UEFA Referees Committee has chosen the following officials to handle 2020-21 Europa League's Round of 16 first legs.
18:55 CET - Prague (Eden Arena)
SK Slavia Praha (CZE) - Rangers FC (SCO)
Referee: Ovidiu Haţegan (ROU)
Assistant Referee 1: Vasile Florin Marinescu (ROU)
Assistant Referee 2: Sebastian Gheorghe (ROU)
Fourth Official: István Kovács (ROU)
Video Assistant Referee: Marco Di Bello (ITA)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Paolo Valeri (ITA)
UEFA Referee Observer: Jan Wegereef (NED)
UEFA Delegate: Sviatlana Hrynkevich (BLR)
SK Slavia Praha (CZE) - Rangers FC (SCO)
Referee: Ovidiu Haţegan (ROU)
Assistant Referee 1: Vasile Florin Marinescu (ROU)
Assistant Referee 2: Sebastian Gheorghe (ROU)
Fourth Official: István Kovács (ROU)
Video Assistant Referee: Marco Di Bello (ITA)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Paolo Valeri (ITA)
UEFA Referee Observer: Jan Wegereef (NED)
UEFA Delegate: Sviatlana Hrynkevich (BLR)
Manchester United FC (ENG) - AC Milan (ITA)
Referee: Slavko Vinčić (SVN)
Assistant Referee 1: Tomaž Klančnik (SVN)
Assistant Referee 2: Andraž Kovačič (SVN)
Fourth Official: Matej Jug (SVN)
Video Assistant Referee: Bastian Dankert (GER)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Jure Praprotnik (SVN)
UEFA Referee Observer: Alexandru Deaconu (ROU)
UEFA Delegate: Łukasz Wachowski (POL) Duncan Fraser (SCO)
FC Dynamo Kyiv (UKR) - Villarreal CF (ESP)
Referee: Michael Oliver (ENG)
Assistant Referee 1: Stuart Burt (ENG)
Assistant Referee 2: Simon Bennett (ENG)
Fourth Official: Peter Bankes (ENG)
Video Assistant Referee: Christopher Kavanagh (ENG)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Craig Pawson (ENG)
UEFA Referee Observer: Jouni Hyytiä (FIN)
UEFA Delegate: Milovan Đukanović (MNE)
AFC Ajax (NED) - BSC Young Boys (SUI)
Referee: Marco Guida (ITA)
Assistant Referee 1: Ciro Carbone (ITA)
Assistant Referee 2: Giorgio Peretti (ITA)
Fourth Official: Fabio Maresca (ITA)
Video Assistant Referee: Massimiliano Irrati (ITA)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Maurizio Mariani (ITA)
UEFA Referee Observer: Costas Kapitanis (CYP)
UEFA Delegate: Paul Zaharia (ROU)
Granada CF (ESP) - Molde FK (NOR)
Referee: Paweł Raczkowski (POL)
Assistant Referee 1: Radosław Siejka (POL)
Assistant Referee 2: Adam Kupsik (POL)
Fourth Official: Bartosz Frankowski (POL)
Video Assistant Referee: Pawel Gil (POL)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Tomasz Kwiatkowski (POL)
UEFA Referee Observer: Emil Bozhinovski (MKD)
UEFA Delegate: Lennart Vestervall (SWE)
Tottenham Hotspur (ENG) - GNK Dinamo (CRO)
Referee: Serdar Gözübüyük (NED)
Assistant Referee 1: Joost van Zuilen (NED)
Assistant Referee 2: Johan Balder (NED)
Fourth Official: Bas Nijhuis (NED)
Video Assistant Referee: Pol van Boekel (NED)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Dennis Higler (NED)
UEFA Referee Observer: Mikalis Koukoulakis (GRE)
UEFA Delegate: Andrey Medintsev (BUL)
Olympiacos FC (GRE) - Arsenal FC (ENG)
Referee: Daniel Siebert (GER)
Assistant Referee 1: Jan Seidel (GER)
Assistant Referee 2: Rafael Foltyn (GER)
Fourth Official: Christian Dingert (GER)
Video Assistant Referee: Marco Fritz (GER)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Sascha Stegemann (GER)
UEFA Referee Observer: Karen Nalbandyan (ARM)
UEFA Delegate: Anna Bordiugova (UKR)
AS Roma (ITA) - FC Shakhtar Donetsk (UKR)
Referee: Artur Dias (POR)
Assistant Referee 1: Rui Tavares (POR)
Assistant Referee 2: Paulo Soares (POR)
Fourth Official: Tiago Martins (POR)
Video Assistant Referee: João Pinheiro (POR)
Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Luis Godinho (POR)
UEFA Referee Observer: Cyril Zimmermann (SUI)
UEFA Delegate: Roland Tis (BEL)
Hategan with Kovacs’s AR1, Vasile Marinescu replacing Sovre. I don’t know if it is a good or a bad thing.
ReplyDeleteNijhuis, Van Boekel and Higler are tonight in Turin. They will travel to London Wednesday?
ReplyDeleteDefinitely not a good signal for Sovre, as I was guessing yesterday, I think he wont attend EURO...
ReplyDeleteThe fact that he was not given any suspension, when Coltescu was (albeit only a symbolic one), to be honest I think that signals that UEFA wants to keep Sovre available. Maybe not now, maybe not even in future CL matches, but perhaps for the EURO. I hope so, anyways. It would be a shame to see him miss out over this disaster.
DeleteSome 1st class ... candidates to be promoted next season
ReplyDeleteThe same for several years...
DeleteExcellent appointments for Daniel Siebert and Marco Guida.UEFA liked Siebert's performance in Napoli-Granada.
ReplyDeleteNormal assignments for Dias,Gözübüyük and Raczowski.
Ovidiu Hatgean with a quite good game but with a replaced AR1.Bad sign for Sovre and his participation in summer...
Not the best game for Michael Oliver,but first all it is important that he even can referee a match in COVID times.
Unexpected Slavko Vincic in the biggest match.UEFA liked his previous performance in Leipzig - Liverpool.
Why Vincic unexpected? He is one of the best UEFA have at the moment.
DeleteAgree with anonymous...Vincic is in a very good shape this season. I think he is fully expected and deserved.
DeleteTwo consecutive referees from Italy for the Young Boys. Rarely seen.
ReplyDeleteOctavian Şovre's international career is (surely) over. 1973-born, he isn't going to the EURO now, so his last international match was in Paris. At least he has an education programme to look forward to...
ReplyDeleteIt seems UEFA's decision took the refs committee by surprise: Haţegan - Şovre, Gheorghe - Kovács team were in Saudi Arabia on Friday.
I actually can't believe that I'm reading the names Guida, Siebert - how were their R32 performances were IN ANY WAY a recommendation for higher tasks? It's good to know that anything 8,0 and above is a "good performance" in this UEFA era.
Deserved appointments for Vinčić and Soares Dias after convincing on different levels in their CL KO debuts, and glad that Oliver finally got a game.
If the decision took the Ref Comm by surprise, doesn’t that mean Sovre still has a pretty good chance at the EURO? Perhaps this is just cautious management by UEFA, wanting to not put Sovre out in the Europa League a mere three days after this big headline comes out. I hope that’s the reasoning, anyways.
DeleteYes that's a good point, maybe the committee did want to take him out of the media fire so soon after the announcement, on the premise he will return for Haţegan's next assignment.
DeleteI guess we can only wait-and-see if Şovre returns for the EURO, but personally I wouldn't bet on it.
If UEFA did not want Sovre at Euro, they would have given him the same suspension as Coltescu. The non-suspension means that Sovre will be eligible for appointments after he completes the education indicated by UEFA. Otherwise, there is no point for 1973-born AR to continue...
DeleteI guess it is easy to become too fixed in the present. In Vinčić's delicate moment, I thought it could be even all over for him, but he returned without problems on a high level.
DeleteWith (poor) Colțescu having been put over the media parapet, I guess Şovre will be able to return in time without bigger issues. KSA appointment at least was a signal in that direction.
Exactly, if Vincic was back within few months, why not Sovre (although replacing an AR might be easier than finding another top referee)?
DeleteSome video clips from Russian league:
ReplyDeletehttps://t.me/REF_EX/194
https://t.me/REF_EX/195
https://t.me/REF_EX/197
https://t.me/REF_EX/198
https://t.me/REF_EX/199
https://t.me/REF_EX/206
1) Play on correct decision IMO
Delete2) Penalty + YC
3) Play on supportable
4) Penalty
5) Looks offside, not 100% sure though
6) RC, good decision by the ref
Spot on answers. 100% agree.
DeleteAbout Hategan assignment, we can point out that a FIFA referee has been appointed as fourth official, and the same had happened with Kovacs in the middle for EL game with Hategan fourth a few weeks ago. So maybe UEFA asked Romanian federation for selecting only international officials in this role, after the incident in Paris.
ReplyDeleteWe will see whether different names will appear in this role on next assignment for both Kovacs and Hategan.
Vincic in Manchester is a very good signal for him after his CL KO stage group, he showed a good performance, and committe liked it.
At moment he is absolutely in a good form, I don't know how much EURO can be a dream, if Skomina will be out (only in that case, it would be possible, in my opinion). But this should be known before.
Finally a game for Oliver and that's indeed already a success after the troubles, but it is clear that for UEFA Taylor comes before while Oliver must still wait for his chance at very high level.
The rest of appointments should be consequence of positive assessments by committe in previous games, it is very interesting that they didn't care at all about the troubles experienced by Siebert in Napoli - Granada, but, as I stated, important decisions were OK so indeed as Mikael wrote, this should be enough for UEFA.
Raczkowski is always liked by Rosetti, but without a real chance to advance.
I also have a question about Marciniak, no UEFA games, but regularly appointed in domestic league. This doesn't make sense, if he has health problems, he shouldn't officiate at all? What is the reason?
About Marciniak, Today i saw v interview with him and he said that, he has had problem with health after covid infection , but now he is recovered and he will back and he said that he will be referee in elimination WC :)
DeleteBut IDK, if he is health and he had good match in Greece, he should be back earlier maybe, next week
DeleteI think this is a sign that Oliver will have a CL game next week
DeleteIMO, Vincic should go to EURO independently from Skomina. There are not many alternatives at the moment, so that I think, that all referees, that have been used in CL R16 so far, will go to the EURO (if they don't mess it up hugely until then). That's 11 different referees until now - we can probably add Hategan, Oliver, Orsato and Mateu. Then there are three places (if it will be 18 in total again), maybe for Marciniak and Skomina, if they are fully recovered and maybe for Frappart.
DeleteEvery other Elite referee has not done much to justify a promotion in the last two years, I think.
It will be difficult for UEFA to find 18 top referees (17 men plus Frappart), so two referees from some countries (eg Spain, Germany) will be needed. In this context, Vincic has his place on merit.
DeleteVincic and Skomina definitely deserve Euro IMO
DeleteNobody misses Marciniak, a bad season with one match, as for me, this season we will not see him in the cups anymore
ReplyDeleteMy feeling is that these appointments were made before Marciniak fully recovered and got the "green light" to return. I believe that we will see him in FIFA/UEFA matches some time in March.
DeleteCalm down. Marciniak already told that he will be back (UEFA) in March.
DeleteAre you blind or you cant read :) ?
Deleteprobably most agree that Szymon has his best years behind him, now he is a 1st category judge
ReplyDeleteFirst category? He is the best elite referee ever.
Deletegood joke:)
DeleteWell, this is normal. There are a number of names in elite category are 1st category in my mind, such as Sidiropoulos and Karasev.
DeleteSam, I couldn't agree more.
DeleteI watched the Paris - Barcelona game this morning. Thoughts:
ReplyDeleteKMIs
I thought the discussions on the blog yesterday were really excellent and I have little to add (both penalties, potential SYCs).
One can only assume that Attwell only checked the goalkeeper position at the saved penalty, which is actually a big / very hard to accept mistake.
Managing the game
I agree with the consensus - Taylor was very good! We all know that the FA's lobby is very strong, so 2020 could be a stellar year for him in terms of international appointments if he carries on like this.
I want to speak a bit about this 'Taylor vs. Oliver' debate which comes up very often. I would really like to conduct a sociological study re. Michael Oliver, and why so many young people like him so much! It seems they identify with his personality and style somehow.
Taylor simply has a better feel for this 'helicopter overview' as was excellently described on TTT - he can stay in the background and knows when to step in with cards and presence.
Personally, I don't see the same skills in Oliver in his UEFA games (also in foul detection, leadership style), though he is a very clear first place in terms of PL matches.
That being said, I believe both will go to the EURO.
Balance: very good performance from Taylor, but the VMOs not recalling the second penalty is disappointing.
I think that Taylor is certainly on course for CL Semi-final and can even be thrown into the mix for EL final. This of course depends on progression of English teams in both competitions. He is clearly trusted at the highest level.
DeleteIn terms of Oliver and Taylor, I agree that Taylor's style certainly helps him in international games hence why he is given many important games. This is somewhat reversed in the PL, although both receive important games it is Oliver who would be considered the number one.
We cannot forget, however, that Taylor is 42 compared to Oliver who is just 36 still. Oliver could potentially still have more than a decade of refereeing. Assuming he continues at the level he is at in the PL, he has plenty of time to figure the best way to 'adapt' his own personal style when it comes to international refereeing. I think he can expect another year or two of 'good' but not 'excellent' appointments at international level but given the experience he already has and the time he still has left, I strongly believe he will reach the very top of international refereeing.
I think both Taylor and Oliver will be at Euros.
I don't get what UEFA and people on this blog see in Taylor, I watch a lot of his games in the EPL and I don't think he is very good at all Olivier by far should be number 1 in England then followed by Kavanagh
DeleteMarciniak appointed on Saturday at 1 Liga (second tier) match with his regular assistants.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWmi1mtJqfg
ReplyDeleteFrom Belarus Cup QFs - can anybody translate what the committee's conclusions were?
1. ok
Delete2. 2YC - ok
3. RC - ok, penalty - mistake AR.
Manchester - Milan early minutes: correctly disallowed goal by AR2 and now another intervention for handball before the goal scored by Milan. It was disallowed without OFR. Such situations are always difficult to spot live.
ReplyDeleteHow could that possibly be a yc? Acting by the fouled player sold it, but the foul didn't appear reckless.
ReplyDeleteWhat game?
DeleteFor me clear YC, it was a late tackle
DeleteMan U - Milan. Didn't realize that there are 4 games being played tonight.
DeleteAppointments for World Cup preliminars
ReplyDeleteRomania - Macedonia
Fabio Verissimo (Portugal)
Romania - Germany
Clement Turpin (France)
Armenia - Romania
Andris Treimanis (Latvia)
https://www.frf.ro/recomandate/arbitrii-delegati-la-partidele-romaniei-din-martie-in-preliminariile-cm-2022/
Another appointments?
These appointments should be confidential at moment, so Romanian football federation did a mistake by publishing them.
DeleteDecent half from hategan. Correct yc for rangers, yc for Prague manager too. Czech side playacting a bit towards the end but he hasn't fallen for it.
ReplyDeleteI think the 2nd half might be a bit more feisty
Hategan very much favoring the home team here
DeleteMUN - MIL Slavko Vincic
ReplyDeletecorrect disallowed goal by AR2
correct disallowed goal by VAR Dankert due to a handball prior the 0-1
possible wrong offside call by AR1 in 32'
wrong YC for Milan,contact is there but nothing reckless and no stamp on the foot,normal contact
Only one word for Vincic's motivation and fitness: EXCELLENT!
Agree. After two deliberate fouls from behind by Milan players before, caution issued was timely - definitely more careless than reckless, but still late and a defendable call IMO.
DeleteTotally wrong assessed foul by Guida, so also wrong YC for Tagliafico
ReplyDeleteClean tackle on the ball
Wrong YC indeed. It seems Guida's positioning is a bit off in the second half, he is quite far away from the ball most of the time.
DeleteBorderline stamp of Aebischer. YC given by Guida. No VAR intervention is supportable.
ReplyDeleteGuida over-all does decent, 8.2 level so far, but I am not really happy with his style. Bit uninterested, bit unclear at times, and a couple of YC's were possible to interpret different. Over-all, dcent job.
ReplyDelete83' missed second YC Manchester?
ReplyDeleteI think a second yellow there would be harsh. But I think another foul by McTominey and he will see a second yellow
DeleteIMO clear SPA
DeleteShould be assessed as SPA - very clear passing option to the left.
DeleteGood performance by Slavko Vincic!
ReplyDeleteFirst of all I want to underline his outstanding fitness level today! He could be a real challenge for Gil Manzano :)
Correct YC for McTominay 55'
Correct to give NOT a 2YC to the same player,contact was there but player exaggerated the shirt pulling
Missed YC for Amad Diallo in 90+1' similar foul where Saelemaekers was cautioned.
is there a video about milan disallowed goal ?
ReplyDeleteYes, here: https://streamable.com/s5zxts
DeleteGood job
DeleteDisallowed goal is not clear, UEFA must show video!
ReplyDeleteat first replay I've the perception that the ball splats one second on kessie arm but it's no clear agree
DeleteThe replay they show at bout 28 seconds is clear as day there's no doubt it hit his arm
Deletehttps://streamable.com/s5zxts
DeleteAnonymous, does not open...
DeleteGood first half for Siebert on Olympiakos - Arsenal. The match is of normal/easy difficulty with 3 correct cautions. No problems with control and acceptance. Good foul detection.
ReplyDeletePositioning needs improvement.
And 1 clear missed caution for an undeniable reckless stamp on foot in the early minutes.
DeleteDisagree here Edward. Stamp missed at 10' was really clear and in general I think Siebert was too passive (especially regarding (potential) SPA offences). His gestures and mimics were really not sophisticated (-> too aggressive) either.
DeleteHis approach seems to be inflaming the match, not calming it down.
Possible offside at 67?
DeleteYes, I would say the attacker impeded the goalkeeper there - missed that live, well-spotted!
DeleteQuiet 2H, good performance by the German ref.
On the whole, this was no resume to be promoted to Elite for Siebert in my eyes.
I would have liked to see Siebert in a match with crowd. Certainly that would have been a real test.
Delete+1
DeleteI think he'll replace Aytekin in Elite regardless of performance, maybe even as early as the summer.
I believe that you are correct. Germany is a big refereeing nation and can support 4 Elite referees. I think that we have seen it before.
DeleteGermany currently have 4 Elite referees: Brych, Stieler, Zwayer and Aytekin. If no replacement, Siebert would be the 5th, unless Brych will retire after Euro.
DeleteIt is quite likely that Brych will retire after EURO, so maybe nobody will have to be replaced.
DeleteSo if you consider that and you add the current form of Aytekin and Zwayer, you could even dare to say that at moment the only "stable" German Elite referee is the new one, Stieler, and therefore it is absolutely logical to look for another one.
But, and I also agree with Mikael, so far definitely not convinced by Siebert. He needs a real development before such important step.
Maybe Brych will stay one more year, so Germany will have a good candidate for WC2022? If he will retire and Zwayer is not in his best form, who will be going from Germany?
DeleteGood first half for Soares Dias in Roma. No problems at all,only some minor problems.
ReplyDeletePotential missed YC for Cristante for a tactical foul. Should be rewatched.(18')
In 40' Cristante made another foul (with elbow) and now should be cautioned.
AR2 Paulo Soares with a perfect onside decision prior Roma 1-0. Four correct offside ppsitions detected (1',3',11',17').
I think this should have been OFR. Handball can be factual decision but in these 2 videos, handball is not clear. I think it’s better way for the referee watch it on monitor and decide.
ReplyDeleteNo VAR intervention in London? Looked a quite clear penalty.
ReplyDeleteYesterday we were told a stamp on the foot is a stamp on the foot is a foul. Defender was late, didn’t play the ball and hit attacker’s foot. Penalty should have been awarded IMO.
DeleteVery clear penalty in my opinion. If Gozubuyuk saw it but he didn't want to whistle (and this can be only reason for NO INTERVENTION) it is referee's mistake, definitely. Impossible to support...
DeleteDid anyone see Oliver?
ReplyDeleteI saw. Fantastic foul detection, good personality and presence on the pitch. He had no controversial situations but it was a very good match also because well-helped by Stuart and Simon.
DeleteI agree, not too difficult game, but he did a good job.
DeleteI have no explanation for NO VAR intervention in Tottenham - Dinamo Zagreb a few minutes ago. If OFR in Taylor's game yesterday was correct, well, this was more than obvious. Given that van Boekel is very experienced, I really don't understand what happened there.
ReplyDeleteI think that the referee thought the reaction of the home team player was too much and that the contact was more from the side. He had a very good body language and was calm and convinced. However, it did seem like a clear foul and OFR material.
DeleteActually the referee was very far away from the incident, not anticipating towards the zone where the action could be expected.
Deletewhat minute happened ?
DeletePredictions 2nd leg?
ReplyDeleteRangers - Praag: Gil Manzano
DeleteVillareal - Kiev: Schrarer
Milan - United: Stieler
Young Boys - Ajax: Marciniak
Zagreb - Spurs: Kulbakov
Molde- Granada: Collum
Arsenal - Olympiakos: Grinfeld
Shakhtar - Roma: Zwayer
I think Rosetti is very hard to predict, but let's give it a try
DeleteUCL
BMG - MCI: Mateu Lahoz
RMA - ATA: Makkelie
BAY - LAZ: Oliver
CHE - ATL: Orsato
UEL:
DIN - TOT: Grinfeld
MOL - GRA: Sidiropoulos
ARS - OLY: Massa
SHK - ROM: Stieler
YB - AJA: Kovacs
MIL - MANU: Del Cerro Grande
VIL - DNK: Kulbakov
RAN - SLA: Zwayer
My predictions for next week (VAR in brackets):
DeleteManchester-Gladbach: Mateu (Martinez)
Real-Atalanta: Makkelie (Blom)
Bayern-Lazio: Gil Manzano (Hernandez)
Chelsea-Atletico: Orsato (Guida)
Rangers - Prague: Marciniak (Gil)
Villareal - Kiev: Brych (Fritz)
Milan - United: del Cerro Grande (Sanchez)
Young Boys - Ajax: Sidiropoulos (Dingert)
Zagreb - Spurs: Zwayer (Stegemann)
Molde- Granada: Bastien (Delajod)
Arsenal - Olympiakos: Karasev (Meshkov)
Shakhtar - Roma: Stieler (Dankert)
Hard to see Del Cerro and Stieler for Italian teams after very controversial performance in JUV-Porto (clear penalty not given) and ATA-RMA (though the RC was right IMO)
DeleteOpinions about Arsenal’s second goal?
ReplyDeletenothing wrong with it, Olympiakos player play acted to try and get it disallowed
DeleteHowever Gabriel's elbow is on defender's neck
DeleteIt is a good header IMO, I think it would be bad to disallow this goal. Football expects a goal, similiar to Maguire vs. Burnley in January 2021.
DeleteWonder if Madden might get a match given he missed his last 32 tie for covid reasons
ReplyDeleteI agree,I think Madden will get a match and Collum will not I dont see Scotland getting two appointments
DeleteGood match from Raczkowski
ReplyDeleteGreat Raczkowski and his team! In my opinion in 2 years he will be in elite.
ReplyDeleteI was really impressed by Radoslaw Siejka!! He did a great job with some calls that neither a robot would have done. I noticed him in PSG-Leipzig when he was the substitute of Listkiewicz in Team Marciniak. Then I saw it in a Tottenham match, last month in Rangers-Royal Antwerp and yesterday.
DeleteReally great assistant referee.
The incident in Tottenham - Dinamo Zagreb:
ReplyDeletehttps://streamable.com/34he0k
Just to clarify my point of view, if VAR doesn't intervene in such situation in Italy, he is removed from his duties without doubts at the end of the season...
It would be very, very interesting to know the reason of this choice by van Boekel, according to what Gözübüyük saw and said to him.
It is the most obvious penalty ever seen, if you ask me.
I agree. The most clear penalty that you will see.
DeleteIMO, VAR intervention is mandatory here.
Agree that this should be a VAR intervention. "Most clear penalty you will see", "removed from his duties" just indicates that the people on this blog (Chefren, Mikael, Edward) have a very limited view of football. They have expertise on referees yes, but they lack the feeling for the match. That is why they are here and not on a football field.
DeleteI don’t understand why you think it’s necessary to personally disqualify these people with your last sentence. You can disagree of course and present arguments, but your conclusion seems rather poor and your tone arrogant. Why do you choose to discuss the people who present the opinion instead of the situation/decision?
Delete@Anonymous at 22:16
DeleteI can sympathize with you. It has been a difficult week for Dutch refereeing. Moreover I think it's clear that Gozubuyuk has lost his chances of promotion to the Elite.
Actually he was never Elite material IMO.
Chefren, sorry for my late reply, one off the reasons why probably Pol van Boekel doesn't give easy penalty's is he is been a former professional football player himself, to be honest... i'm also a referee myself, and yes i'm Dutch, but to give a penalty for this feels cheap for me, personally i'm also not a person that gives easy/soft penalty's,,, you know in my vieuw a penalty is not something you should get like a present, but something you worked hard for and fully 150% deserved, i mean.... not tot easy, i think that's the reason why they don't give it
DeleteIMO
Deleteit's a mandatory PK and OFR missed and I'm sure that Rosetti and Co. are (very) unhappy with it. However, I don't think it's one of the clearest I have ever seen, that's too harsh.
In addition, I think it's ridiculous to deem that clear stamp on foot as "soft PK".
And if you give penalties for how hard the attacker works for it, we are totally lost, I'm sorry. Referees have to apply the LotG appropriately and if there is such a foul, I give a penalty. It's just a dumb movement by the defender.
If that was the reason for them to not give that PK, it makes it even worse for me.
Flip i think we have a clear different opinion in what is a very clear stamp for you, and what is a very clear stamp for me... this is not even a stamp for me....just a very light touch, yes there is a touch.... but realy need the player to fall over this??? i don't think so, that's also why i also after 10 times seeing this video, and after slowmotion would not give a penalty
DeleteChefren? Are you serious? Did you have something against van Boekel / Gozubyuk? Most obvious? Of course this is not a penalty. This soft penalty’s destroyed football. Big compliment to continue
ReplyDeleteWhat is the attacker supposed to do in this situation Referee1?
DeleteYes I'm serious, nothing against van Boekel and Gözübüyük, focus on the incident. The defender tries to go for the ball but he clearly hits attacker. There isn't any anticipation of contact by attacker who is only trying to advance with ball. The contact with foot is more than clear, the full incident is in my opinion a full classic penalty sequence, I can't find arguments to say "not enough". This would be valid in case of movements by attacker as well, but actually he does nothing and he is clearly hit. Very sophisticad and in my opinion wrong to make an assessment like this, even more from referee's position, you see, he is very far. So, could he make such evaluation? Difficult to say, in a normal context this should have been OFR. In case of incident happened in a game with Italian team and with an important score, this would have been perceived as shocking and without explanation. That's my point of view.
DeleteIMO very clear penalty. With VAR, this is unacceptable
DeleteThat's a super clear penalty. Stamp + tripping.
DeleteBut you still continue and continue. You gave your opinion and we respect it. But it is now for years that some “refs” are trying to kill here. First it was always Mazic, Kassai, Cakir. You give your opinion and that’s it. Why post many times about in my opinion soft penalty. Please be fair. This is a education blog. You say yes , I say no. Respect it, no hard feelings
ReplyDeleteIt's the end of discussion, of course I respect all the opinions, I posted another message just to show the video! That's all!
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletemanchester united f.c. (eng) - a.c. milan (ita)
referee slavko vincic (svn)
var bastian dankert (ger)
04' ok no yc kessie (mil) for slight stamp
05' goal mil disallowed due to offside (ar2)
11' (r.16') goal mil disallowed after var intervention because of handball
17' advantage issue
18' yc saelemaekers (mil) for reckless kick
33' warning james (mun) for delaying the restart
34' penalty incident, ok play-on after possible tripping by kjaer (mil)
44' penalty incident, ok play-on after holding by kjaer (mil)
ht whistle chat with kjaer (mil) about the holding penalty incident
46' handball issue
50' possible yc meite (mil) for spa
55' yc mctominay (mun) for spa
59' penalty incident, correct play-on after alleged jumping at an opponent by wan-bissaka (mun)
67' missed foul and yc matic (mun) for reckless stamp
83' possible 2nd yc mctominay (mun) for spa
85' possible yc rafael leao (mil) for spa
90' missed yc amad (mun) for reckless stamp; conflict management
90+1' correct play-on after accidental handling
Welcome back and thanks for all your reports!
Deletehttps://ninjastream.to/watch/lWJQjwoV4ZdXn
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletea.f.c. ajax (ned) - b.s.c. young boys (sui)
referee marco guida (ita)
var massimiliano irrati (ita)
21' possible yc sulejmani (yb) for spa
24' penalty incident, correct play-on after alleged push
28' possible yc lustenberger (yb) for reckless kick
31' missed fk for studs-up challenge
32' handball issue, possible yc rensch (ajx) for spa
37' possible yc lefort (yb) for reckless kick, no replay
40' possible yc tadic (ajx) for reckless kick
49' yc lauper (yb) for reckless tackle
51' [r.52', 53'] penalty incident, play-on after late striking with head by zesiger (yb)
53' play-on after possible simulation, no replay
53' harsh yc tagliafico (ajx) for reckless tackle
57' possible yc tadic (ajx) for reckless use of arm
59' possible yc klaassen (ajx) for reckless use of arm
64' yc aebischer (yb) for reckless stamp
77' yc sierro (yb) for reckless kick
86' [r.87'] missed handball in attack
88' possible yc timber (ajx) for reckless kick / spa, no replay
90+2' good onside at 3-0 goal (ar2)
https://ninjastream.to/watch/lWJQjlpn5mdXn
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletef.c. dynamo kyiv (ukr) - villarreal c.f. (esp)
referee michael oliver (eng)
var christopher kavanagh (eng)
09' yc sydorchuk (dkv) for reckless tackle
12' missed fk and possible yc kedziora (dkv) for handling / spa
14' missed fk and yc gerson rodrigues (dkv) for reckless stamp
21' accidental clash between gerson rodrigues (dkv) and geronimo rulli (vil)
24' yc alfonso pedraza (vil) for spa
30' [r.43'] good onside at 0:1 (ar2)
36' possible yc ? (vil) for delaying the restart
39' play-on after exaggerated fall by gerson rodrigues (dkv)
41' accidental stamp on hand by capoue (vil)
45+1' [r.45+2'] play-on after alleged illegal use of arm
49' handball issue
53' [r.56'] penalty incident, play-on after handball by shaparenko (dkv)
65' yc capoue (vil) for reckless stamp
70' [r.71'] missed idfk for dangerous play of byesyedin (dkv)
82' possible yc raul albiol (vil) for reckless kick, no replay
85' possible yc moi gomez (vil) for deliberate(?) landing on an opponent
https://ninjastream.to/watch/5YRQoGJ9rQ0aN
DeleteBelarusian Premier League Week 1 Highlights:
ReplyDeleteIsloch vs. Slavia Mozyr
Ref. Viktor Shimusik (UEFA 3rd Caetgory)
Foul + RC Missed?:
https://youtu.be/MY2DZ0f4YDE?t=196
IMO it's a FK and DOGSO RC. However, the foul isn't that clear, so I wouldn't call it a clear mistake.
DeleteAfter watching the performance of Guida in Ajax - Young Boys, i'm convinced he will not reach Elite. He is lacking the soft skills and a bit random foul management. Fine for group fase EL, but nothing more.
ReplyDeleteAgree. Not a bad referee at all, but just not a referee with a really convincing way of doing.
DeleteMy thoughts too! In the past I saw one brilliant performance of him in one of the big Serie A game where he showed great soft skills (so actually he has this x-factor) but in UEFA he is really average. Whistle -> nothing or card, no management at all.
Delete12th March 2021 Süper Lig Matchday 30
ReplyDeleteMedipol Başakşehir - Beşiktaş 2:3
Cüneyt Çakır - Bahattin Duran - Tarık Ongun - Zorbay Kücük
[Mustafa Öğretmenoğlu - Ekrem Kan]
https://m.tr.beinsports.com/mac-merkezi/medipol-basaksehir-besiktas?id=111459997&tab=video#
01.12 potential penalty for Beşiktaş,no VAR intervention
01.55 potential penalty for Beşiktaş,no VAR intervention
4 YCs (46' 61' 61' 89') all correct.No problems for Çakir in this game which was exciting only in the second half.His fitness was very good after the difficult game on Tuesday in Dortmund.
To be honest, I expect him as a VAR on this weekend in some of the games. But maybe he could be a option for a difficult match in European matches?
11.03.21
ReplyDeletes.k. slavia praha (cze) - rangers f.c. (sco)
referee ovidiu alin hategan (rou)
var marco di bello (ita)
05' possible yc boril (slp) for reckless stamp, no replay
09' [r.10'] penalty incident, play-on after alleged holding by helander (ran)
11' prevention at corner kick
15' warning morelos (ran) for exaggerating contact
16', 17' fouls in attack correctly whistled
22' [r.23'] play-on after possible spa tackle by kamara (ran)
24' warning kudela (slp) for late challenge
25' correct no yc boril (slp) after normal foul and exaggerated reaction
29' yc barisic (ran) for spa
32' ok no yc patterson (ran) for possible spa
39' dubious fk to ran, yc to slp staff member
40' possible yc goldson (ran) for spa
43' ok no yc hagi (ran) after careless kick
47' play-on after possible holding/spa by kent (ran)
51' idfk for dangerous play by morelos (ran) instead of fk to ran
53' missed fk slp for handling
54' harsh yc davis (ran) for reckless stamp
56' yc zima (slp) for spa
65' possible yc morelos (ran) for impeding progress
72' possible yc masopust (slp) for reckless tackle
83' possible yc oscar (slp) for reckless kick, no replay
86' correct play-on after collision
87' penalty incident, possible strike, fk for foul in attack
https://ninjastream.to/watch/dwPAV4nNzZR09
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletegranada c.f. (esp) - molde f.k. (nor)
referee pawel raczkowski (pol)
var pawel gil (pol)
06' missed offside by ar2
08' correct play-on after possible handball
26' good advantage prior to 1:0
33' yc eteki (gra) for spa
36' advantage, possible yc nehuen perez (gra) for reckless strike with head
40' very good delayed flag by ar1 after offside
42' warning sinyan (mol) after careless use of arm, dissent roberto soldado (gra)
48' harsh yc sigurdarson (mol) for reckless kick / spa
57' yc hestad (mol) for reckless kick; reckless or sfp?
68' advantage, yc ellingsen (mol) for reckless stamp and correct no penalty after alleged handball
71' 2nd yc ellingsen (mol) for reckless tackle
79' penalty incident, play-on after handball by victor diaz (gra)
89' [r.90', 90+1'] play-on in a possible spa scenario, yc eikrem (mol) for dissent
https://ninjastream.to/watch/8ogAvKpYlQGMD
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletea.s. roma (ita) - f.c. shakhtar donetsk (ukr)
referee artur soares dias (por)
var joao pinheiro (por)
09' play-on in a possible spa scenario
11' good delayed flag by ar2
19' possible yc cristante (rom) for spa
23' good onside at 1:0 by ar2
25' possible yc pellegrini (rom) for reckless tackle
38' possible yc mancini (rom) for reckless kick
40' warning cristante (rom) for another team's foul
49' possible yc mancini (rom) for spa
55' yc kumbulla (rom) for spa
58' yc alan patrick (shk) for reckless stamp, advantage problem
61' possible yc diawara (rom) for spa
63', 66' very good onsides by ar1
64' missed offside by ar1
67' [r.68'] penalty incident, play-on after alleged kicking by cristante (rom)
73' [r.76'] advantage issue prior to 2:0, yc maycon (shk) and taison (shk) for dissent, missed yc gonzalo villar (rom) for reckless kick
75' penalty incident, play-on after possible charging, no replay
76' good onside by ar1
83' play-on in a possible spa scenario, yc mancini (rom) for dissent
86' conflict management
https://ninjastream.to/watch/9dbmXKnyvZyEO
DeleteSurprise surprise - Al-Jassim didn't tell a player "I will kill you", as this article explains.
ReplyDeletehttps://japantoday.com/category/sports/japan's-kobayashi-apologises-for-saying-referee-threatened-to-kill-him
Honestly, It's quite distasteful how easy you can dish out such a huge accusation as a death threat and yet after just say "It was a misunderstanding", it's the easy escape. You have to bee 300% sure about it if you want to talk about it.
DeleteIt reminds me a situation in France where former FIFA referee Tony Chapron was publicly accused of being racist by a player after being sent off, and when match officials gave the recording of their communication during the game, it was clear that this was a lie. Ironically this incident has not saved Chapron from being classified as racist by fans even with clear evidence of the contrary (!!!)
I hope (even if is quite delusional) a punishment will follow, because it's just unacceptable; social medias and co are a very powerful entity which is a front door to hatred, and players are well aware of that.
... or Kobayashi changed his mind in order to continue safely in Qatar?
DeleteVery good way of using the VAR system in La Liga’s match between Getafe and Atletico Madrid. Referee Sánchez Martínez incorrectly issues only a YC to Getafes Nyom after a studs on calf tackle. VAR after a swift check advises an OFR and Sánchez Martínez only needs a quick view on the monitor before deciding for a fully deserved RC to Nyom. All solved in only 1 minute and 49 seconds from foul to RC.
ReplyDeleteIt was indeed a quick process, such SFP was ultra clear and decision has been adjusted quickly.
DeleteLater in the game, a penalty could've been awarded, but I think VAR was right to support Sanchez Martinez, no clear and obvious mistake IMO.
And the other way around in the Real Madrid game. For example when Ramos clearly got pulled down with an arm lock. Nothing from VAR.
DeleteReally strange scene in the Eredivisie today. The trainer of FC Groningen pulled/pushed a player of the opponent down. Referee Lindhout (UEFA 3rd category) gave a YC. Enough?
ReplyDeletehttps://twitter.com/ESPNnl/status/1370845610602082307?s=20
Clear RC ("physical behaviour towards an opposing player")
DeleteMandatory RC for me.
DeleteIf it was a throw-in for the navy blue team, then I agree it's a crystal clear RC, also by the LotG.
DeleteHowever, given the context (throw-in to greens, clear DtR play, match time, players reaction, not a punch or sth like that) - YC is a sensible choice.
In any case I'm sure KNVB and van Egmond will support the common-sensical position.
I’m not that sure. Philipp S quoted the relevant passage in the LOTG, then I see no room for interpretation for Yellow Card here. It’s literally addressed in the Laws
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeletetottenham hotspur f.c. (eng) - g.n.k. dinamo (cro)
referee serdar gozubuyuk (ned)
var pol van boekel (ned)
03' warning after careless use of arm
10' prevention at corner kick
14' warning leovac (dzg) after late challenge
16' missed fk after impeding progress
25' correct play-on in the build-up to 1:0
32' play-on after alleged handball in dogso scenario
37' play-on after tackle
42' possible yc aurier (tot) for reckless kick
44' play-on in a possible spa scenario, no replay
44' play-on in a possible spa scenario, no replay
45+1' possible yc majer (dzg) for spa
45+1' yc dier (tot) for reckless tackle
48' missed fk tot after careless kick
50' missed pk tot after careless trip by majer (dzg)
54' good advantage, possible yc davies (tot) for ub
55' missed yc petkovic (dzg) for reckless use of arm
67' missed fk and yc davinson sanchez (tot) for reckless stamp
67' play-on after tackle
68' yc ademi (dzg) for reckless stamp
77' yc ivanusec (dzg) for spa
79' yc davinson sanchez (tot) for reckless kick
82' missed fk tot after push close to ar1
85' yc hoejbjerg (tot) for holding / spa
86' missed fk dzg after holding
88' play-on after challenge, possible yc leovac (dzg) for reckless kick, yc ristovski (dzg) for dissent
90' missed fk and yc leovac (dzg) for reckless use of arm / spa close to ar1; ub or vc?
https://ninjastream.to/watch/gLeZyJwy4mrKN
Delete11.03.21
ReplyDeleteolympiakos f.c. (gre) - arsenal f.c. (eng)
referee daniel siebert (ger)
var marco fritz (ger)
01' possible yc el arabi (oly) for reckless use of arm
10' missed yc valbuena (oly) for reckless stamp
16' ok no yc lala (oly) after careless kick
18' [r.20'] good onside by ar1
20' possible yc aubameyang (ars) for spa
22' yc m'vila (oly) for reckless tackle
25' ok no yc reabciuk (oly) after possible spa
26' [r.28'] good play-on after exaggerated fall
37' [r.39'] ok play-on after exaggerated fall
37' yc bouchalakis (oly) for spa
39' missed ck oly
43' yc gabriel (ars) for reckless kick
44' correct play-on
45+1' correct play-on after exaggerated fall and missed fk and yc saka (ars) for spa-holding / reckless tackle
53' correct play-on after fair tackle
65' ok no yc papastatopoulos (oly) after possible spa
67' offside issue
76' ok no yc el arabi (oly) for careless use of arm
79' 1:2 allowed, possible illegal use of arm by gabriel (ars), yc to staff member oly for dissent
https://ninjastream.to/watch/w1ymMNdjlAJrb
DeleteI Finally Got Helped !! I'm so excited right now, I just have to share my testimony on this Forum.. The feeling of being loved takes away so much burden from our shoulders. I had all this but I made a big mistake when I cheated on my wife with another woman and my wife left me for over 4 months after she found out.. I was lonely, sad and devastated. Luckily I was directed to a very powerful spell caster Dr Emu who helped me cast a spell of reconciliation on our Relationship and he brought back my wife and now she loves me far more than ever.. I'm so happy with life now. Thank you so much Dr Emu, kindly Contact Dr Emu Today and get any kind of help you want.. Via Email emutemple@gmail.com or Call/WhatsApp cell number +2347012841542 Website (https://emutemple.wordpress.com/)
ReplyDeleteFive weeks ago my boyfriend broke up with me. It all started when i went to summer camp i was trying to contact him but it was not going through. So when I came back from camp I saw him with a young lady kissing in his bed room, I was frustrated and it gave me a sleepless night. I thought he will come back to apologies but he didn't come for almost three week i was really hurt but i thank Dr.Azuka for all he did i met Dr.Azuka during my search at the internet i decided to contact him on his email dr.azukasolutionhome@gmail.com he brought my boyfriend back to me just within 48 hours i am really happy. What’s app contact : +44 7520 636249
ReplyDelete