Blog about the man in the middle: appointments, analysis, discussions and much more. You are welcome.
Europa League 20/21! Wow - we are going to be seeing a great amount of officials used each matchday if they appoint full VAR teams!
Well, it will be 1 more official per match then it is now, assuming var team will have 3 members.
Hillary and Obama are giving loads of money to Google, Facebook and Twitter to steal the election and put crooked democatic politicians back in power to push open borders Look at this
VAR will also be used at Asian Cup 2019, AFC announced today.
European Championship 2024 in Germany ;)
Congratulations for all Germans here!
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
OTDo you agree with this offside call? Correct decision to consider the player as active once he ran towards the ball?Without the offside flag, referee would have assigned a corner kick.Sorry for the quality of the video. https://streamable.com/lxwim
Offside for my taste.
Offside for me :)
Not offside for me. While he's active, he's not interfering with an opponent here as no defender is going towards the ball to make a play on it so no impacting the ability of an opponent.
Law 13.2 seems to be clear that an offside player is only penalised if they become involved in active play - by interfering with play/touching the ball, or if they interfere with an opponent. That player did neither so it should be a corner. http://www.theifab.com/laws/offside-2018/chapters/offside-offence-2018
Yeah, technically, under the LOTG, it's not an offside, but using some common sense... To be fair, I would accept both calls.
Page 196:”A player in an offside position may be penalised before playing or touching the ball, if, in the opinion of the referee, no other team-mate in an onside position has the opportunity to play the ball.”
Thank you for your opinions. I also think that offside is not punishable but one can understand why AR raised the flag. It is a very difficult situation to read, you see that player is running towards the ball and he wants to play it. So you maybe tend to raise the flag. But the choice is definitely not the right one: the player had not influenced any opponent by his action, nobody couldn't prevent the corner kick there.So for sure a very didactic case of study...
But IFAB guiedelines says you can raise the flag. Page 196
The distance bw the payer and the ball was close enough to be an offside, he almost reached the ball.
Cristiano Ronaldo suspended for only one game. Media understood that as UEFA's admission the red card was wrong. Really bad message from UEFA...
I'm curious about the next appointments for Brych and who will be his additional assistant referees...
Maybe Manchester United - Juventus was "too big" to missed it :D
Exactly my thoughts. Business, as always...
In my opinion the choice by UEFA was made because the decision by Fritz on the pitch had been clearly wrong. If he punished the alleged hair pulling - well, simply said - this never happened. But if Fritz had reported the previous kick by Cristiano Ronaldo (I think this action was missed), the player could have received even three matches of ban.
The hair pulling occurred. See the close replay and Ronaldo's hand move. Surely an excessive force used...https://twitter.com/ClassicMessi10/status/1042523509992431617
Ronaldo's hand is not on the Sevilla players head long enough to have actually "pulled hair". I see Ronaldo in what I guess you can consider "an aggressive manner" move his hand towards and make contact with the top of the head of the fallen Sevilla player. Of course if we want to be super strict, by the letter of the Law referee. Then yeah, totally supportable Red Card. Hands have zero business in or around an opponents head, face neck area.However I totally support UEFA's 1 match ban for Ronaldo. And I would have been just as supportive had UEFA decided to rescind the Red Card. But that would have left zero doubt about a mistake and would have totally exposed Brych and his crew.
I fully agree with Sheriff, just to make it clear what I mean for hair pulling: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FyiyHdUf27EReferee of this game was Orsato he didn't send off Chiellini...
Not everyone has long hair but the movement is pretty much the same. I can see it only as excessive force.
Ronaldo's hand is not on the Sevilla players head long enough to have actually "pulled hair". - Sheriff saysIt's long enough to rip someone's hair out. Especially with the force used by Ronaldo. And the subsequent hand's movement speaks for itself.
The hair pulling is clear. If you don't want to see it, then it is up to you. Whether you consider it to deserve a RC or not is a matter for discussion, but I think it was a fully correct decision. It is not so different to spit on to another player, form my point of view. BTW, Chefren, the hand movement is the same in Chiellini and in Ronaldo's situation. The only difference is for how long he holds the hair and the length of it.One final (but quite important) remark: it is not Sevilla. It was Valencia. I have to say, however, that Valencia's kit this season resembles some of Sevilla's, but it is because this year it is the 100th birthday of Valencia and they tried to reproduce their first kit colours.
Never RC IMO, so this decision by UEFA is fair. Of course, it's about CR7, thats also importang thing
I respect all your opinions and I'm happy to have nice discussions here on the blog, but for me this is never a RC in reality. Of course you can justify it by book, but it is not 100% clear that Cristiano Ronaldo wants to pull hair. This is my point of view.
What everyone can see is the head of the defender at the situation, it is moving upwards with the hand for a while, clear thing, Chiellini actions are softer, he only pullit, while Ronaldo does a shring out.
This comment has been removed by the author.
Simulation for me. The way he fell did not add up with the intensity of the contact too.
What do you think about that clip? penalty, play on or simulation?https://streamable.com/8ptzn
That's a clear simulation. VAR?
Penalty was confirm by VAR. No OFR, the play was just stopped to check.
The very very soft contact is totally irrelevant compared to the simulation movement made by the attacking player. So for me VAR should have corrected the decision to YC for Thauvin.
@Vlad: I posted this already in the other thread, but you were interested in the equalizing goal by Chelsea yesterday, which has been checked by VAR for a potential offside situation. I don't know if you have already seen it, but in case you haven't, here it comes.=> https://streamable.com/qp8ir
Oh, thanks, Stake! I totally forgot the yesterday's discussion! Best regards!
OT:With the AFC Champions League Semi-Final pairings set. And keeping in mind the Referee exchange program between CONCACAF and AFC. I wonder what CONCACAF referee along with his crew will be chosen to represent CONCACAF in Asia.What semifinal match up will they be assigned to? Will it be Al Sadd (QAT) vs Persepolis (IRN) or will it be Kashima Antlers (JAP) vs Suwon Bluewings (KOR)? Will it be a 1st Leg match or a deciding 2nd Leg match?Ravshan Irmatov and his crew officiated the 2nd Leg semifinal match between Club America (MEX) vs FC Toronto (CAN/"MLS"). Played on April 10, 2018 at Estadio Azteca.Opinons?
OTThere are some rumors that Danilo Grujic could lose FIFA badge again, also Nenad Djokic. Rumors says they'll be replaced with Milos Djurdjic and Novak Simovic...
OTSandro Schaerer wiil not be in charge of the Greek derby Olympiakos - PAOK on Sunday. According to Swiss FA he is injured and is replaced by San Fedayi (UEFA 3rd Group).
So this is the reason for which he was replaced by Bieri in EL before a very important observation for him on MD1.
Yes, probably he was injured then and he is injured again.
So a UEFA 3rd group referee has to do a very big match in Greece? Ridiculous...
And with very little experience, Rik B.He is FIFA since 2016 and his palmares is quite poor.Ridiculous to say the least.
What's next? De Albuquerque Troleis from the Faroe Islands?
Two U17 Euro preliminary qualifier groups:Group 1: Sweden , Netherlands, Montenegro, LiechtensteinReferees: Krzysztof Jakubik (POL), Iwan Arwel Griffith (WAL), Denys Shurman (UKR); Reserve Referee: Kaspar Sjöberg (SWE).Group 9: Hungary (host), Serbia, Romania, Lithuania.Referees: Kristoffer Karlsson (SWE), Rohit Saggi (NOR), Daniyar Sakhi (KAZ); Reserve Referee: Gergo Bogár (HUN).
Intersting to see a referee from Hungary as reserve referee in UEFA tournament after he has only 1 game in Hungarian I. Division.
@ Mark: Some nations (England, Germany, even Croatia) appoint second division referees as reserves in those tournaments.In Sweden observers are Laslo Vagner and Haim Jakov. In Hungary, Markus Nobs and Nuno Castro.
OT:Ivan Bebek will handle today's biggest match in Croatia between Hajduk and Dinamo.
OT:Andó-Szabó Sándor will handle today's Hungrian Budabest Derby between Ferencváros and Újpest.For the next week:Viktor Kassai Will have a local derby as referee in Saturday.István Vad will have a match in Saturday as AAR after his injury first time ( IMO he will not handle match in Europa in next week)Tamás Bognár will have a match in Saturday as AAR.Ádám Farkas ( II. Cat) IMO he will have debut in UEL in this season), will be AAR in Saturday.
2018 AFC U-16 Championship-Winner qualify for 2019 FIFA U-17 World Cup-Japan v Oman (30/9)Referee: Payam Heidari (Iran)AR: Arman Assadi (Iran), Ismailzhan Talipzhanov (Kyrgyztan)FO: Muhammad Nazmi bin Nasaruddin (Malaysia)Reserve AR: Mohamad Zairul bin Khalil Tan (Malaysia)Korea DPR v Tajikistan (30/9)Referee: Ammar Mahfoodh (Bahrain)AR: Sabet Obaid Al-Ali (UAE), Juma Mohammed Al-Burshaid (Qatar)FO: Omar Mohammed Al-Ali (UAE)Reserve AR: Ali Muhammad (Pakistan)Indonesia v Australia (1/10)Referee: Kim Woo Sung (Korea Republic)AR: Jang Jong Pil (Korea Republic), Jia Hao Chen (Chinese Taipei)FO: Pranjal Banerjee (India)Reserve AR: Abdul Hannan (Singapura)Korea Republic v India (1/10)Referee: Yusuke Araki (Japan)AR: Nishinashi Isao (Japan), Kijsathit Pattarapong (Thailand)FO: Saoud Ali Al-Adba (Qatar)Reserve AR: Ayman Faisal Obeidat (Jordan)All these referee have some AFC Cup matches here. Abdul Hannan is at the final game of AFF U-15 this year and were in Muhammad Taqi's team at friendly JPN-CRC. Shukri Al-Hunfush (KSA) were at this tournament too so that he can't officiate in Saudi league now. Muhammad Nazmi bin Nasaruddin had his AFF U-19 2 years ago.I want to ask question. Who will be VAR at AFC Asian Cup next year?
Very good performance by Clément Turpin in OGC Nice vs Paris Saint-Germain. A very strong 8.4.Key match incidents:Disallowed 0-2 goal after VAR interventionhttps://pasteboard.co/HG9wmRK.png2nd YC Cyprien (Nice) for reckless use of armhttps://streamable.com/mefvpPenalty incident, play-on call confirmed by VARhttps://streamable.com/kbmq4Very good onside at 0-3 goalhttps://pasteboard.co/HGa0EVM.pngAll cards were spot on. Cyprien x2 (for SPA by holding and reckless use of arm), Dante for reckless knee kick, Mbappé for reckless stamp.An interesting situation with, imo, reckless tackle from Nice player when Neymar avoided being hit. Turpin issued a warning in the next stoppage but it was not enough for my taste. Thoughts?https://streamable.com/h3ab9
Everything is correct there, a special mention for the penalty appeal, when I watched it for the first time, it looked a clear penalty, but replay definitely explained the decision taken by referee. About the last incident you mentioned, for sure a YC could have been issued, it would have been better than a warning. Turpin keeps his excellent form, he can achieve definitely much this season at UEFA level...
He was also very good last week in Lyon vs Marseille.I hope he will be as good as last season in UEFA
Good looking gestures by Latre at Barcelona, but strange positioning, often converting into wrong by turning the back to the competent assistant and being in front of the attack. Something not good to be seen on that level, but who knows, he could have had lack of belief at his colleagues.
Martínez Munuera has just officiated Madrid derby. Some discussion about a (IMO) grey area PK for handball asked by Atlético, with no VAR intervention.But, I liked his overall performance, never seemed to lose control and had full acceptance from players.
OT:IMO very good performance from Bebek in Croatian bigest derby between Hajduk and Dinamo.Of course match will be remembered for terrible performances from both teams,some even say this was their worst match ever,but Bebek's performance was very good.He chose very lenient way to handle the match,solved critical situations verbally and not by booking players which resulted in very small number of cards,only 4 were shown,all of them were correct(2 for SPA-Theophile,Palaversa,1 for kicking ball away-Hamza and another one for too much talking-Ivanovski).Maybe he missed or didnt give on purpose 2-3 cards,but it was the deby so he chose that lenient way and most importantly,he was pretty consistent,which was one of his flaws in past years when he officiated matches between these two rivals.So in Croatia noone is talking about Bebek which means he has done his job very well.
Skomina in Hoffenheim - City, Vinčić in United-Valencia.
Melo Perreira observing Skomina, Deaconu for Vinčić.