2024-25 UEFA Europa League, MD3 appointments, games to be played on 23 and 24 October 2024.
16:30 CET - Braga (Estádio Municipal de Braga)
SC BRAGA (POR) - FK BODØ/GLIMT (NOR)
Referee: Nenad Minaković SRB
Assistant Referee 1: Nikola Borović SRB
Assistant Referee 2: Boško Božović SRB
Fourth Official: Milan Mitić SRB
Video Assistant Referee: Momčilo Marković SRB
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Novak Simović SRB
UEFA Referee Observer: Tomasz Mikulski POL
UEFA Delegate: Patricia González García ESP
16:30 CET - Istanbul (Ali Sami Yen Spor Kompleksi RAMS Park)
GALATASARAY (TUR) - IF ELFSBORG (SWE)
Referee: Matej Jug SVN
Assistant Referee 1: Matej Žunič SVN
Assistant Referee 2: Manuel Vidali SVN
Fourth Official: Mihael Antič SVN
Video Assistant Referee: Alen Borošak SVN
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Asmir Sagrkovič SVN
UEFA Referee Observer: Ichko Lozev BUL
UEFA Delegate: Aurel Mihail Ionescu ROU
Thursday 24 October 2024
18:45 CET - Rome (Stadio Olimpico)
AS ROMA (ITA) - FK DYNAMO KYIV (UKR)
Referee: Serdar Gözübüyük NEDAssistant Referee 1: Erwin E. J. Zeinstra NED
Assistant Referee 2: Johan Balder NED
Fourth Official: Sander van der Eijk NED
Video Assistant Referee:Dennis Johan Higler NED
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Erwin Blank NED
UEFA Referee Observer: Dejan Filipović SRB
UEFA Delegate: Marcin Stefański POL
18:45 CET - Frankfurt am Main (Deutsche Bank Park)
EINTRACHT FRANKFURT (GER) - FK RFS (LVA)
Referee: Allard Lindhout NEDAssistant Referee 1: Joost van Zuilen NED
Assistant Referee 2: Rogier Honig NED
Fourth Official: Jannick van der Laan NED
Video Assistant Referee: Rob Dieperink NED
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Cătălin Sorin Popa ROU
Assistant Referee 2: Rogier Honig NED
Fourth Official: Jannick van der Laan NED
Video Assistant Referee: Rob Dieperink NED
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Cătălin Sorin Popa ROU
UEFA Referee Observer: Emil Božinovski MKD
UEFA Delegate: Quanyş Qanapiianov KAZ
18:45 CET - Thessaloniki (Stádio Toúmbas)
PAOK (GRE) - FC VIKTORIA PLZEŇ (CZE)
Referee: Urs Schnyder SUI
Assistant Referee 1: Marco Zürcher SUI
Assistant Referee 2: Benjamin Zürcher SUI
Fourth Official: Anojen Kanagasingam SUI
Video Assistant Referee: Lionel Tschudi SUI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Johannes von Mandach SUI
Assistant Referee 1: Marco Zürcher SUI
Assistant Referee 2: Benjamin Zürcher SUI
Fourth Official: Anojen Kanagasingam SUI
Video Assistant Referee: Lionel Tschudi SUI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Johannes von Mandach SUI
UEFA Referee Observer: Michael Anthony Riley ENG
UEFA Delegate: Amil Gerina MNE
18:45 CET - Belgrade, SRB (Stadion FK Partizan)
MK MAKKABI TEL AVIV (ISR) - REAL SOCIEDAD DE FÚTBOL (ESP)
Referee: Rohit Saggi NOR
Assistant Referee 1: Morten Jensen NOR
Assistant Referee 2: Anders Olav Dale NOR
Fourth Official: Sigurd Kringstad NOR
Video Assistant Referee: Tom Harald Hagen NOR
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Kristoffer Hagenes NOR
UEFA Referee Observer: Stéphane Lannoy FRA
UEFA Delegate: Michaíl Mítas CYP
Fourth Official: Sigurd Kringstad NOR
Video Assistant Referee: Tom Harald Hagen NOR
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Kristoffer Hagenes NOR
UEFA Referee Observer: Stéphane Lannoy FRA
UEFA Delegate: Michaíl Mítas CYP
18:45 CET - Budapest (Groupama Aréna)
FERENCVÁROSI TC (HUN) - OGC NICE (FRA)
Referee: Anastasios Sidiropoulos GRE
Assistant Referee 1: Polychronis Kostaras GRE
Assistant Referee 2: Lazaros Dimitriadis GRE
Fourth Official: Ioannis Papadopoulos GRE
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stefanos Koymparakis GRE
UEFA Referee Observer: Karen Nalbandyan ARM
UEFA Delegate: Ádonis Prokopíou CYP
Assistant Referee 2: Lazaros Dimitriadis GRE
Fourth Official: Ioannis Papadopoulos GRE
Video Assistant Referee: Angelos Evangelou GRE
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stefanos Koymparakis GRE
UEFA Referee Observer: Karen Nalbandyan ARM
UEFA Delegate: Ádonis Prokopíou CYP
18:45 CET - Baku (Tofiq Bəhramov adına Respublika Stadionu)
QARABAĞ FK (AZE) - AFC AJAX (NED)
Referee: Nicholas Walsh SCO
Assistant Referee 1: Graeme Stewart SCO
Assistant Referee 2: Calum Spence SCO
Fourth Official: Christopher Graham SCO
Video Assistant Referee: Kevin Clancy SCO
Assistant Referee 2: Calum Spence SCO
Fourth Official: Christopher Graham SCO
Video Assistant Referee: Kevin Clancy SCO
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: John Beaton SCO
UEFA Referee Observer: Mehmet Murat Ilgaz TUR
UEFA Delegate: Aldi Topçiu ALB
18:45 CET - Herning (MCH Arena)
FC MIDTJYLLAND (DEN) - ROYALE UNION SAINT-GILLOISE (BEL)
Referee: Sebastian Gishamer AUT
Assistant Referee 1: Roland Riedel AUT
Assistant Referee 2: Santino Schreiner AUT
Fourth Official: Jakob Semler AUT
Video Assistant Referee: Manuel Schuettengruber AUT
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Josef Spurny AUT
Fourth Official: Jakob Semler AUT
Video Assistant Referee: Manuel Schuettengruber AUT
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Josef Spurny AUT
UEFA Referee Observer: Konstandínos Kapitanís CYP
UEFA Delegate: Kimmo J. Lipponen FIN
21:00 CET - Porto (Estádio do Dragão)
FC PORTO (POR) - TSG 1899 HOFFENHEIM (GER)
Referee: Damian Sylwestrzak POL
Assistant Referee 1: Paweł Sokolnicki POL
Assistant Referee 2: Adam Karasewicz POL
Fourth Official: Marcin Kochanek POL
Video Assistant Referee: Piotr Lasyk POL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Tomasz Kwiatkowski POL
UEFA Referee Observer: Rune Pedersen NOR
UEFA Delegate: Colin MacDonald SCO
Assistant Referee 2: Adam Karasewicz POL
Fourth Official: Marcin Kochanek POL
Video Assistant Referee: Piotr Lasyk POL
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Tomasz Kwiatkowski POL
UEFA Referee Observer: Rune Pedersen NOR
UEFA Delegate: Colin MacDonald SCO
21:00 CET - Glasgow (Ibrox Stadium)
RANGERS FC (SCO) - FC FCSB (ROU)
Referee: Marco Di Bello ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Davide Imperiale ITA
Assistant Referee 2: Alessio Berti ITA
Fourth Official: Rosario Abisso ITA
Video Assistant Referee: Luca Piretto ITA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Valerio Marini ITA
UEFA Referee Observer: Michal Beneš CZE
UEFA Delegate: Kim Hallberg DEN
21:00 CET - London (Tottenham Hotspur Stadium)
TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR FC (ENG) - AZ ALKMAAR (NED)
Referee: Manfredas Lukjančukas LTUAssistant Referee 1: Mangirdas Mirauskas LTU
Assistant Referee 2: Vytenis Kazlauskas LTU
Fourth Official: Mindaugas Jackus LTU
Video Assistant Referee: Sören Storks GER
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Fedayi San SUI
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Fedayi San SUI
UEFA Referee Observer: Carlos Velasco Carballo ESP
UEFA Delegate: Charles Schaack LUX
21:00 CET - Décines-Charpieu (Groupama Stadium)
OLYMPIQUE LYONNAIS (FRA) - BEŞİKTAŞ (TUR)
Referee: Harm Osmers GER
Assistant Referee 1: Dominik Schaal GER
Assistant Referee 2: Stefan Lupp GER
Fourth Official: Florian Exner GER
Video Assistant Referee: Christian Dingert GER
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Peter Bankes ENG
UEFA Referee Observer: Vlado Svilokos CRO
UEFA Referee Observer: Vlado Svilokos CRO
UEFA Delegate: Peadar Ryan IRL
21:00 CET - Istanbul (Fenerbahçe Şükrü Saracoğlu Spor Kompleksi Ülker Stadyumu)
FENERBAHÇE (TUR) - MANCHESTER UNITED FC (ENG)
Referee: Clément Turpin FRA
Assistant Referee 1: Nicolas Danos FRA
Assistant Referee 2: Benjamin Pagès FRA
Fourth Official: Jérémy Stinat FRA
Video Assistant Referee: Jérôme Brisard FRA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jérémie Pignard FRA
UEFA Referee Observer: Andreas Schluchter SUI
UEFA Delegate: Andrey Medintsev BUL
Fourth Official: Jérémy Stinat FRA
Video Assistant Referee: Jérôme Brisard FRA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jérémie Pignard FRA
UEFA Referee Observer: Andreas Schluchter SUI
UEFA Delegate: Andrey Medintsev BUL
21:00 CET - Malmö (Eleda Stadion)
MALMÖ FF (SWE) - OLYMBIAKÓS SFP (GRE)
Referee: Simone Sozza ITA
Assistant Referee 1: Filippo Meli ITA
Assistant Referee 2: Stefano Alassio ITA
Fourth Official: Matteo Marcenaro ITA
Video Assistant Referee: Gianluca Aureliano ITA
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Marco Serra ITA
UEFA Referee Observer: Konrad Plautz AUT
UEFA Delegate: Iva Olivari-Uliša CRO
21:00 CET - Bilbao (Estadio de San Mamés)
ATHLETIC CLUB (ESP) - SK SLAVIA PRAHA (CZE)
Referee: Morten Krogh DEN
Assistant Referee 1: D. Wollenberg Rasmussen DEN
Assistant Referee 2: Steffen Bramsen DEN
Fourth Official: Mads Kristoffersen DEN
Video Assistant Referee: Tiago Martins POR
Assistant Referee 2: Steffen Bramsen DEN
Fourth Official: Mads Kristoffersen DEN
Video Assistant Referee: Tiago Martins POR
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Aleandro Di Paolo ITA
UEFA Referee Observer: Kýros Vassáras GRE
UEFA Delegate: Thomas Grimm SUI
21:00 CET - Brussels (Lotto Park)
RSC ANDERLECHT (BEL) - PFK LUDOGORETS 1945 (BUL)
Referee: Filip Glova SVK
Assistant Referee 1: Daniel Polacek SVK
Assistant Referee 2: Peter Bednar SVK
Fourth Official: Lukáš Dzivjak SVK
Assistant Referee 2: Peter Bednar SVK
Fourth Official: Lukáš Dzivjak SVK
Video Assistant Referee:Jochem Kamphuis NED
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Edwin van de Graaf NED
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Edwin van de Graaf NED
UEFA Referee Observer: Alexandru Deaconu ROU
UEFA Delegate: Vahan Berakhchyan ARM
21:00 CET - Enschede (De Grolsch Veste)
FC TWENTE (NED) - SS LAZIO (ITA)
Referee: Nikola Dabanović MNE
Assistant Referee 1: Vladan Todorović MNE
Assistant Referee 2: Srđan Jovanović MNE
Fourth Official: Miloš Milanović SRB
Video Assistant Referee: David Coote ENG
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stuart Attwell ENG
UEFA Referee Observer: Stefano Podeschi SMR
UEFA Delegate: Fernand Meese BEL
Assistant Referee 1: Vladan Todorović MNE
Assistant Referee 2: Srđan Jovanović MNE
Fourth Official: Miloš Milanović SRB
Video Assistant Referee: David Coote ENG
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Stuart Attwell ENG
UEFA Referee Observer: Stefano Podeschi SMR
UEFA Delegate: Fernand Meese BEL
Second match for Sidiropoulos in EL
ReplyDeleteDoes that mean he will be relegated to cat.1?
No matches at all for Jovanovic .... injury?
Dabanovic with another appointment, as well as Gozubuyuk.
ReplyDeleteThe referee from Montenegro was heavily criticized by English readers, I fully understand their point of view, but as long as you manage to have a regular game without issues and to solve the crucial incidents (very good no penalty call), you get more. It's not the quality in some cases, but let's say how a referee officiates a game.
Very difficult game in Netherlands for me with the Italian team always ready to question, and we know.
Turpin with an Europa League game, I have the feeling that he has lost some credits under the eyes of Rosetti, of course the poor performance at EURO, but I'm surprised he gets only Europa League now, with Letexier coming from poor performances. We will see in the next set, one could expect the contrary, with Turpin in CL and Letexier EL / ECL (rather EL). The VAR of Leipzig - Juventus is back.
Most important observation for committee is Lukjančukas with Velasco, what are your ideas about the Lithuanian? Too early for thinking about a promotion? For sure now one should consider Rumsas. Then, he follows, having quite long time to develop. Nevertheless, committee seems very interested in him.
The recent performances were overall good, but also true he never faced a very challenging game (not his fault, of course).
Schnyder and Saggi to continue their journey in making experience, with regarded observers (Lannoy and Riley). Should be the first time of Norwegian VAR in Europa League, I think? Harald Hagen comes back after having been international referee in the "Ovrebo times" For sure Norway can't forget that. Important observer for Krogh as well.
Yes first time with Norwegian VAR. Hagen is not refeereing in Norweagian League anymore, just as VAR.
DeleteFenerbahce Manchester a big clash needs a elite referee.
ReplyDeleteThis time it is Turpin. I dont think it will be a demotion.
I agree with your thoughts about Dabanovic. Not a good match in Liverpool and now this match. It could be a hard match for him.
The third important match in a row for Sylwestrzak (Olympiakos-Braga, Iceland-Türkiye and now Porto - Hoffenheim). I think he will soon make his debut in the Champions League
ReplyDeleteThe focus on Lukjančukas is interesting, I guess many of us expect his compatriot Rumsas to make the final step to Elite category.
ReplyDeleteIs it true that Rumsas had no UEFA appointments in MD2-MD3? Is that a normal management? One could question that. I don’t remember how he performed in MD1, however there should be an argument to shift focus to Lukjančukas now.
About the game in London: not sure why Carballo has to be there, in what should be a one-sided game on paper. The team from Alkmaar are in a bad moment and (with a lot respect and sympathy), they suit better in Conference league. Wonderful youth academy… But I almost never understand the choices to appoint a Refcom member. I think there are much better (and more technical) games available to observe a referee.
On Rumsas: it is not the first ime he is out from appointments apparently without reasons (shouldn't be for previous performance), it happened also in past, it looks that he is not available all the time, that's a conclusion I have drawn.
DeleteMaybe also for this reason there is more focus on the other Lithuanian, because indeed with a "full time" Rumsas, this should follow later.
About the habit by committee members to observe referees not in challenging context, it's not the first time. Rosetti many times went to watch a referee in even easier context than this one in London. My final idea is that they just want to meet the referee, and there isn't a real technical plan behind, otherwise they would selected a by far challenging game. Also, many times Rosetti used to be in Switzerland, close to UEFA home, and in France, and he appointed referees to be watched just based on that, not based on the potential difficulty of a game.
Only one Belgian referee appointed in three Leagues togheter ?? Even no Eric Lambrechts, no Visser (he had a NL game with bad comments on this blog again, but we were analysing very closely and we think that his appearance as such is not liked by Rosetti and his collegueas), no D'hondt (extremely promising in Belgian first class). To be clear : I am on this blog NOT the defender or supporter of the Belgian referees ; I am following (with others, not as professionally as most of you, but still) the path of appr. 2/3ds of Cat 1 referees and all elite referees. But the specialised followers in Belgium cannot but see that Rosetti and his team treats the Belgian referees as they were from Malta or San Marino (no offense againts those two beautiful countries). We are wondering why, comparing with all other refs who are repeatedly appointed for consecutive games.
ReplyDeleteLambrechts already had a CL match on Day 2 (Barcelona-Young Boys). I think he'll have a second CL match on the next day or a bigger UEL match.
DeleteVisser has had one UEL match (Lyon - Olympiacos) and one NL Group A match. Admittedly, his performance wasn't extraordinary, but he didn't make any crucial mistakes. I can't see him getting less than 8.2 or 8.1. The rest of his performance is not to blame. I think it's the first time he's had to deal with a “star” and we all know how difficult some referees have been with Ronaldo in the past. I think he'll probably get a game in the CL in the next few days, or some other games in the UEL.
D'hondt had his first match in the UECL group stage on Matchday 2. I have no information on the match.
Vergoote had his first UECL group stage match this week.
As for Van Driessche and Verboomen, they weren't convincing in the first round matches on the pre season. We can't expect much from them other than a normal UECL match or a small UEL match on the last matchday.
Lardot (belgian referees director) says that the fifa belgian ref have 8.4 on average (only one 7.9)... The belgians are very young ... but in progress...
DeleteWhich Belgian referee can be in progress?
DeleteLambrechts (Eventually, but age problem), Visser (No), Van Driessche and Verboomen (No), Dhondt (if he is consistent but still very young) and Vergoote (too young)
The last two mentioned (Dhondt and Vergoote) are not "too young" if they want to make real progress within UEFA; And Visser, well, he started refereeing in First Division more than 10 years ago and he still is not 35 yet. Beneath his own performances, fact is that he has no powerful mentor/people to "promote" him. Do you know who was the mentor of Frank De Bleeckere by the way ? It was a certain.... Collina ! You have to be good but you have to be lucky and supported as well to "follow a succesful path". Finally : I believe as well that Visser will never become Elite, but watch Dhondt and Vergoote (if they are supported by the right people and lucky as well)
DeleteAccording to a match commentator in Belgium, Simon Bourdeaud'hui will become the new FIFA referee in 2025, replacing Jonathan Lardot.
DeleteIs Turpin losing prestige???
ReplyDeleteWhat do you think?
Remember that he is pre-selected for WC26.
I mean this game is the only one that he can ref in the EL for me, he already got a UCL game this year, just think that UEFA wanted a top referee for a game that in Turkey can be really hard. We’ll see in the next few month though
DeleteJose Maria Sanchez Martinez will referee El Clasico next Saturday
ReplyDeleteCorrect 2YC by Minakovic in Braga.
ReplyDeleteBoth YC were given in the span of 1 minute for eerily similar SPA incidents.
DeleteClip: https://streamin.me/v/3810b07e
Very good. One should call him brave, because, be sure, the second YC wouldn't have been issued for "management" purposes by many referees. But both simillar fouls and botjh to be punished as SPA. Hope Serbia can find a good name after the long troubles experienced by Jovanovic.
DeleteMissed offside by several meters (!) from AR2 in Galtasaray-Elfsborg
ReplyDeleteTop officiating performance by Minakovic. He candidate himself for debut at the UCL this year, and probably U21 Euro next year. He should continiue like this!
ReplyDeleteAgree. Only could watch from 30' onwards, but he was almost flawless. It was an intense but generally fair spirited match.
DeleteOFR for handball penalty by Jug: https://streamin.me/v/8b74543f
ReplyDeleteOT:
ReplyDeleteI am curious who will referee the PSG-Atlético Madrid (MD4) on November 6.
Atlético Madrid have sent an official complaint to UEFA regarding the whistled penalty. PSG was probably not satisfied with the overruled PK either.
Normally, I would say this is a typical Marciniak game. But now? Perhaps Taylor or Oliver?
Taylor sounds logical indeed.
DeleteNot many options for him currently, but those two clubs should be fine.
Nicholas Walsh with an early but correct DOGSO red card for QAR#6. Long way to go for the attacker, but nearest defenders not in a position to intervene timely.
ReplyDeleteQarabag - Ajax: DOGSO and straight red card by Walsh.
ReplyDeletehttps://caulse.com/v/26879
Correct decision, I think. Without foul, player clearly with the ball and without other defenders.
In the early minutes, disallowed goal for offside after VAR intervention, I think not a big mistake by AR1 to miss it, very tight.
Actually the early disallowed QAR goal was an infield decision by AR1 which VAR confirmed.
DeleteGozubuyuk with a clear penalty for holding immediately whistled, but maybe more important for him, finally a strong body language doing that.
ReplyDeletehttps://streamin.me/v/95bf59c5
DeleteHonestly, an offside flag that I can't explain by AR1 in Thessaloniki, disallowing a goal scored. Very clear ONSIDE, the assistant referee missed a defender in the assessment, otherwise no explanations. Very poor mistake. VAR corrected.
ReplyDeletehttps://dubz.co/c/9c4604
DeleteNow home team complaining about an alleged foul in the build-up of Amsterdam goal, but it was a fair challenge. So far a good performance by the young Scot.
ReplyDeleteTo continue from Gozubuyuk game, correctly disallowed goal for offside in first half AR1, then now at the start of second half for me missed YC for reckless, should have been given.
ReplyDeleteIndeed the Ukrainian nr15 extremely lucky to escape his second yellow card and a sending off.
DeleteDefinitely an evident mistake by Lindhout in Frankfurt to whistle a penalty for a foul outside the box, it was clearly a free kick, not even close to the line of penalty area. Corrected by VAR.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think you mean the penalty he whistled to Ajax.
Deletehttps://streamin.me/v/0d3bcb32
Defender tring to protect ball, in such situations rarely a penalty is whistled, but of course never a clear and obvious mistake, VAR should support. Coach from Qarabag also booked for dissent.
However, a few ago, absolutely correct second YC with the player accepting the decision, very clear reckless action.
Qarabag - ajax 72'
ReplyDeleteA penalty decision that I have no sympathy for at all. A normal shoulder-to-shoulder duel.
Is it really that hard for VAR?
Horrendous performance by Walsh.
DeleteYes, it's hard for VAR, because the defender goes to make contact with attacker, you can never remove such penalty according to protocol, it's up to referee.
DeleteChefren, I don't like this way of doing things at all. I think this (shoulders and legs) is just a 'contact', not a incorrect contact and not even a 'cheap' penalty.
DeleteJust as the bar for intervention is kept high for VAR, why not keep the threshold for awarding penalties be kept at a minimum? It's a contact sport, so it's no surprise that the content of the contact matters.
If this is a penalty, then we can discuss what is incorrect with this contact.
i completely disagree with everyone who said this is not a penalty.... has nothing to do with shoulder to shoulder, it's an ordinary foul, no intention to play a bal, ìff you look proper... you can see there is no shoulder push, but elbow/arm push in Rasmussens side of his back....
DeletePenalty was way too harsh by Walsh. Correct 2nd yc in minute 79
ReplyDeleteHave you all failed to notice the clear kick to the Ajax players leg. Clear penalty correctly given on field by Walsh
ReplyDeleteThere was no kick to the leg. Shoulder to shoulder.
DeleteThere was a clear kick as shown on the TV broadcast
DeleteSide by side contact, minimal contact with leg. Not for VAR but at this level nobody is expecting a penalty to be whistled.
DeleteDisaster already in Glasgow: Di bello blew the whistle instead of delaying for VAR to confirm the decision onfield for a foul on goalkeeper. He blows before players puts it in net so no VAR intervention allowed. IMO it was no foul and had he delayed an OFR would have followed
ReplyDeleteVideo: streambug.io/cv/27d93e
DeleteHuge mistake from Di Bello, whistling a ghost foul. But the fact that he didn't delay his whistle and therefore eliminating the possibility for an OFR is simply unforgivable.
Regular action by attacker, there is always a fear by many referees when keepers are involved and they are not seen like other players. This can be an example. In that specific incident, with a goal absolutely expected, he could have waited for allowing a VAR intervention, but I see that some referees don't absolutely manage to do that, differently from the delayed flags of assistant referees about offsides.
DeleteI think this could be one of the last international games for Di Bello, it is reported by some rumors he could be replaced for 2025, maybe specializing as VAR. He had an extremely poor season on last year.
Initially I thought the attacker got a touch on the ball but on the replay in slow motion the GK kicks it away and then is impeded on the other leg, so don't think it's a wrong decision - though obviously shouldn't have whistled before the goal.
DeleteMaybe Di Bello wasn't in full focus as very early in the match but terrible to blow the whistle before goal was scored. Totally against VAR protocol. Even being Italian won't save him from big criticism from UEFA for this
DeleteCorrect red card by Dabanovic to Twente keeper for DOGSO:
ReplyDeletehttps://dubz.co/c/226e77
Weird penalty decision by Osmers in Lyon, now corrected to a DFK by VAR. Didn't catch what happened before, but never enough contact for the penalty in the box
ReplyDeleteAgree..IMO not a good week for the German ref‘s..Zwayer with a disaster performance and today Osmers was very bad.(PK decision was disastrous and generally not accepted)
DeleteI don't think Zwayer was that bad, just the completely missed RC overshadowing everything else. Stieler was really solid tho
DeleteAnd-Lud 28. Correct Rc Vidal for violent conduct (arm as a weapon) after Ofr
ReplyDeleteReferee struggling for control in this game. Not helped by the behaviour of the Ludogorets players, supporters and technical staff. Tricky second half ahead
DeleteClip: https://dubz.co/c/46373e
DeletePK by Krogh in Bilbao canceled after OFR due to foul in the APP.
ReplyDeleteVery controversial intervention by Coote in Twente - Lazio, inviting Dabanovic to remove a penalty. For me, never a clear and obvious mistake. Eventful game for Dabanovic and many rough foul.
ReplyDeleteMy impression of Dabanovic was not a good one tonight. I really found him struggling in many aspects
DeleteApart from that Lazio is maybe the most challenging team to manage in this competition
Yes, it was as if he was blowing the whistle at an Italian match for the first time, he was almost lost.
DeleteThe 10-man Dutch team was forced to compete frantically, whistle caused further frustration.
Lenient line towards Lazio players in terms of calling fouls on them and showing no cards cause Twente players to lose theirncool.
DeleteDabanovic was so far in terms of gaining control and he lost the match in 2nd half completely.
Until Lazio scored 2nd goal,match was gone for him.
Not good impression.
Fenerbahce - Manchester United.
ReplyDeleteJose Mourinho got a RC by Turpin in 59' after protesting blatantly for a penalty.
Very good
DeleteDeclarações de Mourinho sobre a expulsão:
Delete"Ele (Turpin) me falou algo incrível. Ele me falou que, ao mesmo tempo, ele conseguiu ver a ação na área e meu comportamento na beira do campo. Dou os parabéns para ele porque é absolutamente incrível. A visão periférica dele.
O jogo a 100km/h e ele tinha um olho no lance do pênalti e um olho no banco e no meu comportamento. Essa é a explicação que ele me deu. Por isso ele é um dos melhores árbitros do mundo".
Just saw, Osmers awarded a corner kick to Lyon after a possible handball penalty (never in 1000 years but some discussion from Lyon) despite the Besiktas picking up the ball well within the pitch. 2 dissent YC in the following seconds.
ReplyDeletehttps://streambug.org/cv/83e94a
ReplyDeleteTo me this one was a typical "English VAR" intervention, to revoke a penalty, in which one can't understand the main reason.
Well, I m pretty satisifed what I saw from Dabanovic last night. One can not understand why David Coote call him, but at the end, nothing that can kill his good performance. Excellent red card given by him. I think that Uefa can consider him as candidate for promotion to Elite.
ReplyDeleteFor me, penalty was supportable or even correct call, I agree that regarding this aspect, the performance will not be spoiled, very good also the red card for DOGSO, but the rest is unconvincing. Struggled to have control of the game, allowed too much. I think he is basically a referee who can make very good calls, having a certain ability, but the management / control of the game when heated, is not at the same level. Since today the most important stuff in refereeing is to take crucial decisions correct and maybe not more than that, committee could be satisfied, but they can also see the level of appointments that can't be exceeded by the referee from Montenegro.
DeleteDidn't watch yesterday but in Liverpool vs Bologna he was terrible, in a rather easy match played in good spirit issued 6 yellow cards and 4 of the were plainly wrong! Probably the worst refereeing performance I've seen this season in European Cups.
DeleteThe incident of contention from Turpin's game:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.streambug.io/cv/733342
Mourinho's expulsion seems exaggerated for the cards-for-managers (sth I would immediately remove :D) era but in previous years, he obviously would have been sent to the stands for 'conduct not meeting the required standard' so full support for Turpin sending him off. Penalty would have been supported by VAR (imo) but the contact on the Fener player's standing leg is fleeting at best and it giving would have given the impression that the ref was 'sold' by a dive of the home team. Despite the hot atmosphere, the game itself (this episode aside) was one of usual difficulty which was well officiated by the French no1.
Thanks for the video.
DeleteImo great (double) call by Turpin. The penalty appeal for me is nothing. I am not sure we even have contact. A YC for a dive should have been possible (but I prefer not issuing it for management reasons). I disagree with the statement VAR would have supported a call, I hope not. The Mourinho RC I 100% agree with you. Maybe not a must, but fully supportable. Generally very strong body language by Turpin.
Close to the tip of the foot, I agree it wasn't a step on foot and that's a very good decision, because live one could have been easily deceived. Of course players are aware that step on foot is always foul, so when they see a similar contact, they do everything to exaggerate it (well, not only this one, of course, but in this case even more, one could say).
DeleteYes, VAR would have supported a call, that's sure, you don't have the evidence that there wasn't contact, and once you have this situation, you can't act in a different way from the room. So, the decision by referee must be praised even more.
About Mourinho, better if I not comment, I think he should really retire from football.
But MIkael, did you know that in French official ranking (they upload a public document when sending new referees list for the next year), at moment Letexier is nr.1 and Turpin 2?
This at moment seems valid in UEFA as well, but apart from EURO performances, one must indeed say it's a bit harhs against the "old" French.
https://media.fff.fr/uploads/documents/cfa-pv3-06-09-24.pdf
DeleteI hadn't noticed that document (and interesting to note the two new FIFAs), thanks. Unless FFF wanted to make a 'protest' about the Euro final appointment then it was probably mandatory to organise it that way. Most noteworthy imo is that for the arbitrary table in 23/24 for Ligue 1, Turpin was given the rating of 3rd place behind Bastien (2nd) and Letexier (1st). I guess they wanted to underline not being 100% convinced by his domestic performances.
DeleteHere's some information:
DeleteReferee Ruddy Buquet (47) recently failed physical tests and should no longer referee after more than 16 years in the league. This would explain his non-renewal from the future FIFA 2025 list.
Concerning the two new referees proposed for the FIFA 2025 list (to replace Buquet and Gaillouste):
- Romain Lissorgue, 33 (ranked 15th out of 20 in 2023/2024) has been refereeing in the top flight since the 2021 season (despite a season in the second division in 2022). To date, he has not refereed any benchmark matches, as he regularly referees matches involving mid-table teams.
- Mathieu Vernice, 31 (ranked 18th out of 20 in 2023/2024) has been refereeing in the First Division since the 2022 season. He is one of the youngest referees in the French league. In one match in particular (Lyon vs Brest last season), several of his decisions caused a stir as he lost control of the match despite the spectacular scoreline and scenario.
The AFC has unveiled the first episode of ‘Beyond the Field’, a documentary series offering an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at the roles and responsibilities of match officials at the 2023 AFC Asian Cup
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6IG7DqiPaw&ab_channel=TheAFCHub
Btw, I posted the other day that some referees were wearing AFC badges in the AFC U-17 Asian Cup qualification round. Those referees are participants of AFC Referee Academy who are currently not FIFA referee and are wearing badges of AFC Referee Academy. The AFC didn't publish their own badges like UEFA.
Almost all UCL MD4 observers are publiced.
ReplyDeleteIn PSG - Atleti there is a German observer which eliminates Zwayer. My idea is Kovács or Taylor.
For the latter it would be one of the very few games he can officiate tbh — I don’t expect Taylor with Italian (and German?) teams on short term. Some games are more suitable for debut and don’t need Elite.
Peter Sippel observer for that game in Paris means a very experienced Elite referee that committee fully trusts, of course no doubts about the kind of appointment, but indeed the nationality of the observer already says us that it will not be Zwayer (maybe also unlikely before knowing that, watching how committee treats him at moment).
DeleteTo me, impossible Taylor, even if he doesn't have problems with Spanish teams, the committee will avoid such choice, because, very easy to say, in case of another mistake in favor of a Spanish side, it would be the very end for him.
Makkelie is still a name you have to consider, but getting this one meeting again PSG after a long time, sounds unlikely.
Marciniak situation is still particular and he alreadywas in the spotlight for PSG. Honestly, I'm surprised by how much easy sometimes committee makes the choices for some games. I'm really in trouble to find a referee for this one, but at the end I will say that only real option seems to be Kovacs, passing from a big match, to another one (this could also find a confirmation in Rosetti recent management of some referees, as long as they come from good games, they get further ones). If we want to exclude the Romanian, well, Oliver is the other possible option.
"Almost all observers..."
DeleteWell, guess who is missing, among others?
The one for an Italian team, of course. Inter - Arsenal :D
I don't think Taylor can avoid Spanish sides atm - He is the obvious choice for me
DeleteI think, your argument regarding Taylor and Spanish teams goes too far. It's already quite harsh, that he apparently can't do Italian teams (due to one game even without big mistake) and German teams (due to one mistake). But now also eliminating referees from countries, which they favoured with one mistake? Then we really have no options left.
DeleteI try some predictions without repeating referees from this week. And still without Gil Manzano and Marciniak.
ReplyDeleteIt's just about feasible IMO, but obviously quite a stretch in some cases.
PSV - Girona: Rumsas (di Paolo)
Slavan - Dinamo: Aghayev (van Boekel)
Dortmund - Graz: Kabakov (Delajod)
Liverpool - Leverkusen: Sanchez (del Cerro Grande)
Real - Milan: Letexier (Brisard)
Celtic - Leipzig: Obrenovic (Kwiatkowski)
Lille - Juventus: Petrescu (Dieperink)
Sporting - ManCity: Siebert (Dingert)
Bologna - Monaco: Kavanagh (Attwell)
Brugge - Villa: Grinfeeld (Adler)
Donetsk - Bern: Stefanski (Lasyk)
Bayern - Benfica: Massa (di Bello)
Inter - Arsenal: Hernandez (del Cerro Grande)
Paris - Atletico: Taylor (Coote)
Feyenoord - Salzburg: Martinez (San)
Red Star - Barcelona: Visser (van Driessche)
Sparta - Brest: de Burgos (Soto)
Stuttgart - Atalanta: Lambrechts (Dieperink)
Rumsas, Letexier, Massa, Taylor are the ones to appoint. The rest are mid refs - uel material like for example who is Stefanski in the bread queue Haha dont make me laugh
DeleteDespite my terrible predictions in MD3 - Here I go again, I have included Manzano as he's back in La Liga.
DeleteMarciniak & Jovanovic, I've not heard, so left off.
PSV - Girona: Sozza (di Paolo)
Slavan - Dinamo: Stegermann (Brand)
Dortmund - Graz: Kavanagh (Attwell)
Liverpool - Leverkusen: Sanchez (del Cerro Grande)
Real - Milan: Turpin (Millot)
Celtic - Leipzig: Saggi (Higler)
Lille - Juventus: Gozubuyuk (Van Boekel)
Sporting - ManCity: Kovacs (Kwiatolski)
Bologna - Monaco: Visser (Ruperti)
Brugge - Villa: Grinfeeld (Martins)
Donetsk - Bern: Xhaja (Van Boekel)
Bayern - Benfica: Letexier (Millot)
Inter - Arsenal: Siebert (Dingbert)
Paris - Atletico: Taylor (Coote)
Feyenoord - Salzburg: Manzano (Del Grande)
Red Star - Barcelona: Massa (Di Paolo)
Sparta - Brest: Kabakov (Delajod)
Stuttgart - Atalanta: Hernandez (Bengotexia)
Kapitanis is the observer in Dortmund - He's already observed Kavanagh in Nations League, so updated prediction below (no observer yet for Inter v Arsenal):
DeletePSV - Girona: Kavanagh (Attwell)
Slavan - Dinamo: Stegermann (Brand)
Dortmund - Graz: Sozza (Chiffi)
Liverpool - Leverkusen: Sanchez (del Cerro Grande)
Real - Milan: Turpin (Millot)
Celtic - Leipzig: Saggi (Higler)
Lille - Juventus: Gozubuyuk (Van Boekel)
Sporting - ManCity: Kovacs (Kwiatolski)
Bologna - Monaco: Visser (Ruperti)
Brugge - Villa: Grinfeeld (Martins)
Donetsk - Bern: Xhaja (Van Boekel)
Bayern - Benfica: Letexier (Millot)
Inter - Arsenal: Siebert (Dingbert)
Paris - Atletico: Taylor (Coote)
Feyenoord - Salzburg: Manzano (Del Grande)
Red Star - Barcelona: Massa (Di Paolo)
Sparta - Brest: Kabakov (Delajod)
Stuttgart - Atalanta: Hernandez (Bengotexia)
Any early predictions for the UCL final?
ReplyDeleteChefren,Referee observers were appointed for the 4th week of the Europa League today.Or was it appointed yesterday?Do you have information about this?
ReplyDeleteI don't know because I didn't check yesterday, so I can't say about the exact moment of the appointment, can I ask again why it is so important to know tnat for you? I don't think that a day or another can change anything...
DeleteThe observer appointed, Elmir Pilav, can indicate an Elite referee for this one, Galatasaray - Tottenham.
On Friday, yes :)
DeleteThat could indicate that some names in UEL/UECL can make an appearance in MD4 again.
OT
ReplyDeleteRwandan veteran international referee Salima Mukansanga has announced her retirement from refereeing at the age of (only!) 36. Congratulations for what she has achieved in her journey, including being selected as support referee in FIFA men's World Cup in 2022.
Source: https://www.newtimes.co.rw/article/21235/sports/football/football-fraternity-pays-tribute-to-retiring-referee-mukasanga
OT:
ReplyDeleteSunday (27/10) - Greece:
Panathinaikos x Aris Saloniki: Zwayer, Kempter, Dietz, Vergetis (GRE), Perl, Evangelou (GRE).
Any reports about Sanchez Martinez in El Clasico?
ReplyDeleteSolid I'd say .. No big talking points.
DeleteGot some fouls wrong but overall a good performance.