marciniak was in charge of PAOK-Aris 2-2, on 7 March 2021. That's the only time he has been appointed in the greek league.

      Delete
  37. Dutch Cup Final:

    Ajax - PSV (30/4)
    Higler - Van Zuilen, Diks - Van der Eijk - Dieperink, Vandeursen

    He has previously refereed the Supercup twice (in both cases Ajax - PSV as well) and both times it was nothing short of a disaster, so an interesting choice to appoint him to his first cup final with the same two teams. However, you can't give Makkelie every cup final (he has been quite controversial as well recently, especially regarding Ajax) and Gözübüyük was appointed for the league clash between the two sides, so it was expected to be Higler

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Makkelie controversial regarding Ajax? It’s not his fault they are so so bad… His Classico in March was a high level piece of refereeing. The best and most entertaining Classico in years. Decisions and management fully in line with the UEFA 2023 approach.

      It's the analysts and commentators that need a LOTG course and are mostly Pro-Ajax. Shameless.

      Delete
    2. Controversial doesn’t mean he was bad. However, of the 4 games with Ajax this season, he missed a crystal clear RC against Utrecht, had a very controversial no-penalty decision in the cup game against Twente, had a controversial no SYC in the Classic (which was correct, but still controversial) and probably two missed RC (one for both teams), and against PSV he gave a wrong penalty (revoked after OFR), he really hasn’t been good in games with Ajax, nothing to do with Ajax’s form (the outcome in any of those games probably wouldn’t have changed)

      Delete
    3. The fouls in the Classico are no RC’s according to UEFA RAP 2023. That’s why VAR did not intervene. And the other incidents: you just literally copy-pasted the rabble-rousing of the Dutch Ajax-minded press (Telegraaf), and they need a LOTG course.

      And besides, in none of the games you mentioned, the final result was influenced by the referee or VAR.

      Delete
    4. I did mention your last part myself, about it not influencing the result. However, the fact that these situations are mentioned in the press (even if it is Ajax-minded press), prove the fact that it was indeed controversial - although it would be too easy to discard those situations by saying they are Ajax-minded, do you honestly think it wasn’t a RC for the incident in Utrecht?

      Anyway, Makkelie is still the best Dutch referee right now, his games just haven’t been as convincing as 1/2 years ago (which might be a psychological effect, as back then he had to fight for those games due to Kuipers’ presence, but right now he is the undisputed nr 1, which is a new situation for him to deal with)

      Delete
  38. Correct PK + YC by Delajod in Youth League final just before HT.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Overal good game. Good Penalty detection. Missed only a YC around min 75-80 for either AZ or Hajduk player.

      This was the situation where AZ player played the ball (I would agree on giving a foul aswell) and Hajduk player made a harsh tackle seconds after. Would be a YC for me. Combination of the intensity and frustration of not getting a free kick seconds before.

      Delete
  39. It seems as Massa was attacked by fans after the game he had in Greece. When enough is enough, I invite FIFA and UEFA to take immediate action against Greek federation and their situation of refereeing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not only fans but also the Piräus President attacked Massa.

      Delete
    2. As far as I know, this guy is one of the main reasons why Greek football looks like that. A slimy, all-powerful and very dangerous person.

      Delete
    3. seing all scenes from greece at the weekend, it is an absolute shock :-(

      Delete
    4. No sanctions will hapen. Years of appalling and dangerous behaving by some clubs. Impossible job for CRC without uefa Fifa supporting.

      Delete
  40. Doveri gets Inter-Juve,Coppa Italia.

    Under 3 cards my prediction. 😉

    On a serious note,lot of pressure on him cause this is for both teams realisticaly only chance to get a trophy,derby D'Italia,controversies these past weeks(Juve-Napoli,Lukaku red card,Juve plus 15 points).

    ReplyDelete
  41. Antonio Mateu Lahoz withdrawn from La Liga duty for 2023/24.

    End of an era. 😢

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Since we got many fake news about that in past, I would be still not 100% sure, let's wait. Other sources reported that he didn't want to retire!

      Delete
    2. It is now more or less official, the sources are pretty solid. Basically, it is a leak from CTA. This also includes Del Cerro Grande, BTW. Mateu Lahoz didn't want to retire, but Medina Cantalejo wants him to leave. According to the news, both of them have been invited to carry on as VAR referees, but Mateu has rejected that offer.

      Delete
    3. Is it possible for Mateu to continue in other FA like Clattenburg or Mazic? And if that happened, is it also possible for Mateu to continue in UEFA like Faghani in AFC, considered that Mateu is still at good performance? If Mateu retired I think it was huge loss for UEFA consider at the moment UEFA is struggle to find another very trusted referee or the pool of very trusted referee was very light.

      Delete
    4. I see. One can easily understand why Mateu rejected a VAR role for the future.
      Also, I understand the point of Medina Cantalejo, asking him to retire, with Gil Manzano and Sanchez Martinez to become new nr.1 and 2, and a chance for Hernandez Hernandez to get Elite. This should be indeed related to the next update of UEFA categories.

      Delete

Thank you for writing a comment on our blog!