At the end of the first-ever VAR Instructor course put on by FIFA in Madrid this past week, legendary referee and current Chairman of FIFA’s Refereeing Committee Pierluigi Collina spoke with FIFA.com about the importance of the event, the state of VAR and where the technology might go in the future.
Mr Collina, can you describe why this seminar was organised?
It came about because FIFA received many requests from Member Associations after the success of VAR at the FIFA World Cup in Russia, and they were interested in the implementation process for their domestic competitions. At the moment it’s quite difficult to have VAR instructors because VAR is something very new. We decided to create a panel of instructors that could help implement VAR around the world. The VAR Instructor seminar was arranged this week in Madrid with some former referees and some active referees who had experience with VAR in their countries or were with us during the preparation of the 2018 World Cup.
What did that training look like?
Some of 40 candidates who went through the programme. It included theoretical lessons and also practical sessions with the VAR simulator, which reproduces exactly the VOR – the Video Operation Room, which is used during the match – using clips of matches already played. Then we had a practical sessions on the field with players creating planned incidents with decisions taken by the referee, who is in touch with the VOR where our instructor candidates were, so they learned how the VAR operates in a variety of situations and will be able to coach and instruct others to use the system in the future.
Is this likely to be repeated in the future?
At the moment, related to the specific matter of VAR, there are very few instructors capable, and we wanted to make that group bigger. In terms of the future, VAR should become even more popular, so it’s possible we will do it again based on the needs. There are several Member Associations who clearly say they are keen to start, plus Confederations, including AFC who said they will use VAR in the Asian Cup in January next year, and UEFA have said they will use it in the next Champions League. So where there is a need to prepare the referees for these competitions, we as FIFA are happy to provide support and help.
Beyond training referees, what are the challenges for VAR?
The Technical Innovation Department at FIFA also give support in terms of the technology. VAR has two different parts: one is the human part, and that is the referees, and one is concerning technology. And of course we are not an expert in that, and so whenever an MA wants to implement something, the Technology Innovation Department can give knowledge and expertise and advise how to deal with the challenges the MA can face Also it’s important to note that VAR is not something that works in the same way for everyone. At the World Cup we had four video match officials in the VOR while most domestic competitions use only two. There are also decentralised and centralised versions. In Russia we had one VOR in Moscow, which is similar to how it is run in Germany and Spain where it is also centralised. On the other hand, in Italy they have a decentralised version with one VOR, one room, in each venue. Also, in Russia we had more than 40 TV cameras. There are some leagues with just 12 or 13, so for the former you need more people to analyse all the angles quickly. With less cameras, you need less people. It’s something that is flexible and adaptable depending on the needs to the competition.
How do you see VAR moving forward in terms of helping referees? Could it be expanded further?
We have just completed an experiment this past March when the IFAB decided to include VAR in in the Laws of the Game so the history is quite short. The first time we discussed about a video technology which could have assisted referees was in November 2014, so less than four years ago. VAR is very very young. Based on the experience we have had and continue to have, we can certainly think about amendments and adjustments in certain details, though I don’t see the big picture changing.
What are you looking for in these instructors?
Every instructor has to be able to communicate something which has to be understood. We are very pleased because the vast majority of the people we had at this seminar were very very good. The quality of the people, who were pre-selected to attend, was high. The challenge for them is that VAR is still a new tool and it is still something that needs to be learned and known about at a deeper level. But at the end of the seminar, the feeling I have is very positive.
Source:
fifa.com
LaLiga host broadcast made an interesting documentary about refereeing, featuring an extended interview with Mateu Lahoz, and following Fernandez Borbalan as he handled his final match last season.
ReplyDeleteLink is below, many thanks to meho7 on reddit for uploading.
https://ok.ru/video/1113605474918
Wow, didn't know anything about that documentary.
DeleteAs a Spaniard, many thanks!
Almost all parts are very nice, thanks!
DeleteHowever, Relaño's comments are really disgusting, but really valuable for the people to see what kind of people provides them with information, so they can realise the rubbish they may read.
Beautiful video.....exciting the last few minutes !!!
ReplyDeleteEgyptian-Saudi SuperCup, today 19:00 CET in Riyadh
ReplyDeleteAl-Hilal Riyadh - Zamalek Cairo
Referee: Felix Brych
Assistant Referees: Mark Borsch / Stefan Lupp
Fourth Official: Robert Schröder
Video Assistant Referee: Pol van Boekel
Very particular appointment, why officials from Germany and VAR from Netherlands?
DeleteMost of the UEFA Elite Category officials officiate in Saudi Arabia last months. As there is also VAR system now, Saudi FF invite foreign officials only for this role, too...
DeleteWell, Van Boekel is an an experienced VAR. Besides, I am sure his German is fine.
DeleteMinute 68' in Tottenham - Cardiff: I really can't understand what Dean saw there. He had a perfect positioning, clear penalty but he indicated that defender had played the ball. No explanations for sure...
ReplyDeleteMost horriffic tackle in many years.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.fotbollskanalen.se/allsvenskan/tv-otack-small-pa-hysen--tff-anfallaren-visades-ut-det-ar-alldeles-illrott/?utm_medium=organic_post&utm_source=facebook.com&linkId=57821318
No translation needed ... The picture says it all :D
ReplyDeletehttps://www.24ur.com/sport/nogomet/tekmo-angleske-premier-league-prekinil-umetni-penis.html
Question for VAR experts: A defender is fouled immediately before a free kick execution, the free kick leads to a goal and the referee allows the goal to stand (missed the foul) - may the VAR intervene or not?
ReplyDeleteTechnically it's a new situation after the set piece execution, but it would make sense to allow an intervention...
Example from today:
https://img1.picload.org/image/dcrrggww/dortmund2.gif
For sure in this scenario VAR can't intervene. An intervention is allowed before the execution of free kick, otherwise a new action starts... but you are right, it should be added in the protocol.
DeleteWas the ball really 'deliberately kicked to the goalkeeper by a team-mate'? Unnecessary call, IMHO.
ReplyDeletehttps://streamable.com/v30bk
Not 100% sure but in my opinion you can whistle it...
DeleteThat's a pretty clear deliberate kick to the keeper.
ReplyDeleteIMO, the defender tried to control the ball and failed. Therefore it wasn't a deliberate action to kick the ball to the goalkeeper.
DeleteHere is an excellent situation to illustrate the importance of the Fourth Official in evaluating crucial situations, which presented itself during Manchester United - Newcastle yesterday in Premier League.
ReplyDeleteUEFA Elite Anthony Taylor led the match, Stuart Attwell was Fourth Official.
https://streamable.com/w8wsg
Referee team made a crucial mistake, and missed a clear handling inside the penalty area.
Many English broadcasters informed their viewers that "referee wasn't even looking at the ball: poor refereeing", of course, we know this not to be the case (in grassroots refereeing yes, but not at this level with FO + comms kit).
Fourth Official should be controlling the wall; here's a good example from UEFA's most recent RAP (https://imgur.com/VhNn3Nq).
Referee SHOULD have covered this in his pre-match talk, maybe he did, we don't know conclusively (why it is impossible to always fairly mark referees just from pictures without a post-match de-brief).
Speaking directly to English referees, it is quite irritating to see how passive Fourth Officials are every week in Premier League (and below sometimes). It is an vital role in the team! Perhaps, it is hard to be fully concentrated, having the day before handled a PL match, as many FOs have in England as the designations are currently done.
As a more general take home message for referees at any level, the pre-match talk (regarding distribution of responsibilities) is really important in order to have a fully cohesive refereeing in the match.
Fully agree with you, Mikael. Wise words.
DeleteWatching the video, I can indeed add that it is for sure poor to see referee looking into the box, and leaving the ball area without any control. This should have been done for sure by Fourth Official (when not AR side). Nowadays it is impossible to have "dead zones" in the field. I strongly encourage referees at every level to discuss everything about this issue in the meeting before the game.
Of course, if you have VAR, everything is solved, but we shouldn't forget that it is possible to cover everything with a smart cooperation. Fourth official's view would have been vital.
I want also to add something about the appointments, indeed the fact that in England we see referees working as FO the day after or before another game (as main referee) is not good. The resulting message seems to be that FO is not a that important role. That's wrong. All officials should feel always involved in every minute of a game. If Premier League referees are not enough to cover all games as both main referee and FO, well, I think that it would be better to see young officials from lower categories, who would be even honored to do that.
After such situations, I can understand why we won`t see ukrainian referees in UCL ...
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CzsAa7BXpJs
No comment... Kryvonosov was among several officials who were expected to get their FIFA badges in January but mysteriously didn't earn that. Reasons are still unknown...
DeleteI was watching this moment at stadium! Awful situation, awful refereeing...
DeleteKryvonosov wasn`t referee at this moment(he was replaced by Kutakov, because of injury(back of the thigh)
Another situation. Look at the referee indicating throw-in... Total lack of alertness...
Deletehttps://twitter.com/FootballHub_Ua/status/1048974007540826113
UEFA is looking for a good Ukranian referee by years, but nothing to do...
DeleteEven same Collina wasn't able to 'create' a real elite referee...
DeleteInteresting situation in Spanish 2nd Division match Deportivo-Málaga. Referee is Isidro Díaz de Mera Escuderos.
ReplyDeleteDeportivo striker attempted an acrobatic shot to goal, but defender cleared just before, so at the end, attacker kicked defender's head instead of ball.
I always thought than kind of situation was YC, but referee surprisingly decided to issue a straight RC for SFP.
I'll try to upload some footage of the action later so you can give your opinion...
According to how you described the situation, it should be YC, but let's wait for a video.
DeleteHere you have, sorry for the delay.
Deletehttps://streamable.com/0ijbg
I can say (as match reports of professional matches are of free access in Spain) what the referee writed down there:
Delete"In minute 77, Deportivo de la Coruña player Enrique González Casín was sent off because of: Kicking the head of an opponent, with use of excessive force (I would underline this), while attempting to play the ball"
defender comes from behind, the attacker has no visual contact with the defender, so YC all day long for me
DeleteZemun - Crvena Zvezda penalty given by Srdjan Jovanovic
ReplyDeleteCant belive that Srdjan and AR2 gave penalty for this, attacker clearly hitting his own feet..
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ArgTtP79i0
UYL
ReplyDeleteAS Roma (ITA) - FC Viktoria Plzeň (CZE)
Referee: Ádám Farkas (HUN)
https://twitter.com/FrSerieAGoals/status/1048574802401939456
All knee ligaments have been torn by that tackle. In addition, there are also meniscus derangements.
It seems as the player was only booked (but it was the second card and he was sent off)...
DeleteI can report a good/expected performance of González González in Valencia-Barcelona.
ReplyDeleteSteve McLean awards a penalty in a Scottish Premiership match - except there was no contact and the player doesn't even claim for it!
ReplyDeletehttps://youtu.be/KZb8cvfklCw?t=54
VAR has been ruled out on grounds of costs in Scotland (apparently at least £2.25m each season, plus more officials) but there's multiple incidents each weekend that shows it's desperately needed...
Benoît Bastien was replaced by Antony Gautier on PSG - Lyon because he is injured
ReplyDeleteDid anyone watch the game? I only saw highlights. It seems as it was a tough game.
Delete9'penalty to Psg, I could not see a close picture but it seems correct
35'RC to Kimpembe (Psg) after VAR, correct decision IMO
45'RC to Tousart (Lyon), the 2nd YC seems harsh
Replays here
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OHMknAvJesw
LaLiga host broadcast made an interesting documentary about refereeing, featuring an extended interview with Mateu Lahoz, and following Fernandez Borbalan as he handled his final match last season.
ReplyDeletelink?Please!