Blog about the man in the middle: appointments, analysis, discussions and much more. You are welcome.
There are also an AVAR2 for every match (source - FIFA app) (delete comment after adding them).
I checked now these names, they are not even domestic (NO FIFA) referees, for sure they are VAR operators and we don't have the need to post them! They are wrongly listed as "Offside VAR".
Indeed, I didn't pay enough attention to the names. Well, at least we probably know the ROs. ;)
REPLAY OPERATORFERREIRA ( POR)OMANA (MEC)CACERES (ARG)KARALIS (GRE)
Who is Ferreira (POR) ?
@Unknown Probably a Replay Operator from Portugal. Full name - Antonio FERREIRA. Will work in the opening match Brazil - Canada.Full names of the 4 individuals considered as ROs:Antonio FERREIRA (POR)Guilhermo OMANA (MEX)Santiago CACERES (ARG)Evangelos KARALIS (GRE)
You might know that none of the names listed as AVAR2 is actually a FIFA referee, so FIFA has made a mistake in posting them, and so should not put them here.
any Saudi appointment for today?
Al-Faiha'a - Al-FatahREF: António Nobre (POR)AR1: Bruno Rodrigues (POR)AR2: Tiago Costa (POR)4OF: Svein Oddvar Moen (NOR)VAR: Damir Skomina (SVN)AVAR: Robert Vukan (SVN)Damak - Ar-Ra'idREF: Bas Nijhuis (NED)AR1: Erik Kleinjan (NED)AR2: Dave Goossens (NED)4OF: Sultan Al-Harbi (KSA)VAR: Marc Nagtegaal (NED)AVAR: Ra'id Az-Zahrani (KSA)
Some facts about refereeing at the tournament (comparing 2017 with 2019):=> Number of involved match officials have increased from 70 to 82 (decreased to 65 if not counting video match officials).=> Number of referee + assistant referees trios have decreased from 21 to 20. => In 2017 there were 7 support referees. Only one of them (Esther Staubli from Switzerland) had to act as an on-field match official in a match (Japan VS New Caledonia, Group Stage; because Sandro Ricci for some reason didn't referee a single match although he was listed as a referee). This time there are 5 support referees.=> In the previous edition there were 5 trios consisting of different nationalities; this year - 7.=> Represented countries have increased from 36 to 45 (decreased to 32 if not counting video match officials).
The first two matches will be played at 21:00 CET, 26 October; the next two - at 00:00 CET, 27 October. You probably meant CEST but please make it clearer. (Delete this comment when corrected.)
Not 100% on topic but I would like to highlight the very low ticket prices: the most expensive ticket you can get is for 9 EUR. The cheapest was 1,12 EUR.
OT: Kassai will have a game in Hungary after his injury. His last game was 14/09. He will handle Paks-DVTK on Saturday with NON-FIFA referee assistants.
I need clarification because something strange just happened. First of all VAR gave a red card in Leicester vs Southampton . Yes you read it right. But the red card was a foul that was an advantage quite the first time I am seeing such.
if the red card offense is for dogso and the goal is scored then you give a yc for unsporting behaviour. if the red card offense is for violent contact or serious foul play and you allow advantage and the goal is scored the red card still stands. Correct me if I am wrong
Chris you are correct but in the real world if the referee had spotted the SFP he would have called the foul and not given an advantage here. But yes the red still stands if the red isn't a DOGSO.
OT: PK in 2. Bundesliga, Bochum striker shots goes wide but a Holstein Kiel substitute who was warming-up next to the goal line stopped the ball just before it went out. After VAR review, penalty awarded by referee Timo Gerach. Correct application of LOTG. Don't have a video, sorry.
Very rare situation I must say, but based on your description, correct decission.
Try with this one.https://twitter.com/mezvanvid/status/1187804632833245185
I watched Nantes-Monaco handled by Thomas Léonard and have become his fan immediately. His body language and mimics are absolutely on the top elite level!Question for our French readers: why the FFF didn't nominate him for FIFA referee? Ridiculous taking into account his skills!
He only has 2 seasons in Ligue 1 but for sure a good referee, better than Abed IMO...
Agree with both of you. His body language is excellent among other qualities.
Video of RC Bertrand in Southampton - Leicester Cityhttps://streamable.com/rdkdc
In PL the images of the VAR situations are shown on the big screens ???
Premier league finally doing something right with VAR but still not the way it should be. Referee gave the red card for SFP on the advice of the VAR without going to the Referee review area and doing an on field review.
Correct call but it would be much better if Marriner did OFR.
OT: Spanish crew led by Xavier Estrada Fernández will handle the big Riyadh derby in Saudi league on Sunday.
Roberto Tobar (Chile) conformed for Club World Cup in December.
Watching Felix Brych in the Schalke v Dortmund derby. Solid first half from him. A couple of tough offside calls for AR1.
During the 2nd half he missed an penalty kick against Dortmund because handball. The VAR also missed an intervention.
DFB confirmed the decision that was originally taken by Brych. No punishable handball.https://www.dfb.de/news/detail/sportliche-leitung-elite-schiedsrichter-ordnet-handspielszenen-ein-209395/
"Dortmund player Hazard is not oriented to defend the ball. As the ball approaches, he tries to take his arm out of the "danger area". It is therefore clearly not a deliberate action with the hands to the ball. Likewise, there is no unnatural enlargement of the body surface to fend off the ball. The decision to continue playing is correct and supported. The video assistant rightly does not intervene, since the referee had perceived the process itself and evaluated in the manner described."https://media.giphy.com/media/J1e8vRiBHh6wIIjXUK/giphy.gifhttps://media.giphy.com/media/UsLwHGiywEVgYfDPA0/giphy.gifhttps://media.giphy.com/media/iIMxmrfczM8OtybFdR/giphy.gif
Today's games in Saudi Pro LeagueAl Taawon - Al FaisalyREF: Ivan Kružliak (SVK)AR1: Tomáš Somoláni (SVK)AR2: Branislav Hancko (SVK)4th: Majed Al Shamrani (KSA)VAR: Marc Nagtegaal (NED)AVAR: Erik Kleinjan (NED)Al Hazm - Al AhliREF: Ivan Bebek (CRO)AR1: Goran Pataki (CRO)AR2: Bojan Zobenica (CRO)4th: Faisal Sulaiman Al-Balawi (KSA)VAR: Baj Nijhuis (NED)AVAR: Dave Goossens (NED)
Ref. Saudi Today ?
If I'm not wrong, it was reported that Spanish Estrada Fernández had one of the two games, I don't remember which one.
VAR in the Premier League have given a penalty for the first time in Brighton Everton game, took them to the 10th gameweek for this to happen but with the red card overturned yesterday is the high bar being relaxed a bit now, however there was still no OFR
With OFR or without, it's good to see the VAR finally works in the Premier League.
Yea today again....var overturned Michel Oliver penalty in Chelsea vs Burnley game....I think var has really done a good job this matchweek..
I think it is a penalty but most certainly it is one that I would want the referee to make the final decision on with an on field review. It took so long to give I almost think it would have been quicker for the referee to go to the monitor.https://streamable.com/tbeybA rare mistake from Michael Oliver. He's usually spot on with his penalty decisions. But this is why we have VAR, to help in situations like this when the player is guilty of simulation. Again, no OFR.https://streamable.com/0vthn
Solomon Islands - ItalyMonday 28 October 2019 - 21:00Referee: Redouane Jiyed (MAR)Assistant Referee 1: Lahcen Azgaou (MAR)Assistant Referee 2: Mustapha Akarkad (MAR)Fourth Official:Peter Waweru (KEN)Video Assistant Referee: Abdullah Ali Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Yaqoub AL HAMMADI (UAE)
Spain - Argentina BEATH Christopher (Australia)Paraguay - MexicoKABAKOV Georgi ( Bulgaria )Tajikistan - CameroonWALDRON Nick ( New Zealand )
Reckless-SFP incident from the NGAHUN game.https://streamable.com/0r4w9
Very dangerous tackle but the hitting point (exactly on the foot) justifies NO VAR intervention. For the used force, however, red wouldn'd have been wrong.
Rejected penalty appeal after an on-field review in the NZLANG gamehttps://streamable.com/1adoe
Ma Ning what are you doing!?? That's a clear penalty.
Interesting situation, thanks for the video.We know that it is rare (at least at UEFA level) to see an OFR for a pushing, because, differently from low contacts, here the intensity and the effects are all at referee's discretion.But in this case the pushing is very clear and I would say a clear foul, so I think correct by Craig Pawson to invite referee to monitor. I'm also sure he didn't see it live.About the final call, to play on, I can just underline that Ma Ning was not so sure, he took a very long time in front a quite clear situation, and I noticed that he still wanted to watch monitor when he had left it for the first time. For what I saw also here in Italy and my experience, this should mean that referee has not still 100% clear ideas for some reasons.Also, to add, very long time before inviting referee to rewatch and I think this was because VAR had to be sure ball was in play when foul materialized.
For me that was a penalty.
In my opinion, Ma Ning was aware that the New Zealand player's only goal was to unfairly disturb the Angolan goalkeeper. The referee even whistled a foul in attack, exactly for impeding the progress of the goalkeeper. To be honest, I fully understand his view - awarding a penalty in this incident would mean a praise of an unfair attitude.
Exactly my point
Sorry, but no. That's not applying the Laws of the Game. NZL player does nothing that is forbidden at the moment he is pushed. However, the goalkeeper does. Instead of trying to run for the ball and being blocked with contact (direct free kick), he decides to push him instead (direct free kick inside the penalty area, so penalty kick). He just made a poor decision and should have had to suffer the consequences of that.However, I have to say that I'm not happy with VAR/operator performance either. The replay was not shown in live speed and was also very slow to play, almost frame by frame, which doesn't help the referee on the pitch.
I guess the slow-mo replay was shown because Craig Pawson wanted to show Ma Ning that the push has occurred when the ball was in play.
Exactly my point...Really tough mistake by ma Ming...I think in a FIFA tournament like this...it might be the end of the tournament for me...To my point of view Craig Lawson has already told him it's a penalty when ma Ming was reviewing the decision but...Lawson still go on and show the incident in slow motion...
In my opinion both do a bad job, referee and VAR. First of all, it took far too long to invite the referee to an OFR. Yes, it had to be sure whether the ball has already been in play. However, I don't think you should need almost 2' for that. When OFR occurs, VAR at first shows the referee that the ball has already been - for his opinion - in play. After that, VAR chose an adequate angle for the referee in order to assess the push by the goalkeeper. As most of the time a freeze was shown, the referee was not ready to take a final decision. It would have been necessary to show the referee the incident in real speed from the chosen angle as a continuous loop. As this was not the case and the whole procedure has already taken very long, the referee decided to leave the OFR-area and continued with goal kick.
Clear penalty. The attacker was not doing anything against the laws of the game by just standing there at that moment. This is a blatant push. The GK has zero right to push him like that. Trying to get space okay, but pushing him blatantly is a foul.
Was the ball actually in play at the moment of the foul? For pushing it's the very first frame or contact that counts. To sell to the audience maybe VAR opted for OFR to show that it's a foul but ball was not in play. That would explain why they went frame by frame.
@Jack_Johnsson before calling referee to OFR, VAR must check that ball is in play, this process must be done before inviting referee. You can't make an OFR for understanding that ball is not in play, not even to show that to people and fans, they wont understand something like that, this is only technical stuff.
Of course you can do it, it's an explicit recommendation in the FIFA VAR protocols, or at least an opportunity. As VAR you have the freedom to either do nothing or, in order to be transparent, opt for OFR to sell 'we saw the offence, but this is why it can't be a penalty'. Just an idea. Ok we can discuss OFR but it cannot be a foul. Ball was not in play.
Not convincing performance by Daniele Doveri in Bologna 2-1 Sampdoria.In the first half too lenient,CLEAR fouls missed,too passive,no motivation like sprinting to fouls etc. and an inconsistent foul management.All 4 YCs correct but in the second half and for equal fouls in the first half no cards even not for clear tactical fouls!Correct onside before Bolgona goals.Key match incident around 50' minute.Sampdoria goal was cancelled by VAR due to an offside position.Corner for Sampdoria and goalkeeper was blocked by his own player.No replays shown but IMO there was no offside position (Doveri gave indirect free kick).Very confusing!!
About 50', it is an excellent call by AR2.No matter whether Gabbiadini touches ball or not before the goal scored, he impedes the intervention to at least one of the two defenders behind him. You can clearly understand that without him there, at least a player would have tried a save (and very likely, with success). VAR confirmed. Video (sorry, poor quality, recorded live):https://streamable.com/9aq5t
This was called as onside prior to Inters goal.https://www.maxbetsport.rs/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Inter.png
Foot of Parma's second-last defender kept ONSIDE attacker.Better picture to understand:https://i.postimg.cc/yNgq03gk/234.jpg
Sorry to say this but Jared Gillett (VAR) has just made game changing call to rule out goal for arsenal for a phantom foul, no OFR taken. Unbelievable call to make at 2-2. Does no favors for VAR project in premier league. http://arsenalist.com/f/2018-19/var-disallows-sokratis-goal-for-this-chambers-foul-2019-10-27.html
It is still shocking for me to see a referee listening to VAR and then changing his decision about a so important call without taking a look. I'm speechless and I think Premier League should stop VAR if they go on in this ridiculous way.How can you be sure that Atkinson will agree on that call?
I think it's good like this...Trust me Europe will start using this logic...Using ofr takes a lot of time...
VAR was born as "help" for referees, if you use it in this way, it is something like a "second refereeing". You miss the point that the only official allowed to take decisions is the main referee appointed for the game. This is a vital criterion, otherwise let's start to officiate from rooms withoutr any official on the pitch.
In Norwich-Man UTD prior 1st penalty for UTD referee made the decision to play on, but VAR ref tokk the decision that it is penalty. Incredible that VAR ref decide whether it is penalty or not. English VAR is a stupid joke. What's the point to have ref on the pitch if any crucial decision can take ref sitting in the room. And for me, that wasn't penalty for United. Is there OFR in England at all? I watched lot of matches but never seen that - every time the decision was written on the screen, which is incredibly stupid. About Arsenal match, I think it was foul on Milivojevic. However, Atkinson had to review it make final decision.
@Nole about OFR: "If the advice falls within the referee’s range of expectation, they can make their final decision based on that information without use of the RRA.Where the information received from the VAR falls outside of the referee’s expectation range or where there is a serious missed incident, they should use the RRA to assist with the final decision."https://www.premierleague.com/news/1297393
Thanks, Dominic. Probably there were some OFRs so far, but in all games I watched (and I watched lot of games this year in PL), I've never seen an OFR.
I am pretty sure that there has not been an OFR in PL yet! It is a shame how VAR is used in England...
Am I the only one who sees this as a clear fou??? I think you have to realise Jarred Gillett, the VAR in this game, is one of the most experienced VAR's in the world, certainly the most experienced with VAR in England. He's been using it since Australia became the first country in the world to use it in their domestic top flight league.
There is a clear hooking action by the attackers leg. I think it's a foul.https://streamable.com/twz9zLooks very similar to me as the Vertonghen one that wasn't given but a lot of people thought should have been given. https://streamable.com/6nvi3Except that this latest one is the attacker instead of defender. The issue for me is again it should have been an OFR. The referee needs to make the final decision. Referee's body language is pretty bad when he realises he has to have another VAR intervention.Because earlier in the match the Australian VAR Jarred Gillett intervened when Atkinson gave a yellow card for what he thought was a dive. Correct intervention to instead give a penalty. But again no OFR.https://streamable.com/m1dx0However it must be extremely difficult to continue in the game feeling so undermined because the players would ask how he can go from thinking its a dive to a penalty without so much as a look at the incident himself.
The question is, who is responsible for the contact between the legs. The defender is also moving his feet, therefore one could also blame him for the hooking. So, IMO an unclear situation, which can be decided in both ways, i.e, rather no VAR stuff.I agree regarding Atkinson's body language - he doesn't seem convinced - and that OFRs would help in both occasions.
Yes the real problem is regarding OFR, and I am very curious as to why Gillett who has so much experience regarding VAR is so comfortable to simply overturn Atkinson's decision as VAR. I am sure if he was still in the A-League as VAR or as main referee he would never ever overturn the call without OFR. I suspect it is a problem with PGMOL, in first 9 matchdays (90 games) 0 red cards or penalty was given out, now this weekend 4 penalties 1 red card given out. This is still with ZERO OFR conducted. Referee's need clarity about what the bar for VAR usage is, otherwise is very difficult to make decisions under pressure. Even experienced VAR like Gillett is confused, let alone many of the PL refs who are just getting used to VAR system.
Yeah, I don't think he has a choice. Probably just doing what he's told.
Phantom penalty called by VAR for Man UTD..https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCrSQiIKMu4
I wrote about it above. Just incredible for me. More incredible is to give such a penalty in England. Real joke. In England most of main refs are poor, but those in VAR rooms - they are disastrous for me.
OT: Busy weekend in the Premier League. We went from pretty much no VAR intervention to 7 this weekend.None of these VAR interventions had an OFR.I repeat NO ON FIELD REVIEWS.Southampton v Leicester City -https://streamable.com/rdkdcBrighton v Everton -https://streamable.com/tbeybBurnley v Chelsea -https://streamable.com/0vthnArsenal v Crystal Palace -https://streamable.com/m1dx0https://streamable.com/twz9zNorwich v Manchester United -https://streamable.com/py1b5https://streamable.com/4mxoe
Southampton v Leicester City - Correct RC decisionBrighton v Everton - Correct Penalty, Brighton attacker was clearly stampedBurnley v Chelsea - For me this was a penalty. Hudson-Odoi was pushed from behind, OFR should have been mandatory in this case.Arsenal v Crystal Palace -- First penalty can be a supportable decision, but the 2nd decision is a very poor VAR intervention, in any other area of the field this would have not been a foul.Norwich v Manchester United -No doubts for the 2nd penalty, but the first one honestly is a joke, if anything that was more an offensive foul.
Nigeria -Ecuador =ESCOBAR Mario (Guatemala)Angola - Canada = UMPIERREZ Claudia ( Uruguay)Brazil - New Zealand = AL MARRI Khamis ( Qatar )Australia - Hungary = MOHAMED AMIN MOHAMED OMAR Amin ( Egypt)
Angola - CanadaReferee: Claudia Umpierrez (URU)Assistant Referee 1: Luciana Mascaraña (URU)Assistant Referee 2: Monica Amboya (ECU)Fourth Official: Diego Mirko Haro Sueldo (PER)umVideo Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Piero Daniel Maza Gómez (CHI)
Ribery pushed AR Passeri after Fiorentina - Lazio because he was very angry for some decisions. Let's see how many games of ban he will get. https://twitter.com/Val61/status/1188574630941822977
What do you think about this scene? Foul or not?https://streamable.com/p4dlsVAR didn't intervene since the referee blew the whistle and ended the match.
Watching carefully, it's a handball, so it should have been a RC.
I agree with Quilava, freekick and RC-DOGSO to be given.How did Sousa perform in that match?
In general it was a good performance on a normal difficulty match. The first caution was shown at min. 2' for a SPA offence. He was a little more lenient than he should be but no major problems.There is a disallowed goal due to an attacker's handball (there was an OFR, I will try to upload a video).
RC and free kick would be my decision as well.
Here is the disallowed goalhttps://streamable.com/lmr3d
And this scene? YC or RC?https://streamable.com/moceb
Could be a RC, yep.
RC for VC, what the green player did wasn't clear based on the one view we got. Also, if YC is given, there should be a SYC for the VAR gesture.
Nigeria -EcuadorReferee: Khamis Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Referee 1: Mohammad Dharman (QAT)Assistant Referee 2: Ramzan Al-Naemi (QAT)Fourth Official: Juan Gabriel Calderon (CRC)Video Assistant Referee: Abdulla Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Yaquob Al-Hammadi (UAE)Angola - CanadaReferee: Claudia Umpierrez (URU)Assistant Referee 1: Luciana Mascaraña (URU)Assistant Referee 2: Monica Amboya (ECU)Fourth Official: Diego Mirko Haro Sueldo (PER)umVideo Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Piero Daniel Maza Gómez (CHI)Brazil - New ZealandReferee: Mario Escobar (GUA)Assistant Referee 1: Humberto Panjoj (GUA)Assistant Referee 2: Nicholas Andersson (JAM)Fourth Official: Peter Waweru (KEN)Video Assistant Referee: Armando Villarreal (USA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Quetzalli Alvarado (MEX)Australia - HungaryReferee: Amin Mohamed (EGY)Assistant Referee 1: Attia Amsaaed (LBY)Assistant Referee 2: Mohammed Ibrahim (SDN)Fourth Official: Edina Alves Batista (BRA)Video Assistant Referee: Marco Di Bello (ITA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Hiroyuki Kimura (JPN)
LIGUE 1 CONFORAMA - MATCHDAY 12Friday (01.11)Dijon - Paris, 20:45 CET, referee: Ruddy Buquet, UEFA Cat. 1 (VAR: Mikael Lesage)Saturday (02.11)Marseille - Lille, 17:30 CET, referee: Hakim Ben El Hadj (VAR: Benoît Bastien, UEFa Elite Cat.)Nîmes - Rennes, 20:00 CET, referee: Willy Delajod (VAR: Mikael Lesage)Metz - Montpellier, 20:00 CET, referee: Stéphanie Frappart, UEFA Elite Women Cat. (VAR: Jérémie Pignard)Toulouse - Lyon, 20:00 CET, referee: Karim Abed, UEFA Cat. 2 (VAR: Jérôme Miguelgorry)Angers - Strasbourg, 20:00 CET, referee: Florent Batta (VAR: Antony Gautier)Amiens - Brest, 20:00 CET, referee: Frank Schneider, UEFA Cat. 2 (VAR: Wilfried Bien)Sunday (03.11)Bordeaux - Nantes, 15:00 CET, referee: François Letexier, UEFA Cat. 1 (VAR: Eric Wattellier)Nice - Reims, 17:00 CET, referee: Jérémy Stinat (VAR: Clément Turpin, UEFA Elite Cat.)Saint-Etienne - Monaco, 21:00 CET, referee: Jérôme Brisard, UEFA Cat. 2 (VAR: Benoît Bastien, UEFA Elite Cat.)
EFL CARABAO CUP - ROUND FOURTuesday (29.10)Burton - Leicester, 20:45 CET, referee: Darren EnglandCrawley - Colchester, 20:45 CET, referee: Tony HarringtonEverton - Watford, 20:45 CET, referee: Simon HooperManCity - Southampton, 20:45 CET, referee: Jon MossOxford - Sunderland, 20:45 CET, referee: Jeremy SimpsonWednesday (30.10)Liverpool - Arsenal, 20:30 CET, referee: Andre MarrinerAston Villa - Wolverhampton, 20:45 CET, referee: Lee MasonChelsea - ManUnited, 21:05 CET, referee: Paul Tierney, UEFA Cat. 2
Southampton is lucky) In 5 days, twice a game against Manchester City)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
PREMIER LEAGUE - MATCHDAY 11Saturday (02.11)Bournemouth - ManUnited, 13:30 CET, referee: Chris Kavanagh, UEFA Cat. 2 (VAR: Mike Dean)Arsenal - Wolverhampton, 16:00 CET, referee: Michael Oliver, UEFA Elite Cat. (VaR: Paul Tierney, UEFA Cat. 2)Aston Villa - Liverpool, 16:00 CET, referee: Jon Moss (VAR: Martin Atkinson)Brighton - Norwich, 16:00 CET, referee: Kevin Friend (VAR: Tim Robinson)ManCity - Southampton, 16:00 CET, referee: Lee Mason (VAR: Andre Marriner)Southampton - Burnley, 16:00 CET, referee: Simon Hooper (VAR: Graham Scott)West Ham - Newcastle, 16:00 CET, referee: Stuart Attwell, UEFA Cat. 2 (VAR: Jarred Gillett)Watford - Chelsea, 18:30 CET, referee: Anthony Taylor, UEFA Elite Cat. (VAR: Mike Dean)Sunday (03.11)Everton - Tottenham, 17:30 CET, referee: Martin Atkinson (VAR: Anthony Taylor, UEFA Elite Cat.)
ManCity - Southampton...Southampton - Burnley...Sheffield United - Burnley. Not Southampton)
OTMatchweek 10 of the Premier League featured 7 VAR reviews (all of them VAR-only; 1 - RC shown, 1 - goal canceled due to foul, 1 - penalty canceled, 4 - penalty awarded). Until this matchweek the biggest number of reviews in one MW was only 4. This matchweek featured the first ever RC VAR review in the PL and also the first ever penalty VAR review in the league. The average number of reviews per match has risen from 0,21 (1 review every 4,74 matches) before this MW to 0,26 (1 review every 3,85 matches) now.Go to the following link to watch a full video of every review, get all information about each of them and get statistics about VAR in the league. https://thefref.weebly.com/var-at-premier-league.html
Norway (Lillestrøm-Vålerenga):The match security delegate enters the field and orders the referee to stop the game. Is this correct procedure? https://twitter.com/Trogold/status/1188777770530283520
Off topic - appointments for following weekend from AUSTRIABy the way: The decision was made to introduce VAR up from the play-off-period in march 2021. Theory- and training-phase will start in early 2020.Samstag, 02.11.2019Tipico Bundesliga - Grunddurchgang (TBL-GD)17:00 SK Puntigamer Sturm Graz - RZ Pellets WAC Schörgenhofer Robert , Gutschi Markus , Beganovic Anel, Untergasser; Steindl Christian Merkur Arena 17:00 SK Rapid - spusu SKN St. Pölten Schüttengruber M., Brandner, Steinacher Robert, Muckenhammer; DI Liebert Allianz Stadion 17:00 SV Mattersburg - FC Red Bull Salzburg Ciochirca Petru, Höfler Martin, Bauernfeind Gerald , Lechner H.; Gerstenmayer PappelstadionSonntag, 03.11.201914:30 FC Flyeralarm Admira - TSV Prolactal Hartberg Ouschan Felix , Schreiner Santino , Gruber S. , Spurny; Steiner Thomas BSFZ-Arena17:00 LASK - FK Austria WienEiser Rene, Dr. Witschnigg A., Trampusch D., Hameter Markus; Schwab N. Raiffeisen Arena, Pasching
Offtopic:The Dutch FA (KNVB) has started a investigation into the commercial activities of Danny Makkelie. He is running a webshop with referee articles as clothing, headsets flags etc. He is selling nike clothing (official sponsor of the KNVB) but also from other brands like Erima and Macron. The nike clothing being sold is the version without the sponsorname of ARAG. Arag is the sponsor of refereeing in The Netherlands. Question is if this is allowed under the current contract Makkelie and other referees have with the KNVB. Or are they restricted to only commercial activities with the official partners as Nike and ARAG.
I found him on Instagram. He has an open account. It looks really nice what he shows there. Great to see him developing referee equipment. Keep up the good work Makkelie! He is an example for many young referees like me.
A disallowed goal due to offside.Is the player interfering with play?https://streamable.com/lnjj9
Yes. In a split second he is even in the GKs line of vision. Impacted the GKs ability to play the ball.
In J.league, this is not offside.The commentator is an English speaker.https://youtu.be/zU-9MwmzCmU
Interesting. Basically the exact same situation and reaction by the GK. Usually if a GK reacts like that it means he actually did not see the ball. And we can tell for sure he didn't in this case. But it's always up to the referees.
Netherlands - SenegalReferee: Andres Rojas (COL)Assistant Referee 1: Dionisio Ruiz (COL)Assistant Referee 2: John Alexander Leon (COL)Fourth Official: Ko Hyung-jin (KOR)Video Assistant Referee: Nicolas Gallo (COL)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: German Delfino (ARG)Korea Republic - FranceReferee: Adonais Escobedo (MEX)Assistant Referee 1: William Arrieta (CRC)Assistant Referee 2: Michael Barwegen (CAN)Fourth Official: Edina Batista (BRA)umVideo Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Braulio Machado (BRA)United States - JapanReferee: Guillermo Guerrero (ECU)Assistant Referee 1: Juan Carlos Macias (ECU)Assistant Referee 2: Ricardo Baren (ECU)Fourth Official: Ivo Mendez (BOL)Video Assistant Referee: Drew Fischer (CAN)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Craig Pawson (ENG)Chile - HaitiReferee: Andris Treimanis (LVA)Assistant Referee 1: Haralds Gudermanis (LVA)Assistant Referee 2: Aleksejs Spasjonnikovs (LVA)Fourth Official: Juan Gabriel Calderon (CRC)Video Assistant Referee: Bibiana Steinhaus (GER)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Bartosz Frankowski (POL)
Interesting to see how collina has change Craig pawson from Var to avar 👀
Spain - TajikistanReferee: Iván Arcides Bartón Cisneros (SLV)Assistant Referee 1: David Jonathan Morán Santos (SLV)Assistant Referee 2: Zachari Jair Zeegelaar (SUR)Fourth Official: Ivo Nigel Méndez Chávez (BOL)Video Assistant Referee: Nicolás Gallo Barragán (COL)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Piero Daniel Maza Gómez (CHI)Solomon Islands - ParaguayReferee: Victor Miguel de Freitas Gomes (RSA)Assistant Referee 1: Souru Phats'oane (LES)Assistant Referee 2: Lionel Hasinjarasoa Andrianantenaina (MAD)Fourth Official: Peter Waweru Kamaku (KEN)Video Assistant Referee: Dennis Higler (NED)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Armando Villarreal (USA)Mexico - ItalyReferee: Diego Mirko Haro Sueldo (PER)Assistant Referee 1: Víctor Armando Ráez Izaguirre (PER)Assistant Referee 2: Michael Luis Orué Medina (PER)Fourth Official: Claudia Umpierrez (URU)Video Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Bráulio da Silva Machado (BRA)Cameroon - ArgentinaReferee: Srđan Jovanović (SRB)Assistant Referee 1: Uroš Stojković (SRB)Assistant Referee 2: Milan Mihajlović (SRB)Fourth Official: Ko Hyung-jin (KOR)Video Assistant Referee: Drew Fischer (CAN)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Craig Pawson (ENG)
Cüneyt Çakir was appointed to an interesting match in Turkish Süper Lig on Saturday.Süper Lig Cemil Usta Season 2019/2020 (Profesyonel Takim)Matchday 10Match Code:1084Saturday,02 November 2019 18:00 Central European Time (20:00 Local Time;Eastern European Time)Antalya StadyumuAntalya,Republic of TurkeyAntalya Kulübü (14.) - Beşiktaş Jimnastik Kulübü (8.)Referee: Cüneyt Çakir (FIFA Referee,UEFA Elite Referee)Assistant Referee 1: Bahattin Duran (FIFA Assistant Referee)Assistant Referee 2: Mustafa Emre Eyisoy (FIFA Assistant Referee)Fourth Offical: Caner Ak (TFF Referee)Video Asssitant Referee: Özgüç Türkalp (TFF Referee)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Tarik Ongun (FIFA Assistant Referee)Referee Observer: Necdet Erdilek Delegate: Berk ÖzbekDelegate: Aydin BalkanliDelegate: Alper Sami Çayar
Ümit Öztürk (36) removed from the FIFA list by TFF. instead of Ümit, Arda Kardesler (31) Added.
Thanks for that info.Why is Ümit Öztürk removed?Can Arda Kardesler be considered a talent?
Slavko Vincic from Slovenia (UEFA, 1st) has been appointed to the PAOK - Panathinaikos match on Sunday. His assistants will be Tomaz Klacnik and Andraz Kovacic. FO will be Koutsiaftis and VAR Tzilos (UEFA, 3rd).
Orsato management skills in Roma - Milanhttps://streamable.com/z4jia
Is hand around the neck in a choking motion not considered violent conduct in Italy??
Some video clips from the big Al Hilal - An Nasr game handled by Xavier Estrada Fernández (VAR: Alfonso Álvarez Izquierdo) on Sunday.=> 9' Penalty appeal (tripping) - IMO, missed penalty by referee and VARhttps://streamable.com/7i52j=> 70' Penalty appeal (charging), goalkeeperhttps://streamable.com/4z9db=> 90' Tackle assessed as reckless and YC given - IMO it is Serious Foul Play and RC to be issuedhttps://streamable.com/6i3t6In general Xavier Estrada Fernández showed a 8,2/3 level performance.Strengths: Foul detection (besides 67', 85' - many, many duels to assess as normal in KSA), control, correctly gauged distance from players, disciplinary controlAreas for development: Management of dissent, additional time, sometimes chaotic player management, losing the overview a bit at the end, [two crucial mistakes IMO]
Minute 90: 100% SFP. 100% Red Card to be issued.Can never be 8,2/3 mark
We agree Jaak.I just wanted to give the readers a 'flavour' of the general performance, indeed, I would evaluate that tackle as SFP too (high force, such contacts on the knee are very dangerous).
My opinion on 9' is that the attacker moves his leg to the left initiating contact. So for me no penalty and good no VAR intervention.90'The serious foul play wouldn't have happened if the referee did the right thing initially and booked the player who dived in the box before the breakaway. Definite simulation for me.
Controversial decision in Napoli - Atalanta game by referee Piero Giacomelli.He gave no penalty for Napoli after a pushing by Atalanta player, no VAR intervention and two RCs for a staff member and head coach Carlo Ancelotti (90+9').Napoli players did not want to continue playing.
Soft penalty in Chelsea - Manchester United (Carabao Cup) by referee Paul Tierny.Contact is there so at least a supportable call.I'm pretty sure VAR would not have intervened if there would be VAR system...
IMO catastrophic RC in Serie A match Udinese - AS Roma by referee Massimiliano Irrati. Red Card for avoiding a clear chance for a Udinese player but in my eyes clear ball-oriented body contact and never a red card.Also here no VAR intervention,althought it was a clear and obviously mistake by Irrati!
Surprise to hear that cause Irrati is one of the most reliable and trusted referees.
I was in the Dacia Arena this evening and it wasn‘t a convincing performance of Irrati in my eyes. The RC seemed wrong and was not accapted by players and staff of AS Roma. Irrati then lost the control of the game and was fortunate that it became a clear win for Roma.Did someone see the handball penalty that led to the 4:0? It seemed very very soft from the stands...
And controversial ending to Juventus-Genoa match handle by Giua.Penalty given to Juve in 90+ minute and Penalty not given to Genoa in their last attack.Game was very hot, 8 YC's and 3 RC's so it was challenging match for Giua.
Hungary - EcuadorReferee: Ma Ning (CHN)Assistant Referee 1: Shi Xiang (CHN)Assistant Referee 2: Cao Yi (CHN)Fourth Official: Edina Alves Batista (BRA)Video Assistant Referee: Abdullah Ali Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Yaqub Yusif Qasim Hassan Al-Hammadi (UAE)Australia - NigeriaReferee: István Kovács (ROU)Assistant Referee 1: Vasile Florin Marinescu (ROU)Assistant Referee 2: Mihai Ovidiu Artene (ROU)Fourth Official: Adonais Escobedo (MEX)Video Assistant Referee: Marco Di Bello (ITA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Hiroyuki Kimura (JPN)Angola - BrazilReferee: Andreas Ekberg (SWE)Assistant Referee 1: Mehmet Culum (SWE)Assistant Referee 2: Stefan Hallberg (SWE)Fourth Official: Juan Gabriel Calderón Pérez (CRC)Video Assistant Referee: Bibiana Steinhaus (GER)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Bartosz Frankowski (POL)Canada - New ZealandReferee: Mario Alberto Díaz de Vivar Bogado (PAR)Assistant Referee 1: Milcíades Saldívar Franco (PAR)Assistant Referee 2: Roberto Casiano Cañete Luraghi (PAR)Fourth Official: Peter Waweru (KEN)Video Assistant Referee: Armando Villarreal (USA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Germán Raúl Delfino (ARG)
OT: A League appointmentsHyundai A-League Match day 4Sydney FC v Newcastle JetsFriday, 1 November 2019Leichhardt Oval, LilyfieldKick-Off: 7:30pm (Local) (7:30pm (AEDT))Referee: Shaun Evans (FIFA)Assistant Referee 1: Owen Goldrick (FIFA)Assistant Referee 2: Lance Greenshields (FIFA)Fourth Official: Ben AbrahamVAR: Kris Griffiths-JonesWestern Sydney Wanderers FC v Brisbane Roar FCSaturday, 2 November 2019Bankwest Stadium, ParramattaKick-Off: 5:00pm (Local) (5:00pm (AEDT))Referee: Daniel ElderAssistant Referee 1: Andrej GievAssistant Referee 2: Greg TaylorFourth Official: Tim DanaskosVAR: Kate Jacewicz (FIFA) (VAR debut)Melbourne Victory v Western United FCSaturday, 2 November 2019Marvel Stadium, DocklandsKick-Off: 7:30pm (Local) (7:30pm (AEDT))Referee: Alireza Faghani (FIFA)Assistant Referee 1: David WalshAssistant Referee 2: George Lakrindis (FIFA)Fourth Official: Lachlan KeeversVAR: Craig ZetterMelbourne City FC v Wellington PhoenixSunday, 3 November 2019AAMI Park, MelbourneKick-Off: 4:00pm (Local) (4:00pm (AEDT))Referee: Ben Abraham (centre referee debut)Assistant Referee 1: Wilson BrownAssistant Referee 2: Andrew MeimarakisFourth Official: Adam BavcarVAR: Craig ZetterPerth Glory v Central Coast MarinersSunday, 3 November 2019HBF Park, PerthKick-Off: 3:00pm (Local) (6:00pm (AEDT))Referee: Kurt Ams (FIFA)Assistant Referee 1: Josh MannellaAssistant Referee 2: Matthew SouthernFourth Official: Shane SkinnerVAR: Kris Griffiths-JonesThe big news for this weeks appointments is that FIFA womens world cup referee Kate Jacewicz will act as VAR and is one step closer to refereeing an A-League game. This comes after it was announced earlier that she would be the first female referee (not AR) to be appointed to the A-League referees panel.https://www.a-league.com.au/news/kate-jacewicz-and-ben-abraham-appointed-hyundai-a-league-referee-panel-first-timeThe other news is that Ben Abraham, who was also appointed to the referees panel for this season, will make his debut.
Situation from FC København - FC Nordsjælland.Referee: Mads-Kristoffer Kristoffersenhttps://streamable.com/1pw3jThe tackle in itself seems to me like a red card. But I wonder, if Denmark had VAR, might the first part of the situation be deemed a free kick (and the red card therefore not recommended). The referee here didn't whistle anything at all in the situation.
No, VAR can't check or review 'classic' fouls therefore the first potential foul would be ignored, and VAR would start with checking the RC incident and then recommend an OFR (if they wouldn't use VAR in the way Premier League does it - then it would be a VAR-only review ;)).
Gözübüyük, Soares Dias and Bebek handled the games today.
Any referee predictions for the upcoming UCL round?
Mine are (VAR in brackets):Napoli-Salzburg: Gil Manzano (Hernandez/Sobrino)Liverpool-Genk: Stieler (Dingert/Welz)Dortmund-Inter: Kuipers (van Boekel/van Zuilen)Barcelona-Slavia: Bastien (Millot/Delerue)Zenit-Leipzig: Marciniak (Turpin/Brisard)Lyon-Benfica: Cakir (Kalkavan/Palabiyik)Chelsea-Ajax: Rocchi (Valeri/Giallatini)Valencia-Lille: Karasev (Orsato/Fabbri)PSG-Brugge: Raczkowski (Gil/Kwiatkowski)Real-Galatasaray: Zwayer (Stegemann/Siebert)Red Star-Tottenham: del Cerro Grande (Sanchez/Martinez)Bayern-Olympiakos: Buquet (Letexier/Schneider)Zagreb-Donetsk: Brych (Dankert/Fritz)Atalanta-Manchester: Kulbakov (Soares Dias/Pinheiro)Leverkusen-Atletico: Oliver (Tierney/Kavanagh)Lokomotiv-Juventus: Skomina (Makkelie/Vincic)
I am only not sure about Kuipers as he had Dortmund-Slavia in MD2, everything else seems like resonable appointments.
Yes, I missed that somehow. Then I would swap him with Cakir.
I don't expect Zwayer on such a big game. He is too friendly (soft) in his personality. Real-Gala requires a referee with a stronger personality.
Turpin in Group G with Lyon doesn't seem reasonable, if you ask me.
But the same already happened with Zwayer in group D and Valeri in group E on MD3.And Marciniak and Turpin worked together at the WC, that's why I paired them (there are not enough Polish VARs, if Raczkowski is also appointed in CL, because Frankowski is at the U17WC).
Mine are :Napoli-Salzburg: SkominaLiverpool-Genk: Stieler Dortmund-Inter: CakirBarcelona-Slavia: GözübüyükZenit-Leipzig: KulbakovLyon-Benfica: RocchiChelsea-Ajax: MarciniakValencia-Lille: RaczkowskiPSG-Brugge: MassaReal-Galatasaray: BrychRed Star-Tottenham: KuipersBayern-Olympiakos: Del CerroZagreb-Donetsk: BuquetAtalanta-Manchester: KarasevLeverkusen-Atletico: OliverLokomotiv-Juventus: Kassai
Can anyone explain me any reasoning behind that penalty decision:https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7napwk
The referee made a 100% mistake.
Could you somehow justify that penalty?I tried but if anything I can see defender sticking his leg out( nowhere near the ball), while attacker moving into direction of defender leg and suddenly going down.Is it not rather "dive" when attacking player initiates the contact in attempt to deceive a referee???
OTOn 9 November 2019, the women’s friendly between England and Germany will be played at Wembley Stadium. The stadium will be sold out, marking the highest attendance ever for a women’s football match. This is the referee appointment:ENGLAND - GERMANYReferee: Stéphanie Frappart (FRA)Assistant Referee 1: Manuela Nicolosi (FRA)Assistant Referee 2: Michelle O’Neill (IRL)Promotion to Ligue 1, Women’s World Cup Final, UEFA Super Cup, refereeing a world record match in front of 90,000 people: what a year it has been for Stéphanie and her team!Source: FFF
Are you sure that those approximately 90,000 spectators will mark the highest attendance ever for a women's football match? I remember, for instance, the women's World Cup final 20 years ago in the United States in front of a comparable audience.
At least that’s what’s been reported via many news channels, I based myself on that (or I might have picked up sth wrong).At least, I can be sure about the referee appointment. :D
The Women's World Cup Final 1999 is reported to have been attended by 90,185 spectators. The Wembley Stadion is reported to have a capacity of "just" 90,000 spectators with a record attendance of "just" 89,874 spectators so far. ;-) Sources:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_FIFA_Women%27s_World_Cup#Finalhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wembley_Stadium
Chile - Korea RepublicReferee: Georgi Kabakov (BUL)Assistant Referee 1: Martin Margaritov (BUL)Assistant Referee 2: Diyan Valkov (BUL)Fourth Official: Ivo Nigel Méndez Chávez (BOL)Video Assistant Referee: Dennis Higler (NED)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Luís Miguel Branco Godinho (POR)Haiti - FranceReferee: Nick Waldron (NZL)Assistant Referee 1: Isaac Trevis (NZL)Assistant Referee 2: Jeremy Garae (VAN)Fourth Official: Juan Gabriel Calderon (CRC)Video Assistant Referee: Craig Pawson (ENG)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Drew Fischer (CAN)Senegal - JapanReferee: Claudia Umpierrez (URU)Assistant Referee 1: Luciana Mascaraña (URU)Assistant Referee 2: Monica Amboya (ECU)Fourth Official: Ko Hyung-jin (KOR)umVideo Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Quetzalli Alvarado (MEX)Netherlands - United StatesReferee: Amin Mohamed (EGY)Assistant Referee 1: Attia Amsaaed (LBY)Assistant Referee 2: Mohammed Ibrahim (SDN)Fourth Official: Edina Alves Batista (BRA)Video Assistant Referee: Abdulla Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Yaquob Al-Hammadi (UAE)
ATALANTA – CAGLIARI h. 12.30ABISSOCOLAROSSI – DI IORIOIV: RAPUANOVAR: ORSATOAVAR: DI PAOLOBOLOGNA – INTER Sabato 02/11 h. 18.00LA PENNAPASSERI – CECCONIIV: MARINELLIVAR: VALERIAVAR: DEL GIOVANEFIORENTINA – PARMA h. 18.00PAIRETTOVIVENZI – VECCHIIV: PRONTERAVAR: FABBRIAVAR: VALERIANIGENOA – UDINESEPASQUAMONDIN – BACCINIIV: MAGGIONIVAR: NASCAAVAR: BINDONIH. VERONA – BRESCIAMARIANIFIORITO – SCHENONEIV: SERRAVAR: MASSAAVAR: GALETTOLECCE – SASSUOLOROSRANGHETTI – GORIIV: GIUAVAR: BANTIAVAR: LONGOMILAN – LAZIO h. 20.45CALVARESECOSTANZO – ALASSIOIV: SACCHIVAR: MANGANIELLOAVAR: PAGANESSIROMA – NAPOLI Sabato 02/11 h. 15.00ROCCHIMELI – PERETTIIV: ABBATTISTAVAR: AURELIANOAVAR: LO CICEROSPAL – SAMPDORIA Lunedì 04/11 h. 20.45CHIFFILIBERTI – CAPALDOIV: MINELLIVAR: PICCININIAVAR: PRETITORINO – JUVENTUS Sabato 02/11 h. 20.45DOVERIGIALLATINI – TEGONIIV: GUIDAVAR: MARESCAAVAR: CARBONE
Any more on Club World Cup 2019?
Ovidiu Alin Haţegan and Anastásios Sidirópoulos handled today's games in Saudi Pro League.
Argentina - TajikistanReferee: Redouane Jiyed (MAR)Assistant Referee 1: Lahcen Azgaou (MAR)Assistant Referee 2: Mustapha Akarkad (MAR)Fourth Official: Ko Hyung-jin (KOR)Video Assistant Referee: Armando Villarreal (USA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Quetzalli Alvarado (MEX)Cameroon - SpainReferee: Adonais Escobedo (MEX)Assistant Referee 1: William Arrieta (CRC)Assistant Referee 2: Michael Barwegen (CAN)Fourth Official: Mario Alberto Díaz de Vivar Bogado (PAR)umVideo Assistant Referee: Marco Di Bello (ITA)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Hiroyuki Kimura (JPN)Mexico - Solomon IslandsReferee: Andres Rojas (COL)Assistant Referee 1: Dionisio Ruiz (COL)Assistant Referee 2: John Alexander Leon (COL)Fourth Official: Ivo Nigel Méndez Chávez (BOL)Video Assistant Referee: Ricardo de Burgos Bengoetxea (ESP)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Piero Daniel Maza Gómez (CHI)Italy - ParaguayReferee: Khamis Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Referee 1: Mohammad Dharman (QAT)Assistant Referee 2: Ramzan Al-Naemi (QAT)Fourth Official: Peter Waweru (KEN)Video Assistant Referee: Abdulla Al-Marri (QAT)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Yaquob Al-Hammadi (UAE)
MA Ning and the VAR. Terrible what he made in this WC. 2 rejected penalty in 2 games in this tournament after OFR.https://www.facebook.com/392016870930528/videos/2445875119020759/Hungary-Ecuador. His performance is weak. IMO he will left the tournament. In the first half he awrded a penalty for Ecuador and shown YC, but after OFR cancelled. And during the game his foul line is terrible too. Not a FIFA referee category in my view.
Video has been removed from facebook. Do you have another video of the annulled penalty in first half?
Raound 16Angola - Korea RepublicReferee: Srđan Jovanović (SRB)Assistant Referee 1: Uroš Stojković (SRB)Assistant Referee 2: Milan Mihajlović (SRB)Fourth Official: Nick Waldron (NZL)Fifth Official : Isaac Trevis (NZL)Video Assistant Referee: Bibiana Steinhaus (GER)Assistant Video Assistant Referee: Bartosz Frankowski (POL)Nigeria - NetherlandsReferee: Mario Escobar (GUA)Assistant Referee 1: Humberto Panjoj (GUA)Assistant Referee 2: Nicholas Andersson (JAM)Fourth Official: Adonais Escobedo (MEX)Fifth Official : William Arrieta (CRC)umVideo Assistant Referee: Drew Fischer (CAN)Assistant Video Assistant Referee : Craig Pawson (ENG)
liga365liga365 victorialink alternatif liga365liga365 wijayaliga365 benualiga365 alternatifalamat alternatif liga365liga365 me mainwww liga365liga365 tidak bisa dibukavictoria liga365gemilang liga365liga365 link alternatifliga365 melink liga365liga365 betliga365 mobilewww1 liga365 orgliga365 loginliga365 victoria365alternatif liga365liga365 versi androidliga365 pusat judi bolawap liga365lg 3658 liga365 me public validatem. liga365. melg3653 liga365 me public validateliga365 headerliga365 orgsitus alternatif liga365mobile liga365
berkah3657meterby 7meter7meter link alternatif7meter 4u7meter bet link alternatif7meter judi bolalink alternatif 7meterlink 7meter7meter link7meter mobile7meter chatwap 7meterlive chat 7meter7meter wap7meter poker7meter bolalivescore 7meter7meter headerwww 7meter7meter livescorealternatif 7meterpoker 7meter7meter live chat7meter prediksi7meter androidbuka kunci 7meter7meter.cara daftar 7meterprediksi 7meter7meter live scoredaftar 7meter7meter alternatif7meter default7meter bizcinta 7metercara deposit 7meterprediksi bola 7meter
Berkah365Berkah 365liga Berkah365link alternatif Berkah365live chat Berkah365Berkah365 seoBerkah365 asialogin Berkah365link Berkah365dunia Berkah365Berkah365 link alternatifking Berkah365Berkah365 alternatiflive Berkah365Berkah365 mobileberita Berkah365Berkah365 asia mainBerkah365 playsitus link Berkah365bola Berkah365cara main Berkah365Berkah365 livcatBerkah365 loginkontes seo Berkah365Berkah365 asia.comarena Berkah365Berkah365 chatwww Berkah365 asia default 41 aspxBerkah365 info default 41situs alternatif Berkah365Berkah365 sabung ayamBerkah365 forumdownload Berkah365logo Berkah365daftar Berkah365poker Berkah365Berkah365 infositus agen judi bandar bola dan casino online terpercaya - Berkah365situs Berkah365cs Berkah365Berkah365 betsitus judi bola Berkah365bola Berkah365 asiacara daftar Berkah365Berkah365 pokerBerkah365 netBerkah365 default 41Berkah365 live chathttp://berkah365vip.com/https://bit.ly/35a1q1k
12Nagaagen judi bolaagen judi bola terpercayadaftar agen judi bola resmiagen judi bola onlineagen judi bola terbaik dan terpercayacara main judi online bolaagen judi bola terbaikliga Berkah365link alternatif Berkah365live chat Berkah365Berkah365 seoBerkah365 asialogin Berkah365link Berkah365dunia Berkah365Berkah365 link alternatifking Berkah365Berkah365 alternatiflive Berkah365Berkah365 mobileberita Berkah365Berkah365 asia mainBerkah365situs link Berkah365judi kasino onlinecheat menang judi kasinoakun judi kasinositus judi kasino resmi dan terpercayajudi bola minimal bet 1000 lapak judi kasino
judi dingdong onlinejudi online tanpa deposit awalwebsite judi onlineapp judi onlinejudi online capsa susuncheat judi onlinecapsa susun judi onlinepermainan judi dadu onlinem88 judi onlinejudi dadu online androidjudi kartu capsa onlinejudi bola online m88situs judi bola online terbesarjudi online qiuqiusitus judi online resmijudi qiuqiu onlineaplikasi judi bola onlinejudi bola online terbesarsitus judi online terbarusitus judi gaple onlinejudi online kiu kiuslot judi onlinesitus judi online dominojudi capsa onlinetrik menang judi onlinealamat judi onlinesitus judi online terbesarjudi online ditangkapqjoker agen judi bandarq poker dominoqq capsa aduq online indonesiasitus resmi judi onlinejudi online terlengkapsitus judi dadu online terpercayapoker online judijudi pulsa onlinepermainan judi onlinejudi rolet online terpercayabandar agen taruhan judi bola sbobet online