Please find below the referee assignments for 2023 AFC Asian Cup Quarterfinals.
 |
| Ahmed Al Kaf (Oman) in charge of Australia - Korea Republic |
02/02/2024
Tajikistan - JordanReferee: Fu Ming (CHN)
Assistant Referee 1: Zhou Fei (CHN)
Assistant Referee 2: Zhang Cheng (CHN)
Fourth Official: Araki Yusuke (JPN)
Reserve Assistant Referee: Alshammari Khalaf Zaid M (KSA)
Video Assistant Referee: Iida Jumpei (JPN)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom (THA)
Referee Assessor : Abdulrahman Mohammed A M Hussain (QAT)
Australia - Korea Republic
Referee: Ahmed Abu Bakar Said Al Kaf (OMA)
Assistant Referee 1: Al-Amri Abu Bakar Salim Mahad (OMA)
Assistant Referee 2: Rashid Hamed Ali Al Ghaithi (OMA)
Fourth Official: Adel Ali Ahmed Khamis Alnaqbi (UAE)
Reserve Assistant Referee: Hasan Mohamed Hasan Abdulla Almahri (UAE)
Video Assistant Referee: Mohammed Abdulla Hassan Mohamed (UAE)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Omar Mohamed Ahmed Hassan Alali (UAE)
Referee Assessor : Abdullaev Farkhad (UZB)
03/02/2024
Referee: Ma Ning (CHN)
Assistant Referee 1: Anton Shchetinin (AUS)
Assistant Referee 2: Ashley Warwick Beecham (AUS)
Fourth Official: Muhammad Nazmi Bin Nasaruddin (MAS)
Reserve Assistant Referee: Mohamad Zairul Bin Khalil Tan (MAS)
Video Assistant Referee: Sivakorn Pu-Udom (THA)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Muhammad Taqi Aljaafari Bin Jahari (SGP)
Referee Assessor : Saad K M Alfadhli (KUW)
Qatar - Uzbekistan
Referee: Kim Heegon (KOR)
Assistant Referee 1: Yoon Jaeyeol (KOR)
Assistant Referee 2: Park Sangjun (KOR)
Fourth Official: Abdullah M M H M H Jamali (KUW)
Reserve Assistant Referee: Abdulhadi M O A B Alanezi (KUW)
Video Assistant Referee: Kim Jong Hyeok (KOR)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Ahmad Kh Y Y A Alali (KUW)
Referee Assessor : Altraifi Ali Ahmed (KSA)
Ma Ning is appointed for IRNJPN and Kim Hee-gon is appointed for QATUZB
ReplyDeleteLooks like Ma Ning is a replacement for one of the Australien referees, Shaun Evans is my prediction, as there are australien assistants.
DeleteAnother fact is the replacement of Ma Ning as forth official the day before.
There is no replacement, it's just a lack of planning by the AFC, they appointed the first two games, without thinking about the other two, and when they saw that they needed to appoint another Chinese they had to find other assistants for him, it makes sense to be the Australians, since not even Faghani , nor Evans should work anymore.
DeleteI think it’s simply replacement because you can easily appoint Adham Makhadmeh or Mooud Bonyadifard, they have full team.
DeleteAnalyze the options that AFC can rely on for Iran v Japan, analyze that there will be two more semi-finals and the final, analyze that Australia can advance and be the last opportunity for the Australian assistants, just analyze, and you will see that it was not a substitution, just a AFC choice combined with poor planning.
DeleteThey still have Mohanad Qasim Essey Sarray from Iraq. I agree this is very poor planning and this is political choice that AFC must be taken after poor performance from duo Australian.
DeleteNah, you can’t have a West Asia ref for Iran vs Japan. Is was either Aussie or Central Asia
Delete1. I think you need to googling first where Iran FA come from, Iran is not from WAFF, they change to CAFF; 2. The committee chosen Ma Ning from China so no “neutrality”, so your argument become invalid.
DeleteThis is simply worst management ever.
Yes, if this was the last big tournament for Faghani (no WC 2026 for him), then the management by AFC can be described as even worse, he would have deserved a better farewell. Nevertheless, for some reasons, he can definitely blame himself, maybe not that much regarding this tournament, but more about what he did at last WC.
ReplyDeleteA referee with outstanding skills regarding players management, but in my opinion missing in some other aspects, like smartness on the pitch, and so on.
A pity that very likely he will end with more controversy than glory.
“The Jonas Eriksson of Asia” :)
ReplyDeleteIf Uzbekistan doesn’t make the final is nail on for IIgiz Tantashev to take the final.
ReplyDeleteDifficult because Ravshan irmatov refereed the last final in UAE and also he refereed the final in Qatar 2011
ReplyDeleteI hope Alireza faghani will be in World cup 2026 he is the one of the best referees in the world not in Asia only
ReplyDeleteSolid performance so far from Ahmed Al Kaf, penalty correctly given by him with good positioning to quickly whistle it. I think he surely will go to WC26.
ReplyDeletea name from neutral country since old days but his name up and down. I think he could be another Nawaf Shukralla.
DeleteAl Kaf got big appointments within AFC in the last 3-4 years, but never anything important from FIFA, so WC26 might not be for him. KSA, QAT and UAE refs have far more geo-political support within FIFA.
DeleteBut FIFA is Collina and not Rosetti. Al Hoaish not good enough and AFC will get extra quota for WC26.
Deleteexcellent tournament for Al Kaf, possibility for final?
ReplyDeleteStill for me Mohamed Mohamed from UAE in front, but indeed he is a name for the final with his excellent performance in fast pace match today.
DeleteThe crucial penalty in 90'+6: https://streamin.me/v/dc25b5c8
ReplyDeleteNow OFR, Al Kaf called by Mohamed Mohamed. I think it’s harsh decision, YC still supportable. Seems like Mohamed Mohamed re-refereeing in this decision
ReplyDeleteClip. Studs into the ankle with high force.
Deletehttps://streamin.me/v/e35fd5bb
Here another clip:
Deletehttps://streamable.com/zi57jz
Surely more than a step on foot, one should understand how much contact makes the tip of the foot and the studs into the ankle, the red card in my opinion can be absolutely issued for excessive force, how player enters the challenge, but I think not all VARs would have agreed on this decision and maybe not a 100% red for all.
I prefer yellow. Definitely not for VAR
DeleteToday if iran out Ali Reza faghani will be candidate for the final
ReplyDeleteAFC statement on Referee decision in Round of 16 match between Iraq and Jordan
ReplyDeletehttps://www.the-afc.com/en/national/afc_asian_cup/news/afc_statement_on_referee_decision_in_round_of_16_match_between_iraq_and_jordan.html
Interesting that they make an explanation about a technical referee's decision, something that you should never expect, and it was n't for a technical mistake (because the reason of yellow card can be clearly for excessive celebration).
DeleteBasically, there shouldn't have been place for such statement, but this can explain us how many protests and complaints they had for this fact.
Now, in case of Iran elimination, it would be interesting to see the next step for Faghani, but very likely in all cases his tournament must be considered as already over... that's my feeling.
Agree I think it’s over for him on this tournament but with this explanation I don’t think his chance to attend WC26 is over.
DeleteSo the decision by Faghani was correct and AFC support his decision but with such logical interpretation and then why Faghani if Iran are out would not get SF or F?
DeleteThere have been situations where FIFA or the confederations publicly supported a referee's decision, but not so much internally and avoided further appointments for that referee.
DeleteGreat offside decision by AR2 Ashley Beecham in 63' to take away a goal from Iran
ReplyDeletevery good performance so far from mixed team Ma Ning-Australian ARs, especially for delaying offside decision, credit to AR2 Ashley Beecham.
ReplyDeleteVery clear last minute penalty for Iran whistled directly by Ma Ning in a convincing way. A quite satisfactory performance by the Chinese today, but a bit too lenient with cards for my taste
ReplyDeleteAFC has now a reason not to appoint Faghani in semifinals.
ReplyDeleteBetter for them, not good for the Iranian.
The crucial penalty call by Ma Ning, very clear: https://streamin.me/v/494e3a86
Do we believe or not believe that is DOGSO-yellow? Because #4 was already on a YC and it would have been a 2YC.
DeleteI fear this is one of those situations where the referee felt the penalty was enough because the game would effectively be over, most likely. But had the penalty been not converted, the missed yellow card here would be a big problem for extra time.
No, there is enough doubt for it not to be DOGSO. Control is not 100% there, the goalkeeper is very close, and it can be argued that the direction of play is more sideways than forwards. SPA is a good technical decision and good game management.
DeleteIs it known which referees were sent home after R16?
ReplyDeleteGulmurod, Ko Hyung Jin, Shaun Evans, Faghani, Hattab
DeleteWowww I think at glance it was RC for Qatari goalie
ReplyDeleteKim Jong Hyeok again to support his fellow countryman after horrible support for no RC by Ko Hyung Jin in Lebanon-China
DeleteI hope someone will provide the video, it was controversial moment
Deletehttps://streambug.org/cv/54cbba
ReplyDeleteHere a video, decision: YC for SPA, supported by VAR.
That's a clear red card, I think more for SFP than DOGSO, but still. When keeper make a such desperate intervention...
And it was 2nd non-intervention by Kim Jong Hyeok. I don’t know I think he was good when he in charge in the middle but when in the background he’s very very passive and naive to not intervened in 2 big incidents.
DeleteDespite this situation I think it was not good performance by Kim Hee Gon, still can’t beat Kim Jong Hyeok but much better than his other compatriot Ko Hyung Jin. Shaky performance in short.
+12 unbelievable time management by Kim Hee Gon. Missed YC for Almoez Ali for clear DtR.
ReplyDeleteHow Japanese referee Araki will referee Iran Vs Qatar after iran beaten Japan today in QF
ReplyDeleteJust take a look all circumstances, it’s not easy at all. Ma Ning already lead Iran match in QF, so the other option just Fu Ming and Al Kaf. But did you think Fu Ming initially the 1st name to lead the Chinese team in Jordan-Tajikistan? For Al Kaf, did you think that he is not final candidates? If he assign to this match then surely Mohamed Abdulla Hassan will get the final, but at the same moment committee wouldn’t have backup plan for the final. Then you only have Yusuke Araki available. But I’m not surprise if we will see repeated names again in charge, either Fu Ming, Ma Ning, or Al Kaf. IMO the only conditions that will surprise me is to see Tantashev or Al Ali get their 4th games.
DeleteAnd still we don’t talk yet about political issues, neutrality, etc.
DeleteI agree with Juan Mohammed Abdulla Hassan from UAE will referee the final
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion Ma Ning is most suitable for the final. He is the only one to have refereed two consecutive knockout games, and China has another top referee Fu Ming who can be VAR.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately for Japan, the match officials missed a foul throw by Iran captain in the 90+3’ that led to Iran’s penalty kick (which was the match-winning goal). Did anyone spot this?
Deletehttps://footydarkarts.substack.com/p/japan-denied-extra-time-against-iran
Who will referee Jordan vs south Korea tomorrow?
ReplyDeleteMohammed Abdulla Hassan is appointed for JORKOR.
ReplyDeleteMa Ning is FO
DeleteAsian Nations Cup 2024 - Qatar
ReplyDeleteSemi-finals
Jordan - Korea Republic
Referee: Mohammed Abdulla Hassan Mohamed (UAE)
Assistant Referee 1: Mohamed Ahmed Yousef Abdulla
Alhammadi (UAE)
Assistant Referee 2: Hasan Mohamed Hasan Abdulla Almahri (UAE)
Fourth Official: Ma Ning (CHN)
Reserve Assistant Referee: Zhou Fei (CHN)
Video Assistant Referee: Omar Mohamed Ahmed Hassan Alali (UAE)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Iida Jumpei (JPN)
Referee Assessor : Saad K M Alfadhli (KUW)